...
By Joshua Sammons
Community Manager
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Welcome back to The Conversation. This week, Newsweek readers are debating Jimmy Kimmel after the late-night host once again drew criticism from President Donald Trump and his administration.
The latest controversy follows a joke on an episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live! that aired on April 23. In the segment, the host pretended to deliver a routine for the White House Correspondents Association dinner and joked that first lady Melania Trump had a "glow like an expectant widow."
The remark resurfaced two days later, when the dinner ended abruptly as a gunman charged a security checkpoint at the Washington Hilton, prompting the evacuation of the president and other attendees. The Justice Department later announced charges including attempted assassination of the president.
Read More on News
Trump branded Kimmel’s remarks a "despicable call to violence" and he and Melania called for ABC and its parent company, Disney, to fire the host. Kimmel pushed back on the controversy, saying the joke was "a light roast" and "not, by any stretch of the definition, a call to assassination."
This isn’t the first time Kimmel has faced criticism from the president and his administration. Last September, ABC pulled Jimmy Kimmel Live! after backlash over comments related to the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, before the show later returned.
Newsweek readers were divided—did Kimmel cross the line or was he simply exercising the kind of satire that has defined his career? Here is what you had to say:
- Want to join The Conversation? Join here.
On the Fallout From Jimmy Kimmel’s Joke
Original Article: Donald Trump Should Let Jimmy Kimmel’s Career Die of Natural Causes
Background: On Monday, both the president and first lady called for Kimmel to be fired.
Reader Comment: "It's not about Jimmy Kimmel, and it's not even about his vile comedy. It's more a matter of what's allowed/encouraged by the networks. If the idea here is, give the people what they want, then our entertainment never gets better than Jerry Springer. Someone has to be the adult. That someone is the head of the network. That is where the responsibility and culpability lies. You might think that years of jokes at President Trump's expense are funny, Lorne Michaels. But there have been three assassination attempts recently. What role does media play there?" Your Other Left
Editor’s Note: In response to this article, this reader shifts the focus away from Kimmel himself, arguing that network leadership bears responsibility for setting standards around political satire.
Reader Comment: "Kimmel is engaged in a desperate effort to save his career. All he's worried about is ratings, and he's doing quite well in that department, the alternating personal aggression, playing victim, and crying about it on live TV. Call it what you will, it is not comedy!" oakiewilson
Editor’s Note: This reader criticizes Jimmy Kimmel’s approach, arguing that his on-air commentary is driven more by career and ratings considerations than by traditional comedy.
On Kimmel Defending his Joke Amid Fallout
Original Article: Jimmy Kimmel Defends Melania ‘Widow’ Joke as Trumps Pile Pressure on ABC
Background: On his show Monday, Jimmy Kimmel said he was sorry for what the president and first lady experienced but seemed to defend his joke and didn’t apologize for it.
Reader Comment: "Don’t like him? Don’t watch. It's that simple. Anything else is just grandstanding." lew774
Editor’s Note: Proving to be a popular sentiment, this reader suggests that if you don’t like the content, you should simply switch it off and ignore it.
Reader Comment: "So Melania doesn't have a problem with Trump threatening to kill the entire Iranian civilization in one of his infamous holiday posts? Gee, Kimmel was making a joke—and as a comedian, he's known for doing that—and Trump as president of the United States threatening Iranians with annihilation if they don't agree to his 'peace talks'? OK, who really needs to be fired?" jwarmoth
Editor’s Note: In this response, the reader draws a comparison between rhetoric from both sides, questioning whether political statements by public officials warrant greater scrutiny than comedic satire.
On Calls for Jimmy Kimmel to be Investigated
Original Article: FCC Asked To Investigate Jimmy Kimmel As Trump Demands Disney Fire Him
Background: The National Religious Broadcasters association (NRB) filed a complaint with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), asking it to investigate ABC following Kimmel’s joke.
Reader Comment: "Trump is making sure that Kimmel's ratings are going through the roof, which makes sure Kimmel won't go anywhere. Unlike Trump, Kimmel is doing a good job for America by creating humor out of the humorless." 7%solution
Editor’s Note: Offering a contrasting perspective, this reader argues that the controversy may ultimately benefit Kimmel, framing the backlash as amplifying his visibility.
Do you agree with these comments? Let us know and make sure to check out more highlighted comments in the future.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines