Matt Smith's Home

...

Giulia Carbonaro

By Giulia Carbonaro

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A hard rain was falling on Midland County, Michigan, on May 19, 2020, when tens of thousands of residents were told by authorities to evacuate the area out of fear that the overwhelmed Edenville Dam would release a wall of water over them.

That fateful day, the dam collapsed, releasing a torrent of floodwater that swallowed thousands of homes in the area, ripping some off their foundations while leaving others severely damaged, and overtopping the Sanford Dam.

Miraculously, no one died. But five years on, many of those who survived that tragic event are living in a sort of limbo as they try to get state regulators to take their part of the blame for the failure of the Edenville Dam.

Read More on News

Last month, a Michigan judge allowed their class action lawsuit against the state to finally move forward—pushing the justice they are seeking just within reach.

A Flood Wave That Flipped Their Lives Upside Down

Midland County residents Matt Smith and Bob Woods were among those forced to leave their beloved homes on May 19, 2020.

Smith had just bought his "dream home" on Sanford Lake a year before it was severely damaged by the dams' collapse. "We bought our dream home only to lose it a few months later, very unexpectedly," he told Newsweek.

Little-by-little, over the past five years, they have worked to bring their home back to what it used to be, a feat that cost them hundreds of thousands of dollars out of their personal savings.

"We have new docks being put in because we had three docks, two boats, all destroyed by the dam. And we've had to do seawall repair, landscaping repair. And then we also had to redo our house," Smith said. "Roughly, without looking at our spreadsheet, there was about $175,000 worth of damage inside."

Smith and his wife are now close to having their dream home back, "but I can tell you that again, being in my mid-50s, I would have loved to have that $175,000 in a retirement account rather than replacing what I already had."

Matt Smith's Home

...

Woods has lived in Midland County since 1972. When the dam collapsed, his home was in the way of the floodwater.

"We couldn't get back home because it was flooded. Our streets were flooded," he told Newsweek. "Our basement was completely flooded. We had over five feet of water in the basement."

The water, he said, had come in through the drain in the basement. "It did not come through any windows. It had to come through with a great force, because it flipped our freezer upside down, it was full of meat."

The floodwater "ruined everything from hot water heaters to air conditioners to heaters," Woods said. "Washer and dryer system, plus all the memorabilia that we had down there from my mother and dad. That stuff that can't be replaced, just because of what it was soaked in—sewage."

The total damage on his property, after insurance, was about $60,000-$65,000. But it is not just money that Woods and his family lost—there is also the emotional damage caused by what they went through. His wife, he said, thinks about the flood every time there are heavy rains in Midland County.

Bob Woods' Home

...

And while Smith and Woods could afford to repair their homes and stay in the area, many other residents affected by the dam's failure—a majority of whom lacked flood insurance—have been forced to sell.

Smith, who works as a real estate agent, witnessed how home values dropped in the county in the aftermath.

"Over the last five years, I've seen and heard every story and every heartbreak that you can imagine from people that are in their late 70s, early 80s, who had a place on the lake where they enjoyed grandkids coming to spend time with grandma and grandpa," he said. "They were forced to sell at a not very desirable price to try to move and find a different place somewhere so that they could continue to have that family place where family would gather at the lake."

'It Was Not Just a Serendipitous Event'

In 2023, the private owner of the Edenville Dam, Boyce Hydro's Lee Mueller, was found responsible by a federal judge for the collapse of the dam and the environmental damage caused to the area. His company was forced to pay nearly $120 million in damages.

The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy (EGLE) and the Department of Natural Resources (DNR), who had filed the lawsuit against Mueller, welcomed the judgement as a sign that those responsible for the collapse were being held accountable.

But residents who think that the two departments are also partially to blame for the collapse strongly disagree—and they are hoping the state will sooner or later compensate them for the damages suffered.

"The dam was not sufficiently stable to withstand the additional pressure from the rainfall and the water levels being too high," attorney Sharon Almonrode, who represents over 2,000 individuals who have filed lawsuits against the state, told Newsweek.

"It was not just a serendipitous event. That rainfall level had been experienced in the past; it was not beyond the control of the authorities in this case to lower the water levels instead of ordering them to be raised. It was something that was manageable," she added. "Yes, there was a lot of rainfall—but they had to anticipate that."

"They were given reports recommending to lower the water level before something like this happened, it's pretty well documented. But the choice was to leave the water the way it was," Smith said. "That makes it a hard pill to swallow for those of us who lost not only the structures, but five years of time with our families—it could have been avoided if they had heeded the warnings that were there."

For five years, survivors have sought damages from EGLE and DNR for allowing—and even encouraging—Boyce Hydro to raise the level of water in the dam beyond recommended levels.

But the state of Michigan has rejected any responsibility in the failure, attributing the collapse to "historic levels of rainfall."

Danny Wimmer, a spokesperson for the Michigan Department of Attorney General, which is representing EGLE and the DNR, told Newsweek that the failure of the Edenville Dam "was tragic, and the Attorney General sympathizes with those affected by the dam failure who suffered tremendous losses."

But the state of Michigan, he said, "was not responsible for the dam failure and we expect this litigation will not be successful as the plaintiffs do not have evidence to support their allegations. Conversely, the evidence in this matter confirms that the state agencies are not responsible for the dam's failure."

Edenville Dam Failure

...

An End in Sight?

On July 3, more than five years after the Edenville Dam failure, a Court of Claims judge in Michigan finally allowed a class action lawsuit from residents and businesses blaming state agencies for the tragic event to move forward.

In the lawsuit against EGLE and DNR, plaintiffs, including Smith and Woods, claim that the two departments were responsible for the collapse, as they ignored warnings about the dam's water levels.

"What we have is failing infrastructure that the state knew about for many, many years," attorney Dave Dubin, who represents the class side of the lawsuit, told Newsweek. "And when it fell underneath its jurisdiction, instead of following what Governor [Gretchen] Whitmer had been prioritizing, which was infrastructure, they overlooked a very key component, which is going to impact the lives and property of thousands of people."

The dam was "a ticking time bomb" when it fell to the authority of state regulators in 2018, Dubin said—and they did nothing to stop it from exploding over residents.

According to Dubin and the plaintiffs, the state forced the Edenville Dam's owner to maintain elevated water levels behind the dam, "prioritizing freshwater mussels that were living in the reservoir upstream of the dam over the property and people who lived downstream and around the lakes."

The agencies deny these claims. "The State spent over three years litigating this enforcement action against him and his business, and the Court ruled both that Mueller and his businesses were responsible for the dam catastrophe, while noting that dam ownership did not refute any of the State's evidence," Wimmer said.

"The State has already provided more than $200 million for the affected area. The appropriate venue for plaintiffs to seek additional financial relief would be the Legislature, through the budget process, not through the courts when the State is not responsible for their loss."

The case will be presented at trial on January 12, 2026—which means many more months of waiting for residents whose patience is running thing.

"I just think the whole thing could have been resolved in a different way," Woods said. "We've waited five years. Nothing's happened. It's a funny thing. Almost on day one, they were going to restructure those dams, rebuild the dams. Somehow, they got money to do all of that stuff," he added.

"But we as property owners that do not live on the lake, we're just individuals that don't matter. We have not got a penny back from the state, which to me caused this whole issue to begin with," Woods said. "It's become a political snowball, as you will. Let's push it out to somebody else and see how long we can prolong it. They've done a damn fine job within five years as far as I'm concerned. It's time that they fess up and pay the piper."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines