jd vance

...

Sean O'Driscoll

By Sean O'Driscoll

Senior Crime and Courts Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Vice President JD Vance is asking the Supreme Court to strike down limits on political donations.

Why It Matters

Vance and the Republican Party claim that limits on candidate donations have weakened parties and led to a huge transfer of cash to Political Action Committees, which are outside party control.

Read More

Is Elon Musk a US Citizen? Here’s What Country the Billionaire Is From4 min read

Is Elon Musk a US Citizen? Here’s What Country the Billionaire Is From

Judge Orders DOJ to Return to Court With Answers to Key Questions on Deportations2 min read

Judge Orders DOJ to Return to Court With Answers to Key Questions on Deportations

JD Vance Warns of ‘Threat from Within’ to European Democracy5 min read

JD Vance Warns of ‘Threat from Within’ to European Democracy

If the Supreme Court agrees, it could have a dramatic effect on political campaigns.

Newsweek sought email comment on Friday from the office of Vice President Vance and the National Republican Congressional Committee (NRCC).

jd vance

...

What To Know

Vance is leading the charge to abolish how much political parties can spend on coordinated party expenditures, which is the money that political parties and their candidates can spend together during a campaign.

Cash Is Speech

Vance and the Republican Party claim that the spending limits are a violation of the First Amendment, which guarantees free speech.

That's based on the 2010 Supreme Court decision in Citizens United, otherwise known as the "cash is speech" case.

In it, the Supreme Court ruled that political donations are acts of political free speech and, therefore, have First Amendment protection.

Vance took the case while still a Senator, along with the National Republican Senatorial Committee (NRSC) and the National Republican Congressional Committee.

According to the Federal Election Commission's Website, the Federal Election Campaign Act allows "a national party committee and state party committee to make expenditures in connection with the general election campaigns of federal candidates that are coordinated with those candidates."

What Are The Limits?

The FEC's website states that these inflation-adjusted limits "are based on the office sought and the relevant voting-age population."

The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has already determined that the spending limits do not violate the First Amendment's guarantee of free speech.

What People Are Saying

According to the petition to the Supreme Court by JD Vance and the Republican Party, the spending limits have "harmed our political system by leading donors to send their funds elsewhere, fueling the rise of narrowly focused 'super 'PACs' and an attendant fall of political parties' power in the political marketplace, which has contributed to a spike in political polarization and fragmentation across the board."

The FEC defines Super PACs as "committees that may receive unlimited contributions from individuals, corporations, labor unions and other PACs for the purpose of financing independent expenditures and other independent political activity."

PDF

477794-supreme-court-vance.pdf.PDF

Download

The plaintiffs argue that because super PAC funding is unlimited, they have pushed political parties aside as the place to donate money for political campaigns.

In its ruling in May 2024, the Sixth Circuit of Appeal appeared to be swayed by the plaintiffs' argument that Super PACS now holds the financial power during federal elections.

However, it said that it could not overturn the 2001 Supreme Court decision in FEC v. Colorado Republican Federal Campaign Committee, which upheld limits on coordinated campaign spending.

"These are fair points," the Sixth Circuit noted of the super PAC argument. "But none of them gives us authority to overlook or for that matter override the Supreme Court's decision in this case. The key reality is that the Supreme Court has not overruled the 2001 Colorado decision...In a hierarchical legal system, we must follow that decision."

What Happens Next

The Justice Department has twice asked for an extension before filing its opinion on the case, citing a heavy workload.

The Supreme Court has agreed to extend the Justice Department's reply date to April 10.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines