
Photo-Illustration by Newsweek/Getty/Associated Press

By Jesus Mesa
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Eight incumbent Republican state senators face primary races Tuesday in Indiana after voting against President Donald Trump's redistricting push, with seven facing Trump-backed challengers. The primary tests whether the president's political machine can punish GOP lawmakers who defied him on a key legislative priority.
In December, Indiana's state Senate rejected Trump's demand for mid-decade congressional redistricting to flip two Democratic-held seats. Twenty-one Republicans joined all 10 Democrats in voting against the map, a rare defeat for Trump at the hands of his own party.
Trump, however, vowed immediate retaliation.
Read More on Politics
"Every one of these people should be primaried," he posted on Truth Social, calling the senators "SUCKERS" for the Democrats. He specifically targeted Senate President Pro Tem Rodric Bray, writing that "Rod Bray and his friends won't be in Politics for long." An estimated $9 million in advertising from national groups has been spent attacking the incumbents, dwarfing typical spending in state legislative races.
Vice President JD Vance accused Bray of deception, posting on X the Senate leader had told the White House he would not fight redistricting while secretly working to kill it. "That level of dishonesty cannot be rewarded," Vance wrote.
The stakes extend beyond Indiana's legislative chamber. The primary will demonstrate whether Trump's grip on the Republican Party remains tight or is fraying in a state he has won by wide margins in each of his three presidential campaigns. For Republicans holding a razor-thin House majority and bracing for Democratic gains in the midterms, the answer carries significant weight.
Targeted Incumbents Fight Back
Spencer Deery, an incumbent GOP senator from West Lafayette, is one of the targets. He voted against redistricting after his constituents opposed the change. Facing Trump-backed challenger Paula Copenhaver, who ran against him in 2022, Deery said the operation was designed to silence independent lawmakers.
"All they have to hit me with are lies, and there's no organic grassroots movement behind these attacks, because they're not coming from Indiana and not coming from my district," Deery said in interviews with the Indiana Capital Chronicle. "They're coming from back east, from Washington, D.C."
Deery characterized the campaign as a test of whether outside groups could control state elections. "Outside dark-money groups are trying to show they can control our elections and to intimidate local elected officials across the country into listening to them, not their voters," he said.

...
A Trump-aligned dark money group funneled $1.5 million to attack ads. Club for Growth Action committed roughly $2 million in mailers. Hoosier Leadership for America, aligned with Senator Republican Jim Banks, spent $4 million on television. Six competitive races exceeded $1 million in TV spending, amounts previously unheard of in Indiana state Senate contests.
Vance visited the state twice to pressure lawmakers while House Speaker Mike Johnson, a Louisiana Republican, made personal calls to state legislators. White House officials contacted a third-party candidate in one race, offering job opportunities if she would withdraw. Several senators faced swatting threats and bomb threats.
Bray became Trump's specific target. Although Bray is not on the ballot until 2028, Trump vowed to unseat him. Bray said he had no regrets about the redistricting vote.
"It was a very, very challenging session in December, and those votes were hard, and the folks that voted against it, I know, are now under a massive attack from Washington, D.C., and elsewhere in the nation," Bray said in an interview last week with the Indiana Capital Chronicle. "I just would hate to see those people lose because of the will of somebody outside the state of Indiana."
Republicans Question Trump's Strategy
Republican operatives said they aim to flip three to five of the eight targeted seats, according to Lieutenant Governor Micah Beckwith, a Trump supporter. Even that would require significant GOP shifts, possibly affecting Bray's leadership post in the next legislative session.
Trump's operation has triggered criticism from establishment Republicans. Some question whether the president is overplaying his hand in a midterm year when Republicans face historical headwinds.
"This is not an ideological battle, it's about allegiance to Trump. It's a lot of carnage for very low return," Marc Short, a Republican adviser who served as Vice President Mike Pence's chief of staff, told NOTUS.
Yet, Trump retains a stronger foothold in Indiana than nationally. While his approval rating hovers near 37 percent nationally amid economic pressures and the ongoing conflict with Iran, Indiana voters view him more favorably at roughly 49 percent.

...
Former Indiana Governor Mitch Daniels, who opposed the redistricting push, offered a blunt assessment.
"Let's leave right and wrong out of it for a minute. I just think it's dumb. They're spending all this money just to feel better that they whacked somebody that didn't kowtow," Daniels told KUOW. "It's just not very smart."
Local GOP officials have expressed unease about the nationalization of state-level primaries. "We don't want D.C. dictating what we do in Indiana," Preston Wright, the Wells County GOP chair, told NOTUS. "They're just bringing in all these national talking points into Indiana to try to get these people elected."
Travis Holdman of Markle, an 18-year incumbent facing Trump-backed challenger Blake Fiechter, exemplifies the tension. Holdman's record is conventionally conservative: pro-life, pro-gun, pro-small business, pro-tax cuts. Yet Trump has labeled him a "RINO," or Republican in name only, and an "American Last politician."
"I didn't know I was an enemy of the president. I've supported him. I sent money to his campaign," Holdman said, adding that he no longer contributes to Trump.
The Tension on the Ground
Trump-backed challengers frame their candidacies as substantive rather than retributive. Copenhaver said the redistricting vote represented a missed opportunity to strengthen Indiana's Republican representation. She attended a White House meeting with Trump and other endorsed candidates in March.
"It was truly an honor to meet with President Trump and to shake his hand," Copenhaver posted on social media. "I'm proud to have his Complete and Total endorsement."
Most challengers are first-time candidates recruited specifically for these races. Their campaigns emphasize Trump's endorsement more than policy distinctions with incumbents.
Marty Obst, the Republican consultant who led the redistricting push, framed the effort as accountability. "This was a top political priority of President Trump's and he was very clear about that," he told NPR. "The bottom line is there's consequences and accountability to those actions."
Club for Growth President David McIntosh told reporters his organization was "proud to stand with Indiana voters who are demanding more from their elected officials."
The primary will determine whether outside money and Trump's endorsement can overcome incumbent advantages. Tuesday's results will signal the strength of Trump's hold on the GOP as the party prepares for a challenging midterm cycle.
Full List of the Indiana Republicans Who Voted Against the Redistricting Plan
- Senator Rodric Bray
- Senator Eric Bassler
- Senator Mike Bohacek
- Senator Vaneta Becker
- Senator Brian Buchanan
- Senator James Buck
- Senator Ed Charbonneau
- Senator Brett Clark
- Senator Michael Crider
- Senator Spencer Deery
- Senator Dan Dernulc
- Senator Blake Doriot
- Senator Susan Glick
- Senator Greg Goode
- Senator Travis Holdman
- Senator Jean Leising
- Senator Ryan Mishler
- Senator Rick Niemeyer
- Senator Linda Rogers
- Senator Greg Walker
- Senator Kyle Walker
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines