Biden Executive Privilege Criticism

...

Rachel Dobkin

By Rachel Dobkin

Weekend Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Joe Biden's move to use executive privilege to stop the release of the audio from Department of Justice Special Counsel Robert Hur's interview with him has received criticism.

White House counsel Ed Siskel notified Representatives James Comer, a Kentucky Republican, and Jim Jordan, an Ohio Republican, in a letter on Thursday that Biden has asserted executive privilege over audio recordings of his interview with Hur that was conducted in October 2023 in a move requested by U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland.

The transcript of the interview has already been handed over, but the House Oversight Committee, which Comer chairs, and the House Judiciary Committee, which Jordan heads, subpoenaed the audio from the interview.

Read More

Joe Biden Accused of ‘Political Blackface’ With Morehouse Speech4 min read

Joe Biden Accused of ‘Political Blackface’ With Morehouse Speech

Clarence Thomas’ Latest Ruling Shocks Supreme Court Analysts5 min read

Clarence Thomas’ Latest Ruling Shocks Supreme Court Analysts

Alvin Bragg Made ‘Beyond Foolish’ Move in Donald Trump Trial—Legal Analyst5 min read

Alvin Bragg Made ‘Beyond Foolish’ Move in Donald Trump Trial—Legal Analyst

Biden Executive Privilege Criticism

...

In the letter, the White House accused Comer and Jordan of having partisan goals for requesting the audio.

"The absence of a legitimate need for the audio recordings lays bare your likely goal—to chop them up, distort them, and use them for partisan political purposes," the letter said. "Demanding such sensitive and constitutionally-protected law enforcement materials from the Executive Branch because you want to manipulate them for potential political gain is inappropriate."

Newsweek reached out to Biden's campaign and the White House, as well as Comer's office via email on Thursday for comment.

Biden's move sparked backlash from Republican political strategists and consultants.

"Joe Biden's handlers desperately don't want Americans to hear the actual audio showing how genuinely confused and flustered he was when questioned by criminal investigators," consultant and election law attorney Mark Weaver told Newsweek via email on Thursday. "His claim of executive privilege is a campaign tactic cloaked in a faux constitutional claim."

In February, Hur's report on the classified documents found at Biden's Delaware home in January 2023 and his Penn Biden Center office in Washington, D.C., in November 2022 was released. Although Hur decided not to criminally charge the president, the story that made headlines was how the special counsel described Biden during their interviews for the investigation.

Hur wrote that Biden presented himself as a "sympathetic, well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory" in an interview that spanned two days and occurred while Biden was dealing with the aftermath of Hamas' surprise attack on Israel on October 7.

"Joe Biden's claim of executive privilege to stop the audio release of the Ben Hur interview, while not unexpected, will further cement the image of the president as a 'sympathetic, well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory' - the exact words that Hur used in his report," strategist Matt Klink told Newsweek in an emailed statement on Thursday. "Biden aides were concerned that the audio would be used in Republican attack ads throughout the fall, hurting the Biden re-election campaign and any Democrats running for office.

"Voter perceptions of Joe Biden as in mental decline and as a gaffe-prone president are now deeply embedded in their psyche. It's baked into the November 2024 general election cake. Nothing Joe Biden does or says will dispel that perception - real or imagined."

In May 2019, President Donald Trump used executive privilege to block DOJ Special Counsel Robert Mueller's full report from being released after House Judiciary Chairman Jerry Nadler subpoenaed U.S. Attorney General William Barr to hand over the unredacted version of Mueller's report of the investigation into Russian election interference.

A Democratic strategist, Brad Bannon, didn't think Biden's latest move would hurt his reelection campaign.

"I doubt many voters will notice in the midst of [former President Donald] Trump's trial for paying hush money to cover up his affair with a porn star," Bannon wrote in an email to Newsweek on Thursday. "The Republican hue and cry over the Hur transcripts is just another act in the GOP failed quest to impeach President Biden without a scintilla of evidence of wrongdoing."

Trump, the presumptive GOP presidential nominee, is facing four criminal cases, all of which he has pleaded not guilty to and has claimed are politically motivated. He is on trial for allegedly falsifying business records to cover up a $130,000 hush money payment to adult film actress Stormy Daniels during his 2016 campaign. Daniels claims that she had an affair with Trump in 2006, which he denies.

Comer and Jordan have alleged that Biden was involved in and benefited from son Hunter Biden's foreign business dealings, which the White House has repeatedly denied, and Biden has called a "baseless political stunt." The subpoena for the audio recordings is part of the Oversight and Judiciary Committees' investigation of Biden's mishandling of classified documents.

Democratic strategist Michael Gordon, who was a DOJ spokesman during the Clinton administration, told Newsweek via email on Thursday that Biden using his executive privilege "will have zero impact" on his campaign.

"Because of the deeply divided times we're living in, Democrats will shrug their shoulders, and Republican will feign outrage," Gordon said. "The only people who matter this cycle are the handful of voters in swing states who will decide the election – and this issue will be non-determinative for virtually all of them. And if it is a factor, it still plays in Biden's favor because Trump has been much more aggressive and public about asserting executive privilege."

Full Steam Ahead

Despite Biden using his executive privilege on the audio recordings, the House Judiciary Committee voted to advance a measure to hold Garland in contempt of Congress on Thursday. The House Oversight Committee is expected to vote on the measure later Thursday. The contempt resolution still needs to be brought to a full House vote and then, if it passes, it is still up to Biden's Justice Department to determine whether the charges are fitting.

"The department has a legal obligation to turn over the requested materials pursuant to the subpoena," Jordan said during a hearing in which the measure was voted on. "Attorney General Garland's willful refusal to comply with our subpoena constitutes contempt of Congress."

When asked by Newsweek why Jordan is still going after Garland after Biden used executive privilege to block the audio recordings, Jordan's office said via email on Thursday: "He's not 'going after' Garland. That is a lazy question and frankly, I expect better from Newsweek. Merrick Garland defied a lawfully issued subpoena for the Robert Hur audio tapes."

Newsweek then asked if Jordan thinks he has a chance for the contempt resolution to not only get passed in the House but then for the DOJ to bring charges, given that it was Garland's request for Biden to use executive privilege. Jordan's office did not respond by the time of publication.

Comer wrote in a statement posted on X, formerly Twitter, on Thursday: "Clearly President Biden and his advisors fear releasing the audio recordings of his interview because it will again reaffirm to the American people that President Biden's mental state is in decline...Today's Hail Mary from the White House changes nothing for our committee."

House Speaker Mike Johnson, a Louisiana Republican, wrote on X: "Why is President Biden now using executive privilege to prevent the audio recordings from coming out? Because he's afraid of what you'll hear. DOJ must release the tapes."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines