
...

By Joshua Rhett Miller
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Luigi Mangione wants access to a laptop while in federal custody, but prosecutors object to the proposal, citing alleged witness threats in the high-profile slaying of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson.
Attorneys for Mangione, 26, filed a motion Friday seeking full discovery from the Manhattan District Attorney's Office as the accused killer prepares for trial for the December 4 fatal shooting of Thompson outside a hotel in New York City.
Mangione's attorneys also want a "specially formulated laptop" for their client while he's detained at Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn, according to the 14-page filing obtained by Newsweek.
Read More on U.S.
Federal prosecutors did not object to the request, but their Manhattan counterparts want to block the proposal, attorney Karen Friedman Agnifilo wrote in the filing made public late Monday by Mangione's legal team.

...
"Without the laptop, which allows Mr. Mangione to review discovery outside the presence of counsel, there are not enough visiting hours that would allow the defense to view all the discovery with the defendant (including thousands of hours of video) and also meet the court's current motion schedule," the filing said.
Attorneys for Mangione say they'll need to print out more than 15,000 pages of discovery for the accused murderer to keep in his cell pending his trial without the device. The D.A. balked at the proposal, citing the "sensitive nature of many of the documents and the threats that several witnesses have already received," according to the filing.
"Counsel notes that the District Attorney's Office has no basis to believe that Mr. Mangione has any connection to the alleged witness threats," the filing continued. "This is particularly true given that the prosecution has yet provided counsel with the names of any civilian witnesses or their information."
The alleged witness threats indicate that their identities have already been made public and that Mangione "had no part in disseminating their names," the filing continues.
Mangione's attorneys propose the laptop be configured to contain only non-sensitive and non-civilian-related discovery in his case, including grand jury testimony, body-worn camera footage, surveillance video, DNA evidence and fingerprint reports.

...
"This way, Mr. Mangione will be able to effectively review the 800 GB of discovery while also addressing the prosecutors' stated security concerns," the filing said. "Any civilian-related discovery would only be viewed by Mr. Mangione in counsel's presence."
The Manhattan District Attorney's Office will respond to the motion in a future filing, a spokeswoman told Newsweek early Tuesday.
Mangione, who remains held without bail, has pleaded not guilty to murder and related charges in New York. He's also facing federal charges of stalking and murder, which could lead to a death sentence upon conviction. In addition, the Maryland native faces forgery and firearms charges in Pennsylvania, where he was arrested on December 9.
Mangione's attorneys also claim New York City Mayor Eric Adams and law enforcement officials have leaked sensitive information in the case, including during television interviews and articles in newspaper and magazines, ultimately prejudicing his right to a fair trial.

...
Mangione's legal team also accused law enforcement officials of "consistently" leaking details of the case, including his alleged manifesto, as well as details contained in recent reports in New York and Rolling Stone magazines.
"Similarly, counsel learned for the first time last week via a Rolling Stone magazine article that a police sergeant in San Francisco had called the FBl's New York Office to inform them that the suspected shooter resembled the missing persons case he was working on relating to Mr. Mangione," the filing reads.
"Not only did we learn from a media report that this San Francisco detective proactively called the FBI, but he also leaked private information to the media regarding a bank withdrawal in August, as well as Mr. Mangione's confidential medical information."
Since Mangione is presumed innocent, the leaks are "not harmless" and information that future juries will ultimately learn due to significant Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment issues relating to his arrest and search, his attorneys insist.
"While evidence has been turned over to the media by law enforcement, Mr. Mangione still does not have all of the necessary evidence against him," the filing reads. "To date, the District Attorney's Office has not yet turned over the civilian witness testimony in the Grand Jury or a copy of the numerous electronic devices that law enforcement had seized from Mr. Mangione, including several USB flash drives, a computer chip, and a laptop."
The filing also noted that many other federal inmates at MDC get laptops to review discovery in their cases. The device's connections to the internet, printers, games and entertainment are disabled, attorneys said.
"There is no basis to treat Mr. Mangione differently just because, unlike other MDC inmates, he is facing pending indictments in three different jurisdictions," the filing reads.
Due to the discovery delay, attorneys for Mangione want an extension to file motions until June 26 to allow prosecutors time to produce the remaining grand jury testimony and to provide a copy of their client's seized electronic devices.
"This additional time will also allow counsel to resolve the discovery laptop issue with the District Attorney's Office or with the appropriate federal court," the filing said.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines