10

Loading video...

Amanda Castro

By Amanda Castro

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Tuesday’s hearing in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial delivered some of the most dramatic and consequential testimony yet, with experts clashing over forensic evidence, new revelations about Clancy’s mental state and fresh scrutiny of the care she sought in the months before her children’s deaths.

A clinical psychologist described in detail the auditory hallucinations Clancy reported—including a male voice ordering her to kill her children and herself—while a forensic pathologist defended a head‑first fall reconstruction that prosecutors argued was inconsistent with the lack of visible head injuries.

The court also heard that Clancy was repeatedly turned away from crisis resources, including suicide hotlines and a postpartum program, deepening the defense’s argument that she was desperately seeking help as her condition deteriorated.

Read More on News

Here are the biggest bombshells from Tuesday’s hearing.

Psychosis claims, a fall‑injury clash and evidence she was turned away from multiple crisis services dominate Lindsay Clancy's hearing. (Jonathan Wiggs/The Boston Globe via AP, Pool)

...

1. Dr. Paul Zeizel says Clancy heard a male voice ordering her to kill her children and herself

Clinical and forensic psychologist Paul Zeizel gave the most striking testimony of the day, telling jurors that Clancy described hearing a male voice commanding her to kill her children and then herself. He said she believed her thoughts were so loud that strangers—including teachers at her children’s school—could hear them.

Zeizel explained that psychosis often involves intermittent symptoms, comparing auditory hallucinations to “waves at the beach.” He said Clancy experienced dissociation, depersonalization and “brain fog,” and that her mood “waxed and waned” in the months before the incident.

He emphasized that she showed no signs of malingering, calling her “an honest citizen.”

2. Psychologist let Clancy call her husband while she was cuffed to a hospital bed

Zeizel also revealed that he used his own cellphone to let Clancy call her husband, Patrick, while she was restrained at Brigham and Women’s Hospital under court order. He said she told Patrick she loved him and was confused, frightened and unsure where she was.

The moment is significant because prosecutors have suggested a doctor encouraged Clancy to fabricate hallucinations. Zeizel denied this outright, saying he allowed the call “out of human compassion” and never told her to “make up voices.”

He also testified that he has met with Clancy over 45 times, including at the courthouse lockup, to ensure she remains competent to stand trial.

3. Forensic pathologist’s fall reconstruction clashes with lack of head injuries

Forensic pathologist Elizabeth Laposata testified that Clancy fell head‑first from a second‑story window, causing a Jefferson fracture and severe spinal damage. She described the fall as a “free‑fall dive” onto frozen ground, with enough force to burst the C1 vertebra and compress the thoracic spine.

But prosecutors seized on a major contradiction: Despite what Laposata described as a high‑energy head‑first impact, Clancy had no external head injuries, no skull fracture, no brain bleed and no visible trauma in hospital photos. ADA Jennifer Sprague confronted her with images showing an intact scalp and no blood on the sheet beneath her head.

The exchange became one of the most contentious of the day, with the judge intervening as the two talked over each other.

Laposata also testified that Clancy’s body temperature dropped to 82 degrees, attributing it to spinal cord injury, wet clothing and prolonged exposure to frozen ground.

4. Clancy was turned away from suicide hotlines and rejected from a postpartum program

Testimony revealed multiple failed attempts by Clancy to access emergency mental‑health care. She called suicide hotlines twice and was turned away, according to both Zeizel and Susan Clancy, her former mother‑in‑law.

She was also rejected from Women & Infants Hospital’s postpartum program, which determined she was “overmedicated” and not a candidate for their services. Staff believed her symptoms were medication‑related rather than postpartum‑related.

Witnesses described her as desperately seeking help while reporting insomnia, numbness, fear of medication side effects and concerns she had developed a benzodiazepine dependency. She continued to seek treatment through multiple providers, including psychiatric nurse practitioners and emergency rooms.

Additional Notable Moments

While not bombshells, several other moments added context to the day’s testimony:

What Happens Next

The trial resumes Wednesday with more expert testimony expected, including additional psychiatric and forensic analysis that will shape the central question facing jurors: whether Lindsay Clancy was legally responsible for her actions on January 24, 2023, or in the grip of postpartum psychosis so severe that she could not understand the wrongfulness of what she was doing.

If you or someone you know is struggling with postpartum mental health, emotional distress, or thoughts of self‑harm, call or text 988, or chat at 988lifeline.org for immediate support.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines