
...

By Nick Mordowanec
Staff Writer
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Judge Juan Merchan chastised Donald Trump's attorney, Todd Blanche, during closing arguments Tuesday in the ex-president's hush money criminal trial.
Blanche, according to sources in the courtroom, told the jury that Trump could be imprisoned if they convicted him.
"That was outrageous, Mr. Blanche," Merchan said. "Someone who's been a prosecutor as long as you have, someone who's been an attorney as long as you have knows that it's highly inappropriate."
Read More on U.S.
The judge then said that he would provide curative instruction to the jury when they returned from their break.
Newsweek's Katherine Fung, who is inside the courtroom, reported that Merchan addressed the jury upon their return from break—providing instructions about Blanche's prison comment and informing them that he will be the one to decide sentencing.
Merchan's remarks towards Blanche occurred after prosecutor Joshua Steinglass raised an issue with Blanche's prison comment.
Craig Trocino, a law professor at the University of Miami, agreed with Merchan that Blanche's remark was "blatantly inappropriate."
He told Newsweek that an attorney as experienced as Blanche should know better. His remarks most likely weren't a "slip-up" as juries are never instructed to have sympathy for a defendant.
"Everybody who's ever stepped foot as a lawyer in a criminal courtroom knows that a comment to a jury about potential criminal penalties is a no-no," Trocino said.

...
Carole Lieberman, a forensic psychiatrist based in New York, told Newsweek that Merchan "is sealing the deal for an appeal by his outrage at Blanche."
"The jury presumably knows that Trump could go to jail if he's convicted since they are not sequestered and it has been all over the news that Trump could end up in jail...It wasn't a surprise to hear he could end up in jail."
Former Deputy Assistant Attorney General Harry Litman called it a "terrible final moment for Blanche" in a post on X, formerly Twitter.
Blanche's closing arguments began today at around 9:44 a.m. ET in Manhattan. They were anticipated to last several hours and extend into the late afternoon, with the prosecution originally estimating it could stretch its arguments between 4 and 4.5 hours.
Blanche began his summation minutes after Trump addressed the media outside the courtroom, just as he has done each day for nearly the past three weeks.
On Truth Social, Trump lamented against the rules of having the prosecution get the final word, writing: "WHY IS THE CORRUPT GOVERNMENT ALLOWED TO MAKE THE FINAL ARGUMENT IN THE CASE AGAINST ME? WHY CAN'T THE DEFENSE GO LAST? BIG ADVANTAGE, VERY UNFAIR. WITCH HUNT."
As Blanche delivered his arguments inside the courtroom, political operatives for both Trump and President Joe Biden—including Trump aide Jason Miller and actor Robert De Niro on behalf of Biden—held press conferences outside of the Manhattan Criminal Courthouse.
Blanche completed his closing arguments around 12:50 p.m., focusing on Michael Cohen as a central figure in the case. Blanche referred to Cohen as "the GLOAT," or "literally the greatest liar of all time," on a play of the acronym "GOAT" (Greatest Of All Time).
The defense's closing led to a lengthy break until the prosecution took over at around 2:15 p.m.
Trocino wasn't surprised by the Trump defense team's strategy of making a lion's share of arguments against Cohen to present an argument to the jury for reasonable doubt. He added that the prosecution's rebuttal is that Trump engaged in a criminal conspiracy where "a whole group of bad people [are] doing bad things."
A lengthy closing for the prosecution involves "tension" between being able to tell the jury what you want them to hear and not putting them asleep, Trocino said. They are relying on a proverbial roadmap based on evidence and witnesses.
He added that the prosecution has the "benefit" of being the last to speak directly to the jury as those are the last words they will hear as part of the overall case.
Update 05/28/24, 2:51 p.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information and comments from Craig Trocino and Carole Lieberman.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines