conflict of  family two generations old mother and adult daughter

...

Darlin Tillery

By Darlin Tillery

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A mother’s decision to refuse her 21-year-old daughter’s demand for the largest bedroom in her home has stoked strong reactions online, with many backing her stance and urging the young woman to accept the living arrangement offered.

Reddit user Ok_Occasion_6988 explained that her adult daughter asked to move back in after being told she was no longer welcome at her father and stepmother’s home.

While the daughter said she wanted to be closer to friends, the mother wrote that the real reason was that her stepmother had “cut her off due to her behavior” and that her father told her “she was not welcome in their house.”

Read More on Life

Daughter's Demand

The mom agreed to let her return, but said space was limited. She now lives with her husband, his three children and their 2-year-old daughter. The largest bedroom belongs to her stepson.

Two other rooms are occupied by her stepdaughters, though one is temporarily away as an exchange student.

She told her daughter she could stay in the absent stepdaughter’s room for a few months or sleep on the couch while they worked out a long-term plan. The daughter objected and asked for the stepson’s larger room instead. The mother refused.

“I told her that under NO circumstances would I EVER kick out my stepson from his room because she ‘wanted’ it,” she wrote.

Stock image: A mother and adult daughter in disagreement.

...

The original poster's (OP) husband suggested that if the daughter wanted the room “so bad,” she could pay rent for it. The mother said her daughter responded by calling her by her first name and telling her she was not a good mother for refusing to force her stepson out.

The mom then told her she could remain with her father if she continued to insist.

More than 1,100 Reddit comments weighed in on the matter within six days. Many supported the mother’s position as a "reality" check.

"Your response and offer is perfectly reasonable," a backer reassured the OP, going further, "She's got a lot of growing up to do. What a brat."

A critic chipped in: “How does a 21 year old think they can make the rules and ask for anything they want when they are going to live on the streets if you say no.

"Maybe you need to relay that to her. Being homeless isn't fun.”

aitah choosing my stepson over my daughter and
r/AITAH

View this post on Reddit

The situation reflects a broader issue that can arise between parents and adult children living at home.

In a article for Psychology Today titled, “How to Deal With Disrespectful Adult Children,” Dr. Jeffrey Bernstein maintained that, "your adult child can't take away your grace, strength and dignity.”

He added that parents can say, “It’ll work better for both of us if you can say what you mean without saying it meanly,” according to Psychology Today.

Communicating Expectations

In a separate Psychology Today article, “Setting Win-Win Boundaries With Your Adult Child,” Bernstein wrote, “Parents may establish boundaries regarding living arrangements.

"They might set expectations for when and under what circumstances their adult children can continue living at home, or they may communicate expectations for contributing to household expenses if they choose to live with their parents,” according to the forum.

For the mother who posted, the dispute apparently remains unresolved. She made clear that the offer stands: a temporary bedroom arrangement or the couch. Otherwise, she wrote, her daughter can continue living with her father.

Newsweek has reached out to Ok_Occasion_6988 for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.

To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines