French riot police officers stand guard next to a burnt out trash bin during a demonstration against police in Marseille, southern France on July 1, 2023, after a fourth consecutive night of rioting in France over the killing of a teenager by police.

...

Newsweek Editors

By Newsweek Editors

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


María del Carmen Abascal had lived in the same apartment in Madrid’s Retiro neighborhood since 1956, when her father first rented it. In 2018, an investment fund bought the apartment and moved to end her rent-controlled lease.

She had been paying about €500 ($560) a month. The fund asked for €2,650, then €1,650, which was still more than the 87-year-old’s pension of around €1,350. On September 23, Abascal was carried out of her home on a stretcher while supporters outside chanted: "Maricarmen, you are not alone."

On September 26, tens of thousands of protesters marched in Madrid. On October 5, Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez called a snap election for November 29 after emergency housing measures were rejected in parliament, and within hours tens of thousands were marching in Barcelona too. Maricarmen had changed her country’s history.

Read More on Analysis

Spain is not alone. In France, a protest over unfilled teaching posts at the Saint-Exupéry high school in Créteil, outside Paris, began in mid-September and has spread across the country. By October, around a third of French high schools had been affected, with pupils protesting vacancies, overcrowding and dilapidated buildings.

The same day as the Madrid march, on September 26, the DGB trade-union federation in Germany said about 175,000 people had demonstrated in 15 cities against proposed changes affecting pensions, working hours and health care.

America is approaching the November 3 midterms amid its own argument about affordability, public services, immigration and the size of the state. In one poll, the cost of housing overtook food prices as the top political issue for young Americans.

To Americans accustomed to hearing Europe invoked either as a destination or a warning, the protests and riots offer a glimpse of what happens when generous promises meet housing shortages, aging populations and too few workers.

The Familiar Story

For the left, the European bargain is being broken. Spanish tenants want more safeguards, French pupils began protesting because schools lacked teachers, and German unions say workers are being asked to wave goodbye to social protections they have already earned.

"A strong economy is not created by dismantling social security and further increasing the burden on workers," DGB chief Yasmin Fahimi told a rally in Essen. "It is created by investment, by innovation, by good work and by good wages."

The right sees governments trying to regulate their way around shortages they have failed to solve. Spain’s center-right Partido Popular is calling for a change. "Housing does not get cheaper with decrees, it gets cheaper with more homes," Juan Bravo, the party’s deputy secretary told parliament.

This argument has an American echo. The Democratic Socialists of America’s platform calls for publicly owned social housing and universal rent control, alongside free public education and a publicly funded retirement. In New York, Mayor Zohran Mamdani has already secured a rent freeze for nearly 1 million rent-stabilized apartments.

What’s Really Going On

With fuel prices rising, continuing housing issues and other real pressures, Americans can still look at Europe and feel richer, because, on average, they are.

The OECD’s comparable wage figures for 2024, adjusted for purchasing power, put average annual U.S. wages at $82,933. Germany was at $69,433, France at $60,608, and Spain at $54,564.

That doesn’t tell the whole story. On housing, the comparison reverses. In the latest available figures in the OECD’s "housing cost overburden" series, 28.98 percent of U.S. households were overburdened. Spain’s was at 24.11 percent; France at 11.25 percent and Germany at 9.23 percent.

Like New York, though, Spain has a particularly acute supply problem. The Bank of Spain estimates the country has accumulated a shortfall of about 755,000 homes since 2021, a gap it expects to pass 1 million by 2028. Social rental housing makes up about 1.5 percent of the housing stock.

The Spanish tenants marching in Madrid and Barcelona are demanding a stock of public rental housing their country never built.

France’s demonstrations began with pupils demanding teachers. Measured against other university-educated workers, however, the United States has the more severe teacher-pay problem. OECD data published in September show that American lower-secondary teachers earn on average 37 percent less than full-time tertiary-educated workers. The gap in France is 10 percent, and in Germany just 4 percent.

Yet rank countries instead by the salary of a teacher with 15 years’ experience, adjusted for purchasing power, and the order changes: $111,804 in Germany, $78,231 in the United States, $77,440 in Spain and $54,778 in France. Germany pays its teachers extraordinarily well and France relatively poorly.

America pays a mid-career teacher roughly what Spain does, but with a much larger penalty relative to other careers that teacher might have taken.

Pensions are also not as simple as both supporters and critics of European systems sometimes say. For average earners, the OECD projects a gross pension replacement rate from mandatory schemes (the pension someone receives in retirement as a percentage of what they earned while working) of 39.7 percent in the United States, against 42.1 percent in Germany, 56.6 percent in France and 80.4 percent in Spain.

However, this comparison understates the American system because it excludes voluntary retirement saving. When the OECD includes voluntary private pensions, the U.S. replacement rate for an average earner rises to 74.8 percent—near the top of this comparison.

So European public systems promise more. But their demographics are also deteriorating faster.

In 2023, there were about 30 people aged 65 or older for every 100 working-age Americans. The OECD projects 45 by 2060. Germany goes from 38 to 60, France from 39 to 52, and Spain from 34 to 75. It means that Spain will have roughly three people of retirement age for every four people aged 20 to 64.

The United States has advantages that are easy to miss during an affordability crisis. Its average wages are substantially higher than those of Germany, France or Spain, and its demographic problem is projected to be milder. European welfare states promise more, but the people marching in Madrid, Créteil and Essen do not feel they are getting the better deal.

What the European protests expose is the difference between affordability and abundance. The first is about who can afford to pay for scarce things. The second is about whether enough of those things exist. That might be a real dividing line in the midterms.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines