
...

By Shane Croucher
Senior Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The reassurance about Senator Mitch McConnell came in relays as unsubstantiated rumors swirled online that the 84-year-old Kentucky Republican was “braindead.”
Americans, facing new proof of citizenship rules to vote, were left asking for proof of life for one of the nation's most influential lawmakers.
Emergency personnel went to McConnell's home on June 14, the day he was admitted, in response to an unconscious person, though the dispatch call that surfaced did not name the senator, and his team has not explained why he was hospitalized after a string of health concerns.
Read More on Analysis
Senate Republican leaders have since said they had held substantive phone conversations with McConnell while he remained hospitalized after collapsing. McConnell’s office said the former Senate majority leader was improving and working with staff.
The public does not need to review a senator's private chart from the end of their ward bed. But it does need something much sturdier than secondhand confidence delivered by their political allies and staff to show that their elected representative still has the capacity to serve.
As President Donald Trump presses Congress to make voters prove their citizenship, the democratic bargain has now acquired an awkward mirror reflecting back on the very politicians considering these more stringent rules for everyone else.
The governing class is demanding documents from the governed before they get to vote on who rules over them, while treating their own capacity to function as a closed-door matter for aides, allies, and party management.
The Asymmetry of Expectations
Trump is urging Congress to pass the SAVE America Act immediately, casting the bill as a measure to protect elections from illegal voting, and threatening to withhold his signature from other legislation until it passes.
Senate GOP leaders say they don’t have the numbers.
The House-passed version of S. 1383, approved February 11 by a 218-213 vote, would require documentary proof of U.S. citizenship for federal voter registration and valid physical photo identification to cast a ballot in person.
Mail voters would generally submit a copy of a photo ID or the last four digits of a Social Security number with an affidavit.
A February Harvard CAPS/Harris poll found 71 percent of registered voters supported the SAVE America Act as described in the survey. The National Conference of State Legislatures also says the bill would put Congress and many states inside a broader trend toward verifying that only U.S. citizens vote.
But existing federal law already requires voter registrants to attest to citizenship under penalty of perjury, and Brennan Center research has found suspected noncitizen voting to be vanishingly rare in studied jurisdictions.
The SAVE America Act would still move the burden from attestation to production of documents, and this is where the asymmetry between voters and their lawmakers appears.
Once politics embraces proof as a democratic obligation, it cannot plausibly stop at the polling place and apply only to the people.
It is true that registration proves eligibility against fixed criteria, while officeholders already answer to elections, expulsion and party pressure. But those remedies are slow, blunt and entirely discretionary—and, as the past month has shown, easily waved away.
A citizen who must produce a passport, birth certificate, naturalization paper, or qualifying ID to exercise one public power can reasonably expect elected officials to provide a credible public basis for a continuing ability to use theirs from a seat of power.
The Senate's Trust-Me Rule
Americans concerned about this issue will be agnostic about who is receiving the diagnosis. It should be one nonpartisan process for all.
Senate Majority Leader John Thune, Senate Republican Whip John Barrasso and former McConnell aide Scott Jennings went public within hours of one another with accounts of detailed conversations with McConnell after speculation about his health grew online.
McConnell's spokesperson said the senator was recovering in the hospital, continuing to improve and working with staff on Kentucky and Senate matters.
Those statements may be entirely accurate, but they are still the wrong system for delivering this kind of information. In fact, it’s not really a system at all. Verbal reassurance based on trust is far too informal.
The demand for daylight is not confined to the senator's critics alone.
"We need the truth about Mitch McConnell NOW," conservative commentator Glenn Beck posted this week, arguing that a party that spent four years scrutinizing Democratic President Joe Biden's health cannot credibly fall silent about one of its own.
Beck went further still. “What’s the difference between that and what Iran’s leaders are doing with the new Ayatollah?” he wrote.
“Is McConnell braindead? Or is he chatting about Graham Platner and Iran? It is OUR RIGHT to know. That seat isn’t McConnell’s. It belongs to the people of Kentucky.
“‘No taxation without representation’ was a great start. It’s time for ‘No legislation without representation.’"
Trump was asked if he had spoken with McConnell, during a press gaggle on Air Force One on Wednesday. He replied, "no." When asked how the senator was doing, Trump said, "I have no idea."
The stakes are high, as Beck suggests.
McConnell chairs the subcommittee that funds the Pentagon, and the full Appropriations Committee splits 15-14, meaning a single absent Republican lets the minority block bills in a markup.
Under Kentucky law, a vacancy before Aug. 3 would trigger a swift special election, while a later one would push the choice to November's ballot, a set of midterms in which the latter half of Trump’s presidency hangs in the balance.
Capacity, in other words, is not a private matter with only private consequences.
The Constitution has a presidential incapacity mechanism already.
Under the 25th Amendment, a president may voluntarily transfer power by written declaration, and the vice president acting with a Cabinet majority may declare the president unable to discharge the office's powers and duties.
Congress has no equivalent public process for an individual senator or representative who is seriously incapacitated, according to a Stanford Law Review essay on congressional incapacity.
Article I gives each chamber power over its rules, quorum, discipline and expulsion; none of that creates a routine capacity certification for a living member who remains in office during a medical crisis.
The result is a loose trust-me rule.
Staffers can say the member is working. Colleagues can say the calls were crisp. Rumor merchants can fill the vacuum with grotesque claims. Meanwhile, pity the public is left to choose between institutional opacity and online speculation.
A formal capacity process would shrink that space. It could avoid diagnosis, medication lists and humiliating detail. It could instead answer for voters, on the basis of verified proof, the only public question that matters.
Can this elected official discharge the duties that voters assigned to them?
An Age Limit?
An easy answer to all this is a maximum age for office, given the obvious associations between advanced age and a decline in physical and cognitive health. But that solution has its own flaws.
The Constitution sets minimum ages of 25 for House members, 30 for senators and 35 for presidents. Article I sets the House and Senate minimums, and Article II sets the presidential minimum. It sets no maximum age.
It is a design that leaves voters room to distinguish among individuals instead of treating a birthday as a determiner of someone's fitness for office.
Voters can handle that distinction. One 80-year-old may be sharp, physically steady and well-briefed; another may struggle to complete the job. A maximum age would punish capacity in the name of preventing incapacity.
And it would give Congress a convenient substitute for the harder work of telling the public the uncomfortable truth about a specific officeholder.
Recent history makes the partisan dodge impossible.
Biden withdrew from the 2024 presidential race after a confused June debate performance that confirmed serious doubts about his fitness for office, and escalated Democratic pressure on him to step aside.
The late California Democratic Senator Dianne Feinstein's final year brought a monthslong absence for shingles, a return in a wheelchair, and the development of encephalitis and Ramsay Hunt syndrome as complications from the illness.
Trump, now facing his own recurrent health scrutiny, from his cognitive abilities to bruising on his hands, had a White House physician's memo released in May saying he remained in excellent health after a Walter Reed exam.
Secrecy is not a Republican habit or a Democratic habit. It is an incumbent habit, and one that voters would like broken.
Privacy and Power
Health privacy, of course, is not a courtesy, but a humane norm we can and should all expect.
A public capacity standard could become a partisan weapon, especially in an era when edited clips, bad-faith speculation and medical illiteracy travel faster than records.
Congress should not turn illness into a spectacle. But that objection merely narrows the reform required, rather than defeating the case for it.
The public does not need to know whether a senator had a seizure, a cardiac episode, an infection, a medication complication, or something else entirely.
What the public does need is an accountable statement, from a defined and independent process rather than a political entourage, that the official can perform core duties.
The Stanford Law Review essay argued that congressional incapacity has received little legal attention despite democratic consequences, and proposed a constitutional amendment modeled in part on the 25th Amendment.
The essay's proposed design included temporary transfer of duties during short-term incapacity and an involuntary process, driven largely by state legislatures, for longer-term cases.
Perhaps that’s too elaborate for the immediate requirements, but the principle is sound.
Congress should establish a public trigger for serious, prolonged medical absence. It should require a capacity statement from an independent medical panel or the attending physician under uniform rules.
And then it should create a path, likely through constitutional amendment for lawmakers, for temporary representation when a member cannot serve and will not resign.
For the presidency, Congress already has authority under the 25th Amendment to create an "other body" for determinations of inability to serve. Why not one for its own chambers?
Turn on the Light
This is not anti-elderly or anti-the unwell. It is pro-democratic transparency.
A democracy that demands proof from voting citizens—a principle they agree with—should be able to demand hard evidence of capacity from officers who command armies, confirm judges, write budgets and decide whether constituents receive representation.
The SAVE America Act asks voters to treat proof as the price of trust in the system. But that principle cuts upward too.
The next time Washington asks for a birth certificate at the registration desk, voters should ask for something equally basic from Capitol Hill and the White House.
Proof of citizenship may decide who gets a ballot. Proof of capacity should decide who gets to keep wielding elected power. And no one should get to do it in the dark.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Anna Commander
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines