Man on phone with police.

...

Taylor McCloud

By Taylor McCloud

Staff Writer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Internet commenters rushed to the defense of one 25-year-old man whose patience was tested and ultimately broken after his brother, sister-in-law and infant son moved into his parents' home.

In a viral Reddit post published on r/AmITheA**hole, Redditor u/happily-single-dwarf said he was immediately forced out of his bedroom when the couple arrived and revealed how he was quickly transformed from family member to his sister-in-law's live-in assistant.

Titled, "[Am I the a**hole] for telling my [sister-in-law] that I will call the cops for child abandonment the moment she steps out of the house?" the post has received nearly 21,000 upvotes and 4,000 comments in the last day.

Read More

Neighbor Selling Misdelivered Items to Intended Recipient Stuns Internet4 min read

Neighbor Selling Misdelivered Items to Intended Recipient Stuns Internet

Family Member Praised for Using Spray Bottle to ‘Train’ Nephew6 min read

Family Member Praised for Using Spray Bottle to ‘Train’ Nephew

Mom-of-2 Only Helping Youngest Daughter Buy House Backed: ‘Entitled’5 min read

Mom-of-2 Only Helping Youngest Daughter Buy House Backed: ‘Entitled’

"It all started when 'Jack' and 'Jill' got pregnant," the original poster (or OP) began. "Their lease almost ended and my parents invited them to stay at our house."

Continuing to explain that he was moved to a guest bedroom, OP said it was abundantly clear there would be issues with the new living arrangement, a majority due to his sister-in-law's unrealistic expectations for around-the-clock assistance.

"I was told I must be more accommodating [because] she's pregnant," OP wrote. "She obviously [thought] I will be her personal maid."

After his nephew was born, [OP] said his new responsibilities were expanded to include a caretaker role—much to his dismay.

"I mostly keep [to] myself now. But that doesn't stop Jill [from asking] for favors," OP wrote. "It all came to a head last Friday when she asked me to watch my nephew while she goes to [the] pharmacy for baby formula.

"I refused. She got mad and we had a fight. She [grabbed] her purse to go anyway and I told her that the moment she walks out that door I will call the police for child abandonment," OP continued. "She broke down and screamed what a horrible human being I am.

"Jack accused me of hating Jill...[and] my parents told me enough is enough. That they can't believe they raised such a selfish human being," OP added. "I work from home and pay 50 [percent] of all household expenses...Jack and Jill don't contribute anything."

The last two-and-a-half years have been difficult for many in the U.S., including adults who moved out of their family's home just before the global pandemic, and adults who still live with their parents.

As a result of rising inflation rates, skyrocketing housing costs and myriad other financial hardships brought on by COVID-19, there are more adults living with their parents now than at any point during the last half-century.

Data published by Pew Research Center last year showed there were nearly 60 million U.S. residents living with multiple generations under one roof.

And while multigenerational living has grown steadily since the 1970s, the share of the U.S. population in multigenerational households has increased from 7 percent in 1971 to 18 percent in 2021.

The scenario described in the viral Reddit post is a perfect example of a multigenerational household.

With three generations of family members living under one roof, tension can seem unavoidable. However, when one of those generations is brand-new, and an infant is introduced into an already hostile household, tension is all but guaranteed.

"An infant changes the family dynamics in many ways," Amy Morin, Verywell Mind editor-in-chief and licensed psychotherapist, told Newsweek.

Because new parents' lives revolve around their infant, their ability to socialize and participate in outside activities will be severely diminished. They may also lean on family members in close proximity for assistance with their baby—sometimes to an unwelcome extent.

"It's important that extended family not feel as though they're being taken advantage of or feel as though the new parents are asking too much of them," Morin added. "A family member who feels exploited can have an upfront conversation with the new parents."

When those upfront conversations are rendered fruitless, it is imperative that disgruntled family members—like OP—set boundaries and stick to them.

"This family needs to set some boundaries," Susan Newman, Ph.D., social psychologist and author of Under One Roof Again: All Grown Up and (Re)Learning to Live Together Happily told Newsweek. "Particularly the son who seems to be meeting his sister-in-law and baby's needs.

"He can shore up his boundaries by...letting the family know he has a life beyond being at everyone's beck and call," Newman added. "If [he] does not take steps to protect himself, his resentment may build and tensions will rise."

Man on phone with police.

...

Throughout the viral post's comment section, many Redditors echoed that sentiment and encouraged OP to stand his ground, even if that means moving out of the house entirely.

"This sounds like a super s**tty situation in general," Redditor u/Andante79 wrote in the post's top comment, which has received more than 16,000 upvotes. "They pay nothing toward the house, and treat OP like s**t.

"I would not...be free in-house babysitting under any circumstances barring a genuine emergency," they continued. "[The] way they seem to treat you though, I can't say I'd blame you if you just refuse outright."

"OP is a paying tenant in this house," Redditor u/Unhappy-Coffee-1917 added, receiving nearly 8,000 upvotes. "He has NO obligation whatsoever to watch this child."

Redditor u/Cupcakefrosting2000, whose comment has received nearly 5,000 upvotes, offered a more pointed perspective, as well as a potential solution for OP.

"I don't think that you're an [a**hole] but you are a bit dramatic," they wrote. "So here's what you should do...move out and stop paying for everything...see how your family reacts when half of the money is gone."

"You're 25 years old...it's time to call their bluff," Redditor u/jimsmythee chimed in, receiving more than 4,000 upvotes. "It's time to tell them, 'Great news. I found my own place. I'll be moving there and I'll discontinue paying the bills here.'"

Newsweek reached out to u/happily-single-dwarf for comment. We are unable to verify the details of the case.

If you have a similar family dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured on Newsweek.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines