Kamala Harris with children

...

Chloe Mayer

By Chloe Mayer

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Comments made by a conservative commentator arguing that Kamala Harris "shouldn't be President" because she hasn't had children have sparked outrage online.

A post on X (formerly Twitter) by Will Chamberlain, who describes himself as Senior Counsel for two conservative projects—one to monitor Big Tech and the other set up to protect judges—went viral after he made the claims on Sunday. He was accused of misogyny and some fellow conservatives found the claims offensive and potentially damaging to the Republicans' need to appeal to women voters and the party's politically moderate wing. But Chamberlain defended his comments when questioned by Newsweek.

The outcry comes as Harris is currently being subjected to a string of racist and sexist abuse by online trolls after she found herself the Democratic frontrunner for presidential nominee on Sunday in the wake of President Joe Biden's decision to step down from the electoral race against Republican rival Donald Trump. Biden, who had faced calls to quit amid fears he was suffering from a decline in his health and cognitive abilities, has endorsed Harris to take the top spot on the ticket, although she must still face a vote at the party's convention next month.

Read More

Kamala Harris vs. Donald Trump: Where They Stand on 5 Key Science Issues7 min read

Kamala Harris vs. Donald Trump: Where They Stand on 5 Key Science Issues

MAGA Makes Sexist Attacks Against Kamala Harris4 min read

MAGA Makes Sexist Attacks Against Kamala Harris

Fact Check: Kamala Harris Deep Fake Spreads After Biden Drops Out4 min read

Fact Check: Kamala Harris Deep Fake Spreads After Biden Drops Out

Kamala Harris with children

...

Chamberlain posted a string of X posts suggesting that the Vice President should be disqualified from the top job because she doesn't have children. Being a stepmother to her husband's two children "doesn't count," he added.

"Really simple, underdiscussed reason why Kamala Harris shouldn't be President[:] No children," he said in a post that was liked more than 8,800 times and shared almost 3,000 times. "And no, becoming a step-parent to older teenagers doesn't count," he added in a follow-up post. "The concerns of parents and families will always be abstract to her."

View this post on X

He noted that he had said the same thing about South Carolina Senator Tim Scott, a former presidential hopeful, sharing a post from May 2023 that read: "Tim Scott is 57, never married, no children. Not to be harsh, but that's simply disqualifying." Explaining his point further this week, he added: "I said the exact same thing about Tim Scott. I want a President with skin in the game, a stake in the future, and the lived experience of raising children. Scott didn't have that, Kamala doesn't either."

Some X commentators appeared stunned by his claims. One person replied to Chamberlain's post, saying: "Just curious, which season of The Handmaid's Tale is that idea stolen from?"

Chamberlain did not share his views on other leading female politicians who do not have children, such as former British Prime Minister Theresa May, former First Minister of Scotland Nicola Sturgeon, and former Chancellor of Germany Angela Merkel. But one commentator replied to his post to point out that several male presidents have not had children and managed to hold down the job anyway. "Just like George Washington, James Polk, Warren Harding, James Buchanan, and Andrew Jackson," one X user said.

The first U.S. president, George Washington, did not have his own children but was, like Harris, a stepparent; he helped raise his wife's children from her first marriage. The "founding father" turned out to have quite a stake in the future of the country.

One person replying to Chamberlain's post suggested it was a strange comment for a lawyer to make: "If you didn't hire someone for any other job based on this extremely strange prerequisite, you'd probably be found in violation of a civil rights act."

Another respondent added: "According to you: any woman unable to bear children is automatically disqualified from the presidency, but a man convicted of sexual assault and multiple felonies [Trump] is fine. Correct??"

Other X users were shocked by the suggestion that only a woman who was a mother could perform as leader of the free world. One commentator replied: "Because having someone ejaculate inside of you makes you more presidential?"

Chamberlain's post also appeared to annoy some from within the Republican party.

One X account, whose bio claimed they were a conservative on the run from "'progressive' politics" in California, replied: "Ooohh careful there. That is a GREAT way to turn off a lot of moderates and women—you know, the demographics that Republicans need right now. Not a good look, especially from a man. Seriously, Will. Take this down. I think maybe you don't realize how difficult posts like this make it for women like me to make our case for conservatives. And for what? What exactly have you accomplished??" Another added: "Terrible take. [Harris has] got a lot of problems, this is not one."

But there were a few commentators who agreed with Chamberlain's post. "Solid point," one said. While another added: "Not enough people discuss this very valid point with leadership, generally." And one wrote: "No skin in the game. The future is no concern to you when no one you would die for will be a part of it. Selling out people you don't know or even respect becomes really easy."

Newsweek reached out to Chamberlain to seek clarification via email at one of the agencies he serves; the Internet Accountability Project. His bio on the site says he graduated from Georgetown University Law Center in 2015 and became an attorney before working for Florida Governor Ron DeSantis' presidential campaign.

The organization responded with an email, which it said could be attributed to Chamberlain, saying: "The argument is obviously not sexist, given that both men and women can become parents.

"When Kamala Harris achieves something on par with George Washington winning the Revolutionary War and delivering our independence, perhaps she can apply for an exception. We haven't had a childless President in 100 years.

"I obviously did not claim that every parent is an angel; rather, I claimed that one can't truly understand the challenges parents face without actually being a parent. Necessary, but not sufficient.

"I don't credit those [court] verdicts [against Trump] as being worth the paper they are printed on, and do not hold it against Donald Trump that he was the victim of a coordinated lawfare campaign.

"If Democrats are more worried about comments made by lawyers on the internet than they are about Donald Trump, they are going to lose even more badly than I anticipated."

Newsweek has also reached out to Harris via email seeking comment on the suggestion that she should be disqualified because she does not have biological children.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines