
...

By Robert Alexander
Senior Crime & Court Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A major federal lawsuit over workplace immigration raids in Alabama has been reassigned after a senior judge—appointed by President George W. Bush—declined to handle the class action, citing his policy of no longer accepting such cases and directing the clerk to “randomly reassign this action.” The case now goes to a newer appointee of President Donald Trump.
The lawsuit was filed by Leonardo Garcia Venegas, a U.S. citizen and construction worker who says federal immigration officers twice detained him this year despite valid proof of citizenship. The judge change comes as courts nationwide grapple with shifting Supreme Court guidance on immigration enforcement, including a recent decision allowing broader “reasonable suspicion” stops inside the country.
Newsweek contacted Venegas’ attorneys for comment via email outside of normal office hours on Friday.
Read More on U.S.
Why It Matters
The federal lawsuit by construction worker and U.S. citizen Leonardo Garcia Venegas sits at the crossroads of immigration enforcement and constitutional rights. Coming weeks after the Supreme Court signaled support for broader “reasonable suspicion” stops, the case asks whether federal agents can raid private job sites and detain workers—including citizens—without individualized evidence of unlawful status.
Its outcome could define how far immigration officers may go in workplaces across the country, shaping protections for millions of Americans employed in industries with large immigrant labor forces and testing whether the Fourth Amendment meaningfully constrains interior enforcement.
The stakes grew higher after the case was reassigned from a senior George W. Bush appointee to a newer Donald Trump appointee, a shift that could influence how aggressively the court interprets the government’s enforcement powers.

...
What To Know
The case was filed September 30 by Leonardo “Leo” Garcia Venegas, a U.S.-born construction worker who says he was wrongfully detained twice this year by federal immigration officers at Baldwin County building sites.
Venegas, 26, alleges that armed officers with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and partner agencies entered closed construction sites without warrants, detained Latino workers without individualized suspicion, and refused to release him even after he presented an Alabama “STAR ID,” a REAL ID–compliant driver’s license that requires proof of citizenship or lawful status.
“I just want to work in peace,” Venegas said in a statement released by his attorneys at the Institute for Justice. “It feels like there is nothing I can do to stop immigration agents from arresting me whenever they want”.
The complaint argues that DHS has adopted “warrantless-entry,” “preemptive-detention,” and “continued-detention” policies that violate the Fourth Amendment and federal immigration statutes limiting officers’ authority to enter private worksites and detain individuals.
Venegas seeks to represent other U.S. citizens and lawful residents working in construction who, the filing says, face the same risk.
DHS has rejected those allegations. “DHS law enforcement uses ‘reasonable suspicion’ to make arrests,” assistant secretary Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement. “What makes someone a target for immigration enforcement is if they are illegally in the U.S. – NOT their skin color, race, or ethnicity.”
McLaughlin did not address why Venegas, a U.S. citizen, was twice detained.
Supreme Court Lets ICE Resume Investigations
The legal fight comes weeks after SCOTUS allowed immigration agents in Los Angeles to resume certain investigative stops that had been temporarily blocked by a district court.
On September 8, the Court stayed an injunction that had barred agents from basing stops on factors including “presence at particular locations … the type of work one does … speaking Spanish or speaking English with an accent … and apparent race or ethnicity.”
In a separate concurring opinion, Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote that immigration officers “may briefly detain an individual for questioning if they have a reasonable suspicion … that the person … is an alien illegally in the United States” and that “apparent ethnicity alone cannot furnish reasonable suspicion,” though it “can be a relevant factor when considered along with other salient factors.”
Civil rights advocates say Venegas’s experience shows the practical effect of those rulings.
In one incident described in the complaint, officers entered a fenced and posted job site, “ran right past the white and Black workers without detaining them and went straight for the Latino workers,” including Venegas.
He was handcuffed for more than an hour before release, according to the Associated Press. A similar encounter followed weeks later.
A New Judge
The reassignment of the case to a new judge could influence its trajectory.
On October 2, Senior Judge William H. Steele, who has served since his 2003 appointment by President George W. Bush, declined to handle the class action and ordered the clerk to “randomly reassign this action” because he no longer accepts class suits.
The new judge has not yet been publicly identified in docket filings but will oversee a case likely to test the limits of federal immigration enforcement inside U.S. workplaces.
For now, Venegas’s lawsuit spotlights a growing clash between Supreme Court doctrine and on-the-ground enforcement.
The Court has emphasized that brief questioning based on “reasonable suspicion” remains constitutional, while plaintiffs argue that roving raids and prolonged detentions of citizens show the standard is being ignored.
The outcome could shape how far federal officers may go when immigration enforcement intersects with ordinary employment.
What People Are Saying
Tom Homan, White House Border Czar, June 12, 2025, said: “Worksite enforcement operations are going to massively expand.”
As dozens of federal agents made arrests in Chicago, a top U.S. Border Patrol official told WBEZ on September 29, 2025: “they targeted people based on ‘how they look’.”
Justice Sonia Sotomayor, dissenting in Noem v. Vasquez Perdomo, September 8, 2025, said: “We should not have to live in a country where the government can seize anyone who looks Latino, speaks Spanish, and appears to work a low wage job.”
What Happens Next
The newly assigned judge will take over the case and set an initial schedule.
The federal defendants are expected to file motions to dismiss, arguing that Venegas lacks standing to seek broad relief, that immigration enforcement decisions aren’t reviewable and that his claims fail under the Fourth Amendment and the Administrative Procedure Act.
The court will also consider whether the case can proceed as a class action. If it survives dismissal, the parties could seek early rulings on a preliminary injunction, begin discovery into DHS workplace-raid policies, and appeal interim decisions—meaning the case could reach higher courts, including the Supreme Court, before any trial on the merits.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines