

By Kaitlin Lewis
Night Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
New York Judge Juan Merchan "absolutely should have recused himself" from former President Donald Trump's hush money case after it was revealed that he had previously donated to President Joe Biden's campaign, said senior CNN legal analyst Elie Honig.
Trump was found guilty on 34 counts of falsifying business records by a Manhattan jury late last month in connection to a $130,000 payment made to adult film star Stormy Daniels during the 2016 election. The former president has maintained that he is innocent and vowed to appeal the verdict after he faces sentencing, which is scheduled for July 11.
Throughout the trial, Merchan was heavily criticized by Trump and other supporters for his supposed prejudice against the former president, including after a Federal Elections Commission filing found that the judge made three donations totaling $35 to the Democratic fundraising site ActBlue during the 2020 election, including $10 that was earmarked for the group, "Stop Republicans."
Read More on U.S.

...
Honig, an attorney, was asked by CNN's Jake Tapper on Monday if he believed that Merchan's donations could be grounds for Trump to appeal his verdict.
"In my view, he absolutely should have recused himself," Honig said. "He should have removed himself. I mean, it's a minuscule amount, but judges are not supposed to give any amount. He violated the rules by giving $2, forget about $35."
"And I would just post the converse, what if the judge had donated a tiny amount, $35, to Trump 2020," Honig continued. "Would people be fine with that? I think people would be going nuts about that."
Honig added, however, that Merchan's past political activity doesn't amount "to the level of reversal, because he [Merchan] got this opinion from the ethics board saying, 'You're okay to stay on if you want.' Not 'You have to stay on, but you can stay on.'"
"But keep in mind, there's 40-something other judges in that courthouse who never donated, and it would have been safer," he said.
In July 2023, a complaint against Merchan over his donation to Biden's campaign was dismissed by the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct, although court spokesman Al Baker said in a May statement cited by the New York Times that the judge was cautioned by the board.
Under New York's judicial ethics standards, political donations by judges are banned in any circumstance. The state Commission board wrote in its 2024 annual report that it was made aware last year "of several dozen judges throughout the state who appeared to have made prohibited contributions over the past few years" and that most of the contributions were for "modest amounts."
When asked by Tapper what the ethics board was "thinking" by allowing Merchan to stay on Trump's case, Honig said that the Commission's opinion on the matter "is mishmash."
"It is a two-or-so page opinion that's very conclusory," he continued. "They basically say, 'Well, it was a small enough amount, and it was more than two years ago.' To which I would say, 'Who cares? How does that matter?'"
Newsweek reached out to the New York State Unified Court System via email for comment on Monday.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines