A kindergartner eats lunch

...

Robert Thorpe

By Robert Thorpe

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Proposed federal budget cuts could significantly impact school meal programs across the country, putting millions of children at risk of losing access to free and reduced-price meals.

Newsweek reached out to House Budget Committee Chairman Jodey Arrington via email for comment.

Why It Matters

The U.S. House has introduced a proposal to cut $12 billion from school meal programs, jeopardizing access for low-income students who rely on these meals daily. According to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP), school meal programs serve over 30 million children nationwide.

Read More on U.S.

Proponents of school meal programs argue reducing funding could increase food insecurity, disproportionately affecting students in high-need areas. However, critics argue there are millions of children from middle- and higher-income households receiving free meals at taxpayers' expense.

A kindergartner eats lunch

...

What to Know

The House Ways and Means Committee recently proposed a budget that would slash $12 billion from federally funded school meal programs. If passed, this reduction could eliminate access to free and reduced-price meals for thousands of schools currently benefiting from programs like the Community Eligibility Provision (CEP), which allows high-poverty schools to offer meals to all students without requiring individual applications.

According to the CBPP and the Food Research and Action Center (FRAC), over 24,000 schools that serve more than 12 million children could lose access to the CEP program. California faces the highest risk, with 4,091 schools that could lose access to free school meals. Other highly impacted states include Texas (1,711 schools), Florida (1,175 schools) and New York (1,784 schools).

The proposed cuts could also affect school districts' ability to provide quality meals, as funding reductions could lead to increased food costs, fewer meal options, and lower-quality ingredients. Schools in rural and urban high-poverty areas are particularly vulnerable, as they often depend more heavily on federal funding to sustain their meal programs.

If enacted, these cuts could force school districts to either find alternative funding sources or reduce the number of students eligible for free meals. Many districts do not have the financial flexibility to make up for these reductions, leaving students at risk.

Alexis Bylander, interim child nutrition programs & policy director for the Food Research & Action Center (FRAC) told Newsweek food insecurity undermines kids' ability to focus in the classroom and makes it harder for students to finish their education.

Critics of the CEP argue that the program's broad eligibility criteria lead to inefficiencies and unnecessary spending. Colleen Hroncich, policy analyst at the Cato Institute, told Newsweek millions of children don't need to receive free meals at taxpayer expense because they come from middle- and higher-income households.

"By increasing the threshold for community eligibility, policymakers can save billions of dollars while prioritizing those who need help the most," Hroncich said.

What People Are Saying

Alexis Bylander, interim child nutrition programs & policy director for the Food Research & Action Center (FRAC), told Newsweek: "Lawmakers proposing cuts to community eligibility are failing to see the big picture. Food insecurity can have serious and lasting consequences for children. It undermines their ability to focus while in the classroom, contributes to social and emotional behavior, impairs their health and development, and makes it even harder for them to complete their education.

We can't ensure a strong, prosperous nation for our children if we're cutting programs that directly support their success. Congress needs to prioritize the well-being of our nation's children and oppose any cuts to school meals."

Colleen Hroncich, policy analyst at the Cato Institute, told Newsweek: "The National School Lunch Program is good evidence of the adage that there's no such thing as a free lunch. In 2023, taxpayers spent more than $17 billion on the program—more than $28 billion when breakfasts and other aspects are included. The program was created to feed students from low-income families. But in 2010 it was expanded under the 'Community Eligibility Provision' to allow all students in 'low-income' schools to receive free meals.

Currently, just 25 percent of students need to meet the lunch program's income eligibility for the school to qualify under CEP. This means a school where 75 percent of students do not meet the income eligibility would still be able to provide a "free" lunch to all students. The Food Research & Action Center has found half of all schools in the school lunch program are now using this provision. Under CEP, millions of children from middle- and higher-income households are potentially receiving free meals at taxpayer expense.

There are many problems with the National School Lunch Program, but forcing taxpayers to buy school lunches for wealthy children is one of the most egregious. By increasing the threshold for community eligibility, policymakers can save billions of dollars while prioritizing those who need help the most."

Alex Beene, financial literacy instructor for the University of Tennessee at Martin, told Newsweek: "How these cuts will be presented is through the lens of a need to verify the income levels of families currently receiving free breakfast and lunch in these schools to ensure federal funding isn't being wasted on those who wouldn't qualify. And while that step sounds good in theory, the reality is notoriously difficult to obtain paperwork on the income of every single student's family.

Multiple federal and state government programs have struggled to get individuals and families who qualify for benefits to enroll just because of a complicated application process. Multiplying that by thousands and forcing schools to manage all that data in order to simply requalify for school nutrition programs could be a disaster in the making, as well as cut off perhaps the only meals some of these students receive each day."

What Happens Next

The proposed budget cuts are currently under review by Congress, following the House of Representatives' passage of a budget resolution directing the Education and Workforce Committee to identify $330 billion in program cuts, which could include reductions in school meal funding. Debate is expected to intensify in the coming weeks as lawmakers and advocacy groups push back against potential threats to child nutrition programs.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines