10

Loading video...

Anna Rahmanan

By Anna Rahmanan

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Luigi Mangione walked into federal court this month and admitted that he killed UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. Lindsay Clancy's trial began with even less mystery about the central fact: her lawyers do not dispute that she killed her three children.

In most murder cases, once there is little dispute over who killed the victim, public sympathy becomes harder to explain. Yet both Mangione and Clancy have drawn considerable sympathy even as the basic facts of what they did have become clearer. The reasons are very different: Mangione has described years of debilitating physical pain, while Clancy's defense says she was suffering from severe mental illness after childbirth.

The sympathy makes more sense when you look at what happened to each of them before the killings. Mangione's suffering unfolded inside a health-care and insurance system that many Americans already experience as expensive, frustrating and indifferent. Clancy's unfolded inside a mental-health system she repeatedly turned to for help before the deaths of her children. In both cases, the public is being asked to confront suffering that feels familiar before confronting a crime that does not.

Read More on News

To put it simply: people do not have to approve of what Mangione did to recognize anger at insurers or the fear of being trapped in chronic pain. They also don’t have to excuse what Clancy did to understand why a mother seeking psychiatric help again and again can evoke horror at the possibility that treatment was not enough. The sympathy comes from recognizing the suffering, even when the act that followed it remains unforgivable.

Mangione and Clancy therefore present a harder possibility: a person can commit an act we consider unforgivable while also having suffered terribly before committing it. Recognizing the second fact does not require denying the first.

Luigi Mangione’s Guilty Plea Changed Less Than Expected

By August 14, the evidence tying Mangione to Brian Thompson's killing was already extensive but his admission of guilt highlighted a larger truth about society.

The admission did not end the sympathy that has followed him since his arrest: supporters gathered outside the courthouse as he entered his plea, for example, and that reaction had been visible almost from the beginning. A December 2024 YouGov poll found Americans overall viewed Mangione negatively by more than two to one, while adults under 30 were roughly evenly divided between favorable and unfavorable views.

Related Story

The Price America Pays for Trump’s Reliance on Kushner the Closer

The Price America Pays for Trump’s Reliance on Kushner the Closer

Related Story

Why Cheap Innuendo About Trump’s ‘Natalie’ Is a Dead End for Democrats

Why Cheap Innuendo About Trump’s ‘Natalie’ Is a Dead End for Democrats

Related Story

Hayden Panettiere Didn’t Look Like America’s Idea of an Addict

Hayden Panettiere Didn’t Look Like America’s Idea of an Addict

Related Story

Everyone Was Chasing Jason Arday’s Shadow

Everyone Was Chasing Jason Arday’s Shadow

Some of that reaction is better understood as political approval than personal sympathy. Mangione's case became tied almost immediately to anger at insurers and the American health care system, which was hardly confined to the people cheering him outside a courthouse. In 2026, 61 percent of Americans told Gallup they worried a great deal about health care access and affordability.

None of that turns Thompson into a representative of every insurance denial or medical bill Americans resent, much less makes his killing a legitimate response to them, but the broader anger does help explain why Mangione's story found an audience already primed to recognize the grievance he described.

His own account adds the personal layer; In court, Mangione described years of severe pain after a back injury and his frustrations with the health care system before explaining how he chose his target.

The sympathy surrounding Mangione, then, is not necessarily a judgment that what he did was forgivable. For some people, it begins somewhere more familiar: they recognize the pain, the anger or the system he blamed for them, even while rejecting what he chose to do about it.

Lindsay Clancy Had Already Asked for Help

Clancy's case produces sympathy for a different reason: before she killed her children, she had already been asking for help.

According to evidence presented at trial, Clancy saw multiple mental health providers, was prescribed numerous psychiatric medications and admitted herself to an inpatient psychiatric program. Her defense says her condition deteriorated after the birth of her third child and that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis when she killed Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months old.

Prosecutors dispute that account and argue that Clancy understood what she was doing and planned the killings. The jury will decide whether her illness deprived her of criminal responsibility, but the sympathy surrounding Clancy does not depend entirely on that legal question. It also comes from something more recognizable: she sought treatment before the killings, saw doctors, took medication and entered a hospital, which is exactly what people are told to do when they are in psychiatric distress. Clancy's story raises the frightening possibility that someone can do those things and still become catastrophically ill and do something grotesque.

A Warning for the Broken Systems

Of course, this kind of sympathy may lead to a type of compassion that could slide into romanticization. Explanations may sound like excuses, which would be a dangerous disposition.

So both cases seem to ask what happens to sympathy once innocence is taken off the table. In each, the answer may lie partly in the fact that Americans already recognize the systems surrounding the suffering: an insurance industry many distrust, a health care system many find punishing, and a mental health system people are told to rely on when they are in crisis.

Once again, that recognition does not excuse what came next, but it does explain the sympathy that the characters have gathered. We can condemn what Mangione and Clancy did while recognizing—and even sharing—the anger, fear and helplessness that came before it.

If there is a warning here, it might be for the systems that Mangione and Clancy encountered before their crimes: too many Americans recognize the suffering that came first.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Gray R. Thomas

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines