10
Loading video...

By Faisal Kutty
Lawyer and Law Professor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
For decades, unwavering U.S. support for Israel has been one of Washington's few bipartisan constants. But something unexpected is happening—and it's coming from inside Donald Trump's MAGA base.
Israel's devastating attack on Gaza, which has killed more than 62,000 Palestinians, including over 18,000 children, is exposing deep ideological fissures on the American Right. Populist MAGA figures who once offered reflexive support for Israel are now breaking ranks, challenging Republican orthodoxy and questioning why the U.S. continues to provide "blank checks" for a foreign war.
This isn't a progressive uprising, rooted in solidarity with Palestinian rights—it's a populist backlash against "globalist elites," endless foreign entanglements, and a perceived erosion of American identity. Yet the consequences could be profound—for the GOP, U.S. foreign policy, and the foundation of the U.S.-Israel relationship.
Read More
What’s the Cause of the Gaza Crisis—Hamas’ Tyranny or Israel’s Blockade? Newsweek Contributors Debate7 min read

Recognizing a Palestinian State Is Important but No Substitute for Ending the Atrocities in Gaza | Opinion5 min read

U.K., France Recognize Palestinian State—Will it Matter? Newsweek Writers Debate6 min read

The October 7 Hamas attack initially united the Right behind Israel, which framed its military campaign as a battle of "civilization against terror." But as images of bombed-out hospitals and starving children began to dominate social media, the mood shifted. Tucker Carlson—still one of MAGA's most influential voices despite his split from Fox News—stunned conservatives by blasting unconditional U.S. support. He stated that the U.S. should "drop Israel," criticized U.S. financial and military aid, and argued that deeper American involvement in Middle East conflicts is not in the country's best interest.
Carlson's critique reflects a broader MAGA sentiment. As Mondoweiss notes, Carlson frames U.S. aid to Israel not as a moral or strategic necessity but as an imposition by an unaccountable "elite," tapping into longstanding grievances about Washington's priorities and foreign influence. His very public clash with Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Tex.), who defended Israel on biblical grounds, symbolizes a generational shift. For many younger conservatives, scripture no longer dictates foreign policy. "America First" does.

...
Candace Owens—once one of Trump's most loyal media allies—has emerged as a sharp critic of U.S. support for Israel's war in Gaza. "I do not believe that American taxpayers should have to pay for Israel's wars or the wars of any other country," she wrote in March 2024. In November 2023 she was even more direct: "No government anywhere has a right to commit a genocide, ever." Her comments drew fire from traditional pro-Israel Republicans but electrified younger MAGA voters, many of whom increasingly see Israel as just another foreign lobby dictating U.S. priorities.
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.), a longtime MAGA firebrand, further escalated tensions when she became the first Republican in Congress to openly label Israel's conduct in Gaza a "genocide." In a July post on X, she wrote: "Every U.S. taxpayer is contributing to Israel's military actions.... I don't want to pay for genocide in a foreign country against a foreign people for a foreign war that I had nothing to do with. And I will not be silent about it."
The backlash was immediate and personal. Far-right activist Laura Loomer unleashed a barrage of slurs against Greene—calling her a "whore," a "degenerate," and questioning her faith—accusations that highlighted the growing fracture within the MAGA movement.
This clash reveals a deepening ideological divide in the GOP between an establishment wing shaped by evangelical Zionism and Cold War-era geopolitics, and a rising populist faction fixated on sovereignty, border control, and extricating the U.S. from "forever wars."
A seismic generational realignment is underway. A new Gallup survey found that only 32 percent of Americans approve of Israel's military actions in Gaza—a drop of ten points in less than a year—while 60 percent now disapprove. The divide is starkest among young people: just 9 percent of Americans under 35 back Israel's conduct, and a mere 6 percent view Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu favorably. Even among Republicans, the shift is visible: a Pew study earlier this year showed that half of Republicans under 50 now hold unfavorable views of Israel.
This isn't a passing mood swing—it reflects a paradigm shift in how Americans, particularly younger voters, see the war. For them, Gaza is not just a foreign policy issue. It is a mirror of America's values: whether tax dollars should underwrite what human rights groups have described as genocide, or whether sovereignty and ending "forever wars" should take precedence.
Since the Gaza war began, Washington has provided Israel with over $22 billion in military assistance. For many voters struggling with inflation and rising costs, these billions flowing overseas pose a question for the emerging "America First" foreign policy: should allies receive blank-check support, or should aid be conditional and transactional, tied only to clear benefits for Americans at home?
Israel senses the danger. It has ramped up outreach to MAGA influencers, funding all-expenses-paid tours for conservative commentators to rebuild support. But these efforts risk backfiring, feeding suspicions of "foreign influence operations"—a politically potent narrative in MAGA circles already primed to distrust elites.
For Donald Trump, the stakes couldn't be higher. His first term delivered historic wins for Israel—moving the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem, brokering the Abraham Accords, and providing billions in aid. But his base increasingly questions whether "America First" now means "Israel First." As one pro-Trump influencer put it bluntly: "We voted for America First. Not Israel First." Trump must decide whether to double down on old GOP orthodoxy or align with a base increasingly skeptical of foreign entanglements. It's a gamble that could reshape both his movement and U.S. foreign policy for years to come.
As Human Rights Watch has warned, U.S. credibility on human rights is already flagging due to selective outrage—condemning Hamas atrocities loudly while remaining muted on Israel's devastating response. A MAGA-Israel rift could force Washington to confront these double standards more directly. Remarkably, the one issue that once unified evangelicals, neoconservatives, and grassroots Republicans—unwavering support for Israel—is now fracturing. U.S. support for Israel is now openly debated across X, right-wing podcasts, and conservative talk shows.
This isn't just a foreign policy disagreement. It's an identity crisis for the American right. How it resolves could reshape not just the Republican Party, but the trajectory of U.S. global power itself.
Faisal Kutty is a Toronto-based lawyer, law professor, and frequent contributor to The Toronto Star.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines