...
By Maria Morava
Relationships Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A woman's place in her boyfriend's family was made abundantly clear during his mother's birthday celebration.
In a viral Reddit post, the 27-year-old woman explained how she walked out of the dinner when the mother referred to her as a "hopefully temporary addition" to their family during a toast, especially after her boyfriend failed to defend her. Since the post was published, it has received 26,000 upvotes. Psychotherapist Francesca Harland spoke to Newsweek about the insult and whether or not the poster was justified in her reaction.
In the post, the woman shared that she had been dating her 30-year-old boyfriend for about a year and a half. While the relationship is serious enough for talk of moving in together, his mother has "never liked" her, treating her coldly despite her efforts to be polite.
Read More on Relationships
...
The situation came to a head, though, at the mother's birthday dinner which was planned by the boyfriend. The poster agreed to his request to cover half their portion of the bill, which was being split among the siblings. Then, it happened.
"Dinner's going well—until his mom raises a toast and says: 'I'm just so happy to be surrounded by family... and some of the newer, hopefully temporary additions.' Then she looks directly at me and smiles," she wrote. "The whole table laughed awkwardly."
The woman looked to her boyfriend for support, but he gave her a "please don't make a scene" face, she wrote. Feeling humiliated and unsupported, she excused herself while paying only her portion of the bill.
Afterwards, her boyfriend accused her of being "disrespectful," adding that his mother now viewed her as "dramatic and unstable."
Redditors rushed to the woman's defense.
"He should've said something if you were really in his heart. I wouldn't stand it. Made no sense to just sit there and be attacked," one user wrote.
"His mother only felt comfortable making such a brazenly outrageous comment because she knew he wouldn't stop her," another wrote. "She didn't even attempt to veil the disrespect."
An Expert Opinion
Harland, also a self-esteem specialist at FHPsychotherapy, analyzed the boyfriend's failure to intervene for Newsweek.
"At best, that he doesn't want to rock the boat with his family," Harland said. "At worst, that he doesn't understand or care about her feelings."
While some might label the girlfriend's exit as reactive, Harland found it justified: "I think the response was understandable, dignified even," she said.
She also suggested an alternative approach for handling such hostility directly.
"Personally, I'd always recommend confronting comments like this," she said. "A pause followed by a 'what an odd thing to say out loud, what exactly did you mean by temporary addition?' shifts the blame to those accountable. It allows others to feel awkward instead of you."
Newsweek reached out to u/Cute_Environment_515 for comment via Reddit.
If you have a family dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured on Newsweek.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines