Iran, nuclear, contamination, training

...

Tom O'Connor

By Tom O'Connor

Deputy Editor, National Security and Foreign Policy

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


An Israeli official has said that the country was actively planning to mitigate the potential contamination emanating from strikes against Iranian nuclear facilities, including the massive underground complex at Fordow.

Speaking on background during a virtual briefing Tuesday, the official confirmed that the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) had not yet targeted the Fordow Fuel Enrichment Plant, believed to be a sprawling facility located up to 300 feet beneath a mountain around 20 miles from the city of Qom, amid ongoing Israeli operations that began late Thursday across the Islamic Republic.

At the same time, the Israeli official stated that further raids were planned against nuclear sites, and the IDF had drawn up calculations as to how to minimize the risk of fallout.

Read More on News

"We haven't operated to Fordow to this moment, but that doesn't mean we won't," the official said. "We have not finished and achieved all the goals of this operation. I won't go into more specifics to that, but I will tell you that going into this operation, there was a lot of planning, a lot of thought of how to minimize the risk and damage for civilians."

"And there's also a process to understand what are the possible effects of these kind of strikes on nuclear sites," they continued, adding that "the way we planned our operations is in a way that that there's never a 100 percent guarantee, but in a way that makes it very clear that that is not something that should happen, a nuclear disaster."

Iran, nuclear, contamination, training

...

Israeli strikes targeting nuclear facilities across Iran have raised concerns about the potential for radiation to spread to population centers in the country and potentially beyond.

Matthew Bunn, a Harvard University professor and former adviser to the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, downplayed these risks specifically posed to strikes targeting enrichment sites such as Fordow and Natanz.

"These uranium enrichment facilities, they don't have material that's that hazardous, and they're intentionally located in remote locations," Bunn told Newsweek. "The threat to civilians from bombing places that are in the middle of Tehran is way bigger than the threat to civilians from bombing possibly causing a little bit of uranium hexafluoride release at some locations."

He noted, however, that there would be a more significant threat posed by potential destruction at Iran's Bushehr Nuclear Power Plant, where contamination could affect the nearby Persian Gulf, a risk exacerbated by the waterway's poor circulation.

This argument was echoed by James Acton, co-director of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace's Nuclear Policy Program.

"If Israel were to strike Iranian reactors, the radiological consequences could be extremely serious," Acton told Newsweek, "but it has not done so, and I do not expect it to do so."

He said he believed that "Israel's military operation will prove catastrophic over the long run," though he was "not concerned about contamination resulting from the attack on Fordow."

"The uranium in an enrichment facility is barely radioactive and, while it is toxic, significant off-site spread is unlikely," he added. "Indeed, I'd point out that Israel has already attacked Iran's other enrichment facilities at Natanz with no significant off-site consequences according to the IAEA."

The comments came after International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Director General Rafael Grossi reported Friday on "radioactive and chemical contamination" at the Natanz Nuclear Facility, following an earlier IDF strike there. The IAEA said radiation levels outside the facility "remain unchanged."

Grossi said that, while the Israeli strike appeared to have destroyed the above-ground facility at Natanz, the subterranean section showed "no indications of damage."

The Israeli official on Tuesday questioned the sourcing of the IAEA findings on the level of devastation to the facility, saying the initial assessment of the IDF operation was that the strike "was a success," though the results were still being studied.

Asked by Newsweek if the IDF had the capability to effectively destroy the underground complexes of nuclear sites in Fordow, Natanz or elsewhere without the support of the United States, the Israeli official touted the military's capabilities, without getting into specifics.

"We have prepared for this operation on different levels for years," they said. "This is a well-planned operation, and we have a lot of different capabilities, and we have a few surprises up our sleeve, and we leave it at that.

"We have had a lot of success already," the official added. "There is more to come, and we are prepared to operate against the Iranian nuclear plants on ourselves and have the right achievements and be smarter once all this is said and done, but we've had a lot of success so far."

The Israeli official also referred to "a lot of innovation" among the IDF's capabilities, pointing specifically to prior operations conducted "in different places throughout the Middle East," as well as "our capabilities operating against different targets underground, including targeted elimination of arch terrorists underground in real time."

In September, nearly a year into the ongoing war in Gaza that sparked soaring regional tensions, the IDF killed longtime Hezbollah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah in a raid against his underground bunker in the southern suburbs of the Lebanese capital, Beirut.

A number of current and former Israeli officials have doubted the IDF's capability to take out Iran's heavily fortified underground nuclear facilities, given that the Israeli military was not known to possess the kind of 15-ton "bunker buster" bombs produced by the U.S., nor the aircraft necessary to deliver them.

Questions over the IDF's capabilities have raised speculation that the U.S. may become directly involved in the conflict, a notion further fueled by the movement of U.S. military aircraft and ships to the Middle East in recent days, as well as President Donald Trump's ominous warnings to Iran as he left a G7 meeting early in Canada late Monday.

Trump called for the immediate evacuation of Tehran, home to around 10 million residents and at least one research reactor. The Fordow Fuel Enrichment Plant is located roughly 125 miles south of Tehran, while the Natanz Nuclear Facility is located around 150 miles south of the Iranian capital.

Responding to French President Emmanuel Macron's claim that the U.S. leader had left to work toward a ceasefire as Israel and Iran continue to trade strikes, Trump said early Tuesday that he was working on something "much bigger than that."

Later that same day, he asserted that "we now have complete and total control of the skies of Iran."

Trump has consistently warned that Iran could not be allowed to possess a nuclear weapon, something the Islamic Republic has always denied seeking to build.

As of March, U.S. Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard had not concluded that Iran was pursuing nuclear weapons, according to her testimony to the Senate. The IAEA has also not stated that it believed Iran was actively working toward building a nuclear bomb.

Both, however, have noted that Iran's enrichment at heightened levels, nearing grades necessary to produce a weapon of mass destruction.

Shortly after Israel commenced its strikes against Iran, dubbed "Operation Rising Lion," an Israeli official told Newsweek that Israeli intelligence had assessed the Islamic Republic had obtained enough to material to produce up to 15 nuclear bombs.

Amid the Israeli raids, Iran has conducted retaliatory missile and drones strikes, called "Operation True Promise III," across Israel. The U.S. is assisting Israel in its interception of the incoming Iranian attacks, and the Pentagon has maintained that U.S. forces in the region were strictly in a "defensive posture" at the moment.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines