Newsweek map showing which metros have seen some of the steepest falls their under-5 shares of the total population.

...

Jordan King

By Jordan King

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The proportion of young children in communities is falling in many places across the United States, but new data reveals that metros in the west are experiencing the steepest declines in birth rates.

Metros in Utah, Colorado and Nevada are among those facing the starkest drops in their under-5 shares of the total population, according to new analysis from the housing market data site Realtor.com published on New Year’s Day.

Population demographics are shifting across the country, and the world. America’s fertility rate is now an average of just 1.6 births per woman in 2024, far below the replacement rate of 2.1 needed to maintain a stable population without immigration.

Read More

At the same time, people are living longer with the average life expectancy for women currently 82.5 years and for men 77.7 years, according to the latest Census Bureau projections. This is up from 81 years and 76 years respectively in 2010, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

This dynamic is leading to significant shifts in the population - Newsweek has mapped out how this combination is showing up in different places.

Why it Matters

The accelerated decline in birth rates is reshaping the nation’s age profile and promises long-term ripple effects. With fewer children born, the proportion of older Americans rises, creating potential strains on the labor market, health care, and social security systems.

Lower birth rates can sometimes ease immediate pressure on housing and schools, but also lead to challenges in supporting economic growth and elder care, as the ratio of working adults to retirees declines.

It is also important to note that the places with the sharpest declines in the under-5 shares of the total population may not necessarily be just because fewer children are being born – some places will be attracting more working-age adults, pushing the under-5 share down even if the number of young children has stayed the same or dipped only slightly.

What To Know

Utah

Utah has experienced five of the steepest drops in its share of the under-5 population between 2010 and 2024, Logan, Ogden, Provo and St. George dipping by 3.2 percent, followed by Salt Lake City with a 3.1 percent drop.

Realtor.com analysts note that these metros had some of the highest under-5 shares in 2010, averaging 9.8 percent, so this will have contributed to how high the drop looks.

There are multiple unique parts at play in Utah, a state where people have consistently had more children than the rest of the country for the last 50 years, which demographers link to its religious sector, with 50 percent identifying as Latter-day Saints, according to the Pew Research Center’s Religious Landscape Study.

“The Church has a primary focus on the importance of families in its theology and practices, which means that a majority of residents have those same values,” Utah Women and Leadership Project (UWLP) founder Susan R. Madsen previously told Newsweek.

“The importance of families is central to the doctrine and teachings of the Church. One of the most unique teachings in the Church is that families can be sealed in temples for eternity,” she said.

Last October, she authored a report showing that the longstanding gap between Utah’s births and the rest of the country’s has narrowed since 2010, showing “Utahns are not immune” to the changes affecting birth rates everywhere, Madsen said.

The birth rate decline is a complex topic with no single cause but major cultural shifts and financial challenges in the aftermath of the 2008 crash are usually cited as the reasons—Newsweek has broken down the main causes being discussed in detail here.

While Madsen argues that the Latter-day Saints church teachings about “rearing their children in righteousness is stronger than in any other religion,” analysis by the Institute for Family Studies shows a connection between religion and births, finding that fertility rates among weekly-attending religious Americans have never dropped much below 2 children per woman. Newsweek has covered this in depth here.

Other Drops

Other metros showing steep drops include Colorado’s Grand Junction (3 percent drop), Nevada’s Carson City (2.6 percent drop), New Mexico’s Farmington (2.6 percent drop) and Idaho’s Pocatello (2.5 percent drop).

Realtor.com’s senior advisor Allaire Conte wrote that these figures may have been diluted by the cities becoming “landing spots for retirees and lifestyle-motivated movers—people drawn to mountain views, lower housing costs, or tax advantages.”

What People Are Saying

Phillip B. Levine, an economist from Wellesley College in Massachusetts previously told Newsweek: "Policies like parental leave, child care subsidies, baby bonuses, etc, are much easier to implement and have the potential to affect fertility more rapidly, if they were effective. Changing the social conditions that encourage family formation is more difficult and takes longer to accomplish.”

Beth Jarosz, a senior program director of U.S. programs at the Population Reference Bureau, previously told Newsweek: "A primary risk, as a population ages, is under-investment in children. As children make up an increasing share of the population, there will be increasing pressure on them to be healthy and productive. But as populations age, there may be pressure to invest more in senior-supporting programs than in child-supporting ones."

What Happens Next

Congressional Budget Office and Census Bureau projections indicate the fertility rate will remain below replacement for decades, falling to 1.55 by 2100.

Whether the change in population demographics in these places changes things like investment and government priorities remain to be seen.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines