
...

By Jasmine Laws
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The Environmental Working Group (EWG)'s Tap Water Database reveals which states have water utilities that serve residents drinking water with levels of arsenic above the legal level outlined by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
According to EWG's database, in 29 states, one or more water utilities have levels of arsenic higher than the EPA's maximum contaminant level (MCL) of 10 parts per billion (ppb)—the level which the agency deems legal and acceptable based on cost, feasibility and public health considerations.
"I’m not surprised that this many water utilities would need to treat their water for arsenic, but I am surprised that this many fail to do so," Charles Harvey, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at Massachusetts Institute of Technology, told Newsweek.
Read More on News
He added that arsenic concentrations above the EPA’s limit are "concerning," and that he "would not let [his] family drink water with these levels of arsenic."
Why It Matters
Arsenic is a natural element found in soils, sediments and groundwater that can feed into water systems. However, studies have unveiled the risk it poses to human health when consumed in drinking water—even at levels lower than the EPA's MCL.
The element is classified, and widely recognized, as a known human carcinogen, and chronic ingestion has been linked with lung, bladder, liver, kidney, and skin cancers as well as heart disease, diabetes and other health issues.
According to EWG, up to 600 out of every 1 million people could potentially develop cancer if they drink water contaminated with arsenic at the EPA's MCL of 10 ppb for their lifetime.
Concern about levels of arsenic in drinking water comes alongside worry about a host of other potentially harmful contaminants in America's drinking water.
What To Know
Out of the 29 states, as shown in the map above, the ones with the highest number of water utilities that have unlawful levels of arsenic in their drinking water supply are California, with 94 water utilities exceeding the limit, Texas (51), Washington (13) and Arizona (12).
The other states are Alaska (6), Colorado (1), Georgia (3), Idaho (9), Illinois (6), Iowa (6), Kansas (3), Louisiana (8), Maine (1), Massachusetts (1), Michigan (7), Minnesota (7), Mississippi (1), Montana (3), Nebraska (1), Nevada (9), New Mexico (9), New York (5), Ohio (1), Oklahoma (3), Oregon (7), South Dakota (1), Utah (5), Wisconsin (2) and Wyoming (2).
EWG data also shows that the state with the highest level of arsenic in its drinking water is California, with multiple water utilities having levels of arsenic more than triple the EPA's MCL, at 30 ppb and above.
California's Great Valley "has a lot of high arsenic and it is the smaller water utilities that serve low income communities that struggle the most as any type of remediation is expensive," Brian Mailloux, a research scientist in geochemistry at the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory at Columbia University, told Newsweek.
Previous studies have also identified inequalities in public drinking water—where levels of arsenic were found to be higher when serving more confined populations in the Southwest.
Other states with concentrations of arsenic above 30 ppb included Texas, New Mexico and Michigan.
"The states with some arsenic tendencies in water, and high numbers of systems," will have the most problems, Marc Edwards, a professor in civil and environmental engineering at Virginia Tech, told Newsweek.
When reviewing the data, he said it is important to consider that the higher number of utilities with unlawful levels of arsenic in California for example, could be in part a reflection on the higher number of water utilities more broadly.
In California, 94 out of its 2,843 water utilities had unlawful levels of arsenic in drinking water, which equates to 3.3 percent.
For Texas, the same calculation would suggest 1 percent of water utilities have unlawful levels of arsenic in drinking water supply, while for Arizona that same figure was 1.6 percent—so slightly higher than Texas, despite the fact the number of water utilities exceeding the legal limit is lower.
Using this method also meant that Nevada had a higher percentage of water utilities with unlawful levels of arsenic than California—at 4.7 percent.
Edwards also noted that most of the water utilities with arsenic problems served a small number of people—often 500 people or less each.
This means that if these smaller water utilities want to treat the water to remove arsenic, "it is very inefficient, and water bills would increase dramatically—in some cases 10 times or even more," he said.
"So some small systems are given a 'variance,' that allows them to not install centralized treatment, but to instead have [point of use] filters in the home that treat only the water used for cooking or drinking," he said.
He said that this is "much more cost effective," as rather than treating all the water used for bathing, showering, flushing toilets, watering lawns, only the water used for drinking or cooking is filtered.
"Having high arsenic in your water does not mean you are endangered, if you do not drink or cook with that water," he said.
What Happens Next
Mailloux said he is "always concerned" about drinking water with arsenic concentrations above the legal limit, but that methods now exist to reduce arsenic concentrations in drinking water well below the EPA's MCL.
Some states like New Jersey and New Hampshire have even lowered their legal limits to 5 ppb, rather than the EPA's 10 ppb.
However, he added that he thought the EPA "should be doing more" to tackle the issue, particularly as more and more data is "coming out saying the safe level needs to be lowered further."
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines