

By Aliss Higham
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Student loan debt remains a significant financial pressure point across the United States, but its impact is not evenly felt. New data from WalletHub examining more than 2,500 cities has found some communities are facing far heavier burdens when compared to their income.
At a national level, the scale of student borrowing is substantial. The United States currently holds around $1.8 trillion in outstanding student loan debt, combining federal and private loans. That figure has climbed steeply from some $520 billion in 2006, a more than threefold increase in under two decades.
Around 42 to 43 million Americans hold federal student loans, or roughly one in six adults in the country. The average federal borrower owes about $39,500 to $40,000, rising to roughly $43,000 when private loans are included. Federal loans make up about 90 percent of all student debt, totalling around $1.7 trillion.
Read More on News
About 10 percent of federal student loan dollars are currently in delinquency. Following the end of pandemic-era payment pauses, millions of borrowers have fallen behind or entered default, with estimates suggesting several million new defaults in the most recent reporting period. Overall, student debt has more than tripled since the mid-2000s, with repayment strain increasing as collections resumed.
Which Cities Have The Worst Student Debt Burden?
Against the national backdrop, new city-level data shows how unevenly the burden is distributed. To find the cities where student loan debt is the biggest burden, WalletHub compared the typical student loan balance in 2,520 U.S. cities with the median income of adults aged 25 and older who have a bachelor’s degree to find a debt-to-income ratio.
The rankings are:
- Ashtabula, Ohio — 78.08%
- Orangeburg, South Carolina — 74.35%
- Loma Linda, California — 73.87%
- Laguna Woods, California — 71.83%
- Rolla, Missouri — 68.06%
- Ashland, Oregon — 66.36%
- Murrells Inlet, South Carolina — 66.08%
- Lafayette, Indiana — 66.07%
- Milledgeville, Georgia — 65.90%
- Sun City, Arizona — 65.08%
- Henderson, North Carolina — 65.07%
- Ridgeland, Mississippi — 64.93%
- Lithonia, Georgia — 64.81%
- Walterboro, South Carolina — 64.52%
- Sun City West, Arizona — 64.38%
- Green Valley, Arizona — 63.85%
- Talladega, Alabama — 63.54%
- Adrian, Michigan — 63.19%
- The Villages, Florida — 61.85%
- Ithaca, New York — 61.71%
- Morgantown, West Virginia — 61.45%
- Ruston, Louisiana — 60.96%
- Bastrop, Louisiana — 60.40%
- Berea, Kentucky — 59.84%
- Natchez, Mississippi — 59.56%
- Ladson, South Carolina — 59.17%
- Elizabeth City, North Carolina — 59.09%
- Union City, Georgia — 58.67%
- Avon Park, Florida — 58.66%
- Westwego, Louisiana — 58.37%
Trump Administration Overhauls
The data comes amid significant changes to federal student loan policy under the Trump administration as it restructures the repayment system and tightens borrowing rules.
A major overhaul of income-driven repayment (IDR) plans is currently underway. Existing options—including SAVE, PAYE, and ICR—are being phased out or eliminated. In their place, a single income-based plan, the Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP), will be introduced for most new borrowers starting in July 2026.
Under RAP, monthly payments will be tied to income at roughly 1 to 10 percent depending on earnings, with repayment periods extending up to 30 years before forgiveness becomes available. For many borrowers, the shift is expected to mean fewer repayment choices and potentially higher monthly payments compared with previous plans.
From July 2026 onwards, new federal borrowers will generally be limited to two main options: a standard fixed repayment plan lasting 10 to 25 years, or the RAP income-based plan. Older income-driven plans will be phased out gradually.
Alongside repayment changes, borrowing limits are also being tightened. New federal caps are being introduced for student and parent borrowing, particularly affecting graduate loans and Parent PLUS loans. Graduate PLUS loans are being phased out entirely, while Parent PLUS loans will face annual and lifetime limits.
Ashtabula, Ohio
Ashtabula, Ohio ranks as the city where student loan debt weighs most heavily relative to income, according to WalletHub's analysis. The median student loan debt per person is $22,449, a figure that does not stand out nationally—it ranks 918th highest in the country.
For residents with at least a bachelor’s degree, the median annual income is just $28,750, which is the second-lowest in the United States. Because of this gap, Ashtabula has a student loan debt-to-income ratio of around 78.1 percent, more than double the national average of roughly 33 percent.
Orangeburg, South Carolina
Orangeburg, South Carolina has the second-highest student loan debt burden relative to income, with a ratio of about 74.4 percent.
Here, the median student loan debt is higher at $27,493, placing it among the more indebted cities nationally. At the same time, incomes remain comparatively low. Residents with at least a bachelor’s degree earn a median annual salary of $36,979, which ranks as the 23rd-lowest in the country.
Loma Linda, California
Loma Linda, California ranks third, with a student loan debt-to-income ratio of 73.9 percent.
Unlike the other two cities, Loma Linda’s position is driven largely by high borrowing levels. The median student loan debt reaches $42,025, which is the second-highest figure among more than 2,500 cities studied.
However, incomes do not fully offset that burden. Residents with at least a bachelor’s degree earn a median annual income of $56,892.
Rising Costs and Repayment Pressure
WalletHub analyst Chip Lupo pointed to long-term cost increases and financing conditions as key drivers of rising student debt.
He said: “College has become much more expensive over the past few decades, with cost increases far outpacing inflation. When you combine that with relatively high interest rates, it’s no wonder that the U.S. has so much student debt. Because of how expensive this debt can be, it’s ideal for students to live in a place where they can maximize their income and put as much money as possible toward finally paying off their education.”
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines