...
By Billal Rahman
Immigration Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A federal judge has launched a scathing attack on President Donald Trump's administration over the confusion created by revoking student visas.
Why It Matters
Immigration is a cornerstone of Trump's policy agenda. Republicans are planning to enact large-scale mass deportations as they look to remove millions of undocumented immigrants from the country.
Read More on Politics
...
What To Know
The White House has begun revoking visas for international students allegedly involved in pro-Palestinian activism on campuses. The action stems from Executive Order 14188, signed in early 2025, which aims to crack down on antisemitism. However, critics argue that the order is being used to silence protected speech, with visa revocations tied to students who participated in peaceful protests or distributed materials like flyers.
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is using AI-powered tools to scan international students' social media for any content interpreted as anti-Israel or supportive of designated groups like Hamas.
A recent federal court hearing captured the deep confusion surrounding the government's handling of student visa revocations.
In a Michigan court last week, DHS said that it does not have the authority to revoke a student's immigration status solely by terminating their record in the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS). The Trump administration said that changes to a SEVIS record, such as indicating a student is no longer enrolled, do not automatically impact the student's lawful nonimmigrant status.
SEVIS is a federal database maintained by Homeland Security that tracks and monitors international students, exchange visitors, and their dependents while in the United States.
Universities and program sponsors must regularly update the system with information such as enrollment status, address changes, and program completion. While it plays a vital role in overseeing visa compliance, the government's position in court has raised new questions about how much legal weight SEVIS designations carry.
Many hundreds of students who have had their SEVIS records terminated by DHS in recent weeks were informed by their schools or the government that they have lost their immigration status and must leave the country immediately.
Andre Watson, assistant director of the national security division for Homeland Security Investigations wrote in a court filing, "Terminating a record in SEVIS does not terminate an individual's nonimmigrant status in the United States."
On Wednesday, District Court Judge Ana Reyes in Washington D.C., ordered Watson to testify in court regarding the claims made in his declaration, which the government had also submitted in the case filed by students.
Reyes openly criticized federal attorneys for creating a legal scenario so convoluted that no one—not the student's lawyers, the court, or even the government—could confirm whether the student was in the country legally. The case involved an international student removed from his academic program just months before graduation.
Government lawyers insisted the termination didn't affect his immigration status, but couldn't provide any clarity when pressed. Calling the situation "Kafkaesque," Reyes pointed out that even seasoned immigration attorneys were not able to advise their clients because no one—not even the court—could make sense of the system.
The judge's blunt remarks quickly went viral, drawing widespread attention to the legal uncertainty facing many international students under the administration's hard-line agenda and constantly shifting policies.
"I've got two experienced immigration lawyers on behalf of a client who is months away from graduation, who has done nothing wrong, who has been terminated from a system that you all keep telling me has no effect on his immigration status, although that clearly is BS," Reyes said.
"And now, his two very experienced lawyers can't even tell him whether or not he's here legally, because the court can't tell him whether or not he's here legally, because the government's counsel can't tell him if he's here legally."
Many universities, fearing federal repercussions, initially advised students to leave the country after being notified of their visa revocations. Now, some of those same students are being told they might have been able to stay.
Schools are struggling to respond to the legal uncertainty and lack of clear guidance from DHS. There is growing concern that institutions could be decertified from hosting international students altogether, a move that would severely impact both academic diversity and cripple finances.
More than 1,500 student visas have been revoked as part of Trump's crackdown on immigrants involved in political activism, according to data from Inside Higher Ed.
What People Are Saying
Émile P. Torres, an American philosopher, intellectual historian, and activist, said in a post on X, formerly Twitter: "Four students at Case Western Reserve University—my university—were told that their visas had been revoked and that they will need to leave the country, while the semester is still going. Now, turns out, they don't! What a complete sh**show."
**Sasha Gusev, associate professor at Dana-Farber Cancer Institute said in a post on X: "**This has to be one of the craziest admissions from A JUDGE that I've ever seen in a court transcript. What the hell are we doing here?!"
What Happens Next
With legal uncertainty hanging over affected students, immigration attorneys are scrambling to provide clarity. Some universities are reviewing their handling of Immigration and Customs Enforcement communication, while civil rights groups are preparing challenges to the administration's moves.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines