Josh Hammer

By Josh Hammer

Newsweek senior editor-at-large and host, "The Josh Hammer Show"

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Tap here to get this newsletter delivered to your inbox.

In the pews of the Church of the Annunciation in Minneapolis, a place of worship was turned into a war zone. A 23-year-old assailant opened fire during a school Mass, murdering two innocent children and wounding at least 17 others before taking his own life. The horror and the carnage are unfathomable. But the broader cultural reaction has been, in its own way, equally revealing.

Read More on Opinion

The media tiptoed—because the assassin identified as transgender (though not without apparent regrets).

The shooter, a biological male, had "transitioned." And with that single fact, the predictable silence set in. Liberal outlets soft-pedaled the clear motive, sanitized the narrative, and buried the lead. The shooter's vile anti-Christian, anti-Semitic screed? Brushed aside. The self-professed admiration for mass murderers? Underplayed. Why? Because it confronts head-on the single most untouchable dogma of our troubled age: that transgenderism must never, under any circumstances, be associated with pathology or mental illness.

Police work the scene following mass shooting

...

Tap here to get this newsletter delivered to your inbox.

But it's time to be honest. Transgenderism is not a benign "identity." It is not just "living one's truth." It is, more often than not, a manifestation of deep psychological distress—a mental health condition that requires serious care and treatment (and, yes, compassion), but not cultural affirmation.

We live in an era where delusion is treated as a civil right. When a person says he is something he is biologically not and cannot ever be, our institutions—not just medical, but also educational, governmental, and religious—are expected to nod along in agreement. And when someone in the depths of confusion lashes out in violence, we act surprised.

But should we be? Individuals who identify as transgender suffer from significantly higher rates of anxiety, depression, suicidal ideation, and yes—on occasions—acts of violence. The politically correct explanation? "Social stigma." But what if the real problem is not stigma, but a society that refuses to help people face reality—with compassion, but also firmly and unapologetically?

A transgender rights activist holds a flag

...

The Church of the Annunciation assassin was not a victim of oppression. He was a victim of lies—lies told by a culture that enables confusion and silences truth.

Transgender individuals deserve our sympathy. But we must never be afraid to speak the truth. We would never affirm an anorexic's belief that she is obese. Why do we affirm the gender dysphoric's belief that he or she is the opposite sex?

Truth, not ideology, must forever guide us. Enough cowardice. It's time to break the taboo. Lives are at stake.

Tap here to get this newsletter delivered to your inbox.


° Spotlight

Fed Lisa Cook

...

Yes, President Trump Has the Authority to Fire Lisa Cook

On Monday, President Donald Trump moved to fire Lisa Cook, a Biden-nominated member of the Federal Reserve's Board of Governors. He moved to fire Cook for "cause," and that cause is clear enough: According to William Pulte, director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency, Cook allegedly committed mortgage fraud by lying about her principal place of residence for purposes of securing more favorable interest rates—and then failed to report her rental income from the properties, to boot.

Trump's move is the first time a president has ever tried to fire a Fed governor for cause, and Trump's usual detractors have criticized him for his latest perceived violation of institutional norms. But Trump has acted appropriately; he is fully within his constitutional and statutorily delegated authority to remove Cook—whether for "cause" or not.

Read the full column.


+ More Views From The Right

Tap here to get this newsletter delivered to your inbox.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines