russia-khodorkovsky-OVCO03

...

Mikhail Khodorkovsky

By Mikhail Khodorkovsky

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The Obama administration seems to be rather proud of the success of the "reset" in Russian-American relations. And it's true: anti-American propaganda in Russia's mass media has indeed been toned down, as has the Kremlin's confrontational talk about U.S. antimissile defense plans in Europe. The two countries have found common diplomatic ground on Libya and Iran, and NATO continues to use Russian airspace to supply its troops in Afghanistan. Last but not least, August's $3.5 billion share swap between Exxon and Rosneft, Russia's biggest state-owned oil company, is seen by the White House as a kind of expensive present to the U.S., from Russia with love.

The bad news is that the price of this rapprochement has been horribly high. Economic and political progress has been bought at the expense of America's quietly forgetting its democratic values and human rights.

If America can still be said to lead the world today, then its leadership is first and foremost a moral one. Millions of people around the world still look to the United States as a lighthouse of freedom. In large part, America's economic might follows from that moral leadership. People believe in the dollar because they believe in America's economic model. But they also believe in the values that the U.S. has created at home and promotes in the international arena: political competition, free elections, an independent media and judiciary.

Read More on World

Of course, President Obama has to deal with hard realities—one of the hardest being that global economic growth has increased competition for resources, particularly energy resources. And it's also clear that in times of economic crisis there is a huge temptation to make friends with countries rich in such resources, however obnoxious their regimes, rather than make war against them or antagonize them.

But the moral hazard in this kind of appeasement is far greater than its short-term advantages. By ignoring its basic values to make friends with dictators, America risks losing its moral capital—capital that is by no means limitless. If the U.S. fails to live up to the values of its own democracy, faith in the American Dream—that everyone is entitled to a fair chance, a fair say, and a fair hearing—will crumble. Just as important, faith in the fact that democracy is the world's most successful and effective system of government will crumble, too.

There is another way. Return ideals to their rightful, central place in politics, and deal with economic questions in the way that smart, honorable men and women have decided them in times past—through the power of intellect. To take a simple, concrete example, if the U.S. spent as much on saving energy and developing alternative energies as, say, Israel or Germany do, then its dependence on imported oil would be a thing of the past. Politicians seem to shy away from those kinds of farsighted policies because they might lose elections. But is there any doubt that America would be the long-term winner for achieving energy independence?

That wouldn't be a good thing only for America. Regimes in, say, Russia, would have to actually get down to some serious political and economic modernization rather than just paying lip service to reform in nice-sounding but ultimately empty speeches.

The time to make a decision is approaching: will America be moral, or merely pragmatic? It's a crucial decision. For America to turn its back on defending human rights around the world is not just wrong. It's dangerous. One might say as dangerous as its continued dependence on imported energy.

America's economic might is dependent on its moral leadership: to lose one is to lose the other. If that happens it will be America, not Russia, that will turn out to have been the real loser of the Cold War. And those of us who continue to believe in and fight for the ideals of freedom will find ourselves fighting an even lonelier battle.

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines