LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA – MARCH 17: Maura Higgins attends Los Angeles Premiere Of A24’s “The Drama” at DGA Theater Complex on March 17, 2026 in Los Angeles, California.

...

Jenni Fink

By Jenni Fink

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Love Island and Traitors star Maura Higgins responded to an Instagram post claiming that she's in talks to be the next The Bachelorette, after ABC pulled the premiere of Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star Taylor Frankie Paul's season.

Paul's season, which was expected to deliver high ratings for the franchise, was yanked from the schedule just days before the premiere. ABC made the decision in light of a new video that was released of a violent altercation between her and her ex-boyfriend Dakota Mortensen. The season had already been filmed and edited, leaving ABC with a hole in their scheduled programming for the spring season.

DeuxMoi, an Instagram dedicated to celebrity news, posted on Instagram that an ABC executive said the franchise is looking into Higgins becoming the next Bachelorette and doing a live shoot of it, which they've never done before.

Read More on News

Higgins commented on the post with the eyeball emoji.

Who Is Maura Higgins?

Higgins, 35, is an Irish reality TV star who has quietly become one of the most bankable crossover personalities in unscripted television. Born in County Longford, Ireland, Higgins first rose to international fame in 2019 as a breakout contestant on Season 5 of Love Island UK, where her blunt humor, viral one‑liners and no‑nonsense dating style made her one of the show’s most memorable figures.

Since then, Higgins has managed what many reality stars fail to do: turn a single breakout season into a sustained, multi‑year television career. After Love Island, she became a regular presence on British TV, appearing on Dancing on Ice and I’m a Celebrity…Get Me Out of Here! before expanding her footprint in the U.S. market.

Most recently, Higgins appeared on The Traitors, where Higgins unfiltered commentary and partnership with fellow Love Island star Rob Rausch made her a fan favorite and introduced her to a much broader U.S. audience. Her Irish accent quickly became a viral meme and Higgins gained support from fans of the show after she believed so deeply that she and Rausch were about to win the show. However, Rausch, who was a traitor from the beginning, threw her for a loop when he revealed at the finale that he would be winning the show for successfully duping everyone else and she would be going home with nothing.

While the revelation was a lot for Higgins to take in the moment, the pair appeared to have made up by the time the reunion aired and she acknowledged that they were playing a game and Rausch played it well. Plus, Rausch did make good on his promise to buy Higgins a Birkin bag and while it's not $125,000, which is what Higgins would have won if Rausch was a faithful, it softens the blow.

Maura Higgins attends Los Angeles Premiere Of A24's "The Drama" at DGA Theater Complex on March 17, 2026 in Los Angeles, California.

...

Maura Higgins 'Love Island': What to Know About Her Season

Higgins entered Love Island UK as a late “bombshell” during Season 5, a year widely regarded as one of the franchise’s strongest eras. She arrived on Day 10 and immediately reshaped the villa’s dynamics, quickly becoming known for her direct confrontations and unapologetic approach to romance.

Over the course of the season, Higgins cycled through multiple romantic pairings before ultimately finishing in fourth place alongside professional dancer Curtis Pritchard. While she didn’t win the series, her cultural impact arguably outpaced the winners, with moments from her season still frequently resurfacing in Love Island highlight reels and memes years later.

What set Higgins apart was not just her screen presence, but her longevity. Unlike many contestants whose relevance fades after their season ends, Higgins remained deeply embedded in the Love Island ecosystem. She later returned to the franchise as a presenter, hosting Love Island USA: Aftersun and serving as a social media correspondent for multiple international spinoffs.

Why Was 'The Bachelorette' Canceled?

ABC abruptly canceled the upcoming season of The Bachelorette just days before it was scheduled to premiere, a highly unusual move for one of the network’s most established reality franchises. The season had already been filmed when the decision was made.

The cancellation followed the release of a previously unseen 2023 video published by TMZ that appeared to show Paul throwing metal chairs at Mortensen while one of her children was present. Shortly after the footage surfaced, Disney—ABC’s parent company—announced it would not move forward with the season “at this time,” saying its focus was on supporting those involved.

The decision came despite significant promotional investment. Billboard advertising had gone up, Paul had appeared on Good Morning America, and the show had been positioned as a ratings driver amid declining linear TV audiences. According to Forbes, canceling the already produced season likely cost the network tens of millions of dollars, but executives opted to protect the long‑term integrity of the franchise rather than air a season overshadowed by legal controversy.

While ABC’s statement stopped short of calling the season permanently canceled, as of now, no new premiere date has been announced, and ABC has not confirmed whether the footage will ever air.

The situation also impacted Paul’s Hulu series, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, which reportedly paused production amid ongoing investigations related to the same parties involved in the video.

“All of us right now are just trying to be like, ‘OK, we’re human beings first. Let’s figure that out and get back to filming the show,'” co-star Jessi Draper said on the Call Her Daddy podcast. “Clearly, there’s no shortage of drama in our lives. So if we get another season, it’s going to be good."

'The Bachelorette' Canceled: Will We Ever See Taylor Frankie Paul’s Season?

While chances that viewers ever get to see Paul's Bachelorette season seem slim right now, ABC's statement left the door open to the possibility that they could release it. ABC's comments didn't say they were permanently cancelling the season, just that they weren't moving forward with the new season "at this time."

Canceling the show could cost ABC tens of millions of dollars in lost production and advertising revenue, so if the smoke clears, it's possible Paul's season could still be released. Or, it could end up like Bravo's *Real Housewives Ultimate Girls Trip: Morocco ,*which wasn't released after an altercation between Brandi Glanville and Caroline Manzo. It's been a few years since that was pulled ahead of its released with no word as to whether it's official cancelled.

In the vacuum left by Paul’s canceled season, speculation has quickly shifted as to who could replace her as The Bachelorette. Some people pushed for Layla Taylor or Miranda McWhorter to take Paul's place, but it's unlikely ABC would recast the show with someone else from Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.

Higgins has not confirmed any formal talks, but her reaction to the post fueled further fan speculation. Whether Higgins ultimately accepts—or is even formally offered—the role remains unclear. But, reaction to rumors that she could be the next Bachelorette was met with approval from fans on social media.

In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.

When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines