
...

By Robert Alexander
Senior Crime & Court Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A Miami federal judge has rejected an attempt by an artificial intelligence company to file an unsolicited legal analysis in President Donald Trump's defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal, its parent companies, and News Corp founder Rupert Murdoch.
In an August 25 order, U.S. District Judge Darrin P. Gayles denied a motion from Mindcast AI LLC, which had sought to submit an 8,500-word amicus curiae brief. The company said its analysis could help the court identify "systematic litigation manipulation patterns" in the case.
Judge Gayles wrote: "Though Mindcast AI LLC (the 'Movant') indicates that it contacted all parties by email, the Court has not received the consent of Plaintiff or Defendants. Moreover, the Court does not find that the proposed brief would be helpful to the Court in adjudicating this matter."
Read More on U.S.
Why It Matters
The case matters not only because it pits a president against one of the world's most powerful media empires, but also because it highlights how federal courts are grappling with new challenges at the intersection of politics, press freedom, and emerging technology.
Trump's $10 billion defamation suit raises weighty questions about media accountability and judicial procedure, while the court's rejection of an unsolicited AI-generated brief underscores how judges may set limits on machine-driven attempts to shape high-stakes litigation.
What To Know

...
The Defamation Suit
Trump filed the lawsuit on July 18, 2025, in the Southern District of Florida, naming Dow Jones, News Corp, Murdoch, News Corp CEO Robert Thomson, and two WSJ reporters, Khadeeja Safdar and Joseph Palazzolo, as defendants.
The complaint seeks at least $10 billion in damages, alleging that The Wall Street Journal knowingly published false and defamatory claims in a July 17 report.
The article in question was titled "Jeffrey Epstein's Friends Sent Him Bawdy Letters for a 50th Birthday Album. One was from Donald Trump." Trump has denied that the letter attributed to him was authentic, saying the story caused "overwhelming" reputational and financial harm.
Deposition Fight Over Rupert Murdoch
One of the earliest disputes in the case has centered on whether Murdoch, 94, should be deposed before the defendants' expected motion to dismiss. Trump's lawyers filed a motion on July 28 seeking an expedited deposition, citing Murdoch's age and health, including reports of a February collapse and prior serious medical conditions.
Gayles later approved a joint stipulation pausing discovery while the dismissal motion is pending. Under that agreement, Murdoch and Thomson waived personal jurisdiction defenses. If the case proceeds, Murdoch must sit for an in-person deposition in the United States within 30 days of a ruling denying dismissal.

...
What Does the MindCast Brief Argue?
Mindcast AI submitted its motion on July 31, asking to file its brief as amicus curiae—a nonparty that submits information or arguments, with permission, to help a judge decide a case. The company argued its analysis could help the court recognize coordinated litigation strategies that "exploit judicial processes for institutional obstruction rather than legitimate dispute resolution."
The proposed brief argued that Trump's $10 billion defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal and Murdoch fit a recurring pattern of "coercive narrative governance" litigation. According to the company, Trump's defamation suits often succeed through settlement pressure applied when defendants face regulatory or institutional vulnerabilities but typically fail on the merits.
The firm highlighted what it called "asymmetric immunity exploitation"—Trump's pursuit of aggressive lawsuits against the press while simultaneously claiming immunity from similar suits against himself. It also argued the timing of the lawsuit, filed one day after the Journal's report and amid congressional pressure over the Epstein files, was part of a broader pattern of procedural weaponization aimed at obstructing oversight rather than seeking a genuine legal remedy.
MindCast presented itself as a neutral AI-driven platform specializing in identifying systematic litigation manipulation through predictive modeling. It said its "Cognitive Digital Twin" technology can detect coordinated campaign patterns that individual case reviews might miss.
The company stressed that it did not take a position on the truth of the allegations against Trump but sought to protect judicial integrity by warning courts about the risk of litigation being used as a tool for narrative control. Its recommendations urged the court to apply stricter case management, proportionality in discovery, Rule 11 sanctions for improper purpose, and expedited constitutional review of Trump's legal strategy, warning that failure to intervene could normalize litigation as a means of suppressing transparency and undermining democratic oversight.
Gayles, however, determined that the submission lacked the necessary party consent and would not aid the court's consideration. As a result, Gayles's order denied leave to file, which means it was never formally accepted into the docket record.
What People Are Saying
President Donald Trump, last month on Truth Social: "We have just filed a POWERHOUSE Lawsuit against everyone involved in publishing the false, malicious, defamatory, FAKE NEWS 'article' in the useless 'rag' that is, The Wall Street Journal."
A spokesperson for Dow Jones told Reuters last month: "We have full confidence in the rigor and accuracy of our reporting and will vigorously defend against any lawsuit."
Judge Darrin P. Gayles, in his order: "Though Mindcast AI LLC (the 'Movant') indicates that it contacted all parties by email, the Court has not received the consent of Plaintiff or Defendants. Moreover, the Court does not find that the proposed brief would be helpful to the Court in adjudicating this matter."
Mindcast AI, in its Motion for Leave: "Mindcast AI takes no position on the factual allegations concerning President Trump's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein or the accuracy of The Wall Street Journal's reporting. Mindcast AI's interest lies exclusively in assisting the Court in recognizing and addressing systematic procedural manipulation patterns that exploit judicial processes for institutional obstruction rather than legitimate dispute resolution."
What Happens Next
The next stage in the case will focus on whether the lawsuit survives a dismissal motion. Defendants, including The Wall Street Journal, Dow Jones, News Corp, Murdoch, and others, are expected to file for dismissal, and the court has suspended all discovery until that request is resolved. Under a joint stipulation approved by Gayles, Murdoch and Thomson waived personal jurisdiction defenses, but no depositions or document discovery can proceed until the judge rules.
If the court allows the case to go forward, Murdoch will be required to sit for an in-person deposition in the United States within 30 days of a denial. Meanwhile, Gayles has already removed Mindcast AI's proposed 8,500-word brief from the docket.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines