
0.cached.png
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Not that it's at all surprising that Summers provoked an "intellectual tsunami," according to The New York Times, with comments that seemed to stop just short of linking menstruation to dyscalculia. He has been apologizing ever since, and rightly so.
But most of the good feminist moms I know do acknowledge that there are some (other, less insulting) innate differences between the sexes. We thought it was culture/nurture/Barbie, too, we say--until our children came along and convinced us otherwise.
A recent Washington Post story on the real--as opposed to intellectual-tsunami insisted on this point. After the first tidal wave hit the Sri Lankan village of Beruwala, it said, some of the men ran down to the beach to get a better look, mesmerized by the strange sight of the sea as it suddenly receded, exposing 600 feet of rocks and sand. "All the sea was like a desert," a fisherman named A. D. Chandaratna told the Post. "We had never seen this happen. This was the first time."
Read More on News
None of the local women stuck around to watch, though. At the first sign of trouble, they headed for the hills, literally, and scrambled to safety. Which is what we do, isn't it?
Of course, most victims of the tsunami had no chance to save themselves. But in this one spot, gender differences seem to have mattered quite a lot:
A retired government worker in a neighboring village, who gave his name as Senarathna, said he lived farther inland but ventured closer to the water, curious about the commotion that greeted the first waves. "Everybody was shouting," he said. "Some people climbed on to a rock" to get a better view. Then came the second, far more powerful set of waves. From the safety of higher ground, Senarathna watched as some of the men who had remained on the beach were swept out to sea, frantically waving for help. He said it was no coincidence that all of those who died were men. "The ladies, they didn't come," he said. "They were very worried."
Stereotypical, yes. But the feminine instinct to protect and preserve is also real, as far as I can see, and hard-wired. Not infrequently, my 8-year-old daughter Della warns her twin brother: "That's dangerous, Connor." She reflexively applauds when he walks away from trouble. "That was a good decision, Connor," I heard her tell him the other day. She can't help it.
And why should she? I love the curiosity and sense of wonder that would without any doubt have left my son spellbound on that beach--but thank God that my daughter would not only have reacted more cautiously, but would have dragged him up the hill, too, if necessary. Somebody's got to know where the emergency exits are, and there is a little "security mom" in all of us.
The conventional wisdom is that that's why so many more women voted Republican in '04 than in previous presidential elections, all but closing the traditional "gender gap." (Women favored Al Gore over George W. Bush by 11 points, but John Kerry over Bush by only three points--a difference that was decisive.)
I can't pretend to agree with the defectors; on the contrary, it's because I worry about security, too, that I wish I could have voted for Kerry 118,600 times, and as an Ohioan. I look at Iraq and hear Osama laughing. I watch Senate Democrats blowing kisses at the man who wrote off the Geneva Conventions as "quaint" and wonder if we are trying to send the message that we are united in our indifference to the abuse at Abu Ghraib. I listen to the president's beautiful Inaugural Address and certainly feel the sincerity in his stated desire to "build an ownership society."
Yet I have too much respect for the women who made a different choice in November to imagine that the mass defections were the result of some clever campaign trick or scare tactic. (Not, needless to say, that both sides didn't try.) Unlike Larry Summers, I assume that women can do the math. Many women obviously found the Democratic Party lacking in a host of ways I won't dismiss and that I want to hear more about.
In fact, this will be my last column for a while because I plan to spend the next year listening to these women, hoping they'll walk me through their calculations for a book I want to write. I'm drawn to this project in part because I have learned so much from readers who have written to disagree with me over the last year--for the most part, quite thoughtfully, and in a thrillingly civil tone. (Except in response to my column on Teresa Heinz Kerry, which provoked mail so mean I couldn't read it.) Special thanks, however, to the West Point instructor who wrote me about just-war theory. To the woman from Ohio who defended the honor of Republican poll watchers, I stand corrected. And to the outraged Notre Dame fan who suggested that in the future I might want to avoid speaking for Our Lady: Point taken, sir. Point so taken.
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines