10

Loading video...

Dan Gooding

By Dan Gooding

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Immigration judges are asking the U.S. Supreme Court to intervene in a yearslong First Amendment fight over a Department of Justice (DOJ) policy that restricts what they can say publicly about immigration and the federal agency that employs them.

The National Association of Immigration Judges (NAIJ) filed a petition Tuesday, asking the justices to review an appeals court ruling that prevents the group from challenging the policy directly in federal district court, instead directing judges toward the federal government's civil service review system.

The judges contend that route may never lead to judicial review and that forcing them to wait while the policy remains in place creates an immediate First Amendment injury by chilling speech before it even happens.

Read More on U.S.

"When the government places a prior restraint on the expression of public employees, they should be able to go to court to challenge that restraint immediately," Ramya Krishnan, senior staff attorney for the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University, which brought the lawsuit, told Newsweek. "With immigration policy, at the center of national debate, it's more important than ever that the public hear what immigration judges have to say."

Newsweek reached out to the DOJ for comment via email Tuesday afternoon.

What Are Immigration Judges Barred From Saying?

Immigration judges are employees of the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR), which falls under the DOJ's responsibility.

The challenged policy treats speech concerning agency policies, programs or subjects directly related to judges' official duties as official-capacity speech. The petition says that effectively prohibits judges from speaking in their personal capacities about immigration or EOIR.

Before the restrictions began in 2017, under the first Trump administration, judges regularly spoke at conferences, taught at universities and law schools, and participated in immigration law training, subject to approvals and disclaimers making clear they were speaking personally, the petition said.

The association said judges are not prevented from personally discussing subjects from immigration court procedure to their own experiences as judges.

"The result is to deny the public access to important insights from those with direct knowledge of how the immigration system operates," the petition said.

The U.S. Supreme Court Building is pictured on October 5 in Washington, D.C.

...

"Judges do not turn in their right to free speech when they put on the robe," Holly A. D’Andrea, president of the National Association of Immigration Judges, said in a press release. "Our country was designed to be governed by public reason, not private silence. Silencing judges deprives the public of a key perspective on the rule of law."

Why Immigration Judges Are Going to the Supreme Court

The immediate question for the Supreme Court is not whether the DOJ policy is a First Amendment violation. Instead, the justices, should they decide to hear the case, would need to decide whether immigration judges are even allowed to take their constitutional challenge directly to federal court.

The case was initially brought July 1, 2020, when the Knight Institute filed a lawsuit on behalf of the NAIJ, challenging the policy.

The district court where the case was filed turned the case away, citing the Federal Service Labor-Management Relations Statute, which prevents unions—in this case, the NAIJ—from using that system to deal with a complaint. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals backed that decision.

After that, in 2022, the NAIJ was formally decertified as the judges' bargaining representative on the case, meaning the original reason for the federal district court turning the case away no longer existed. The Fourth Circuit then vacated its previous decision.

However, the case faced another block in federal court in 2023: the Civil Service Reform Act. That legislation says that the judges would need to go through the DOJ's own complaint system and this is why the appeal has been taken to the Supreme Court.

"Even if they did eventually get judicial review, that judicial review wouldn't be meaningful, because judges are being chilled right now," Krishnan said. "And any relief they got through judicial review at the end of the day under the scheme would come too late to remedy the ongoing and irreparable harm to their First Amendment rights."

The Supreme Court has already intervened in this case, in May, when it granted the government's petition and summarily reversed the Fourth Circuit's judgment. The justices, however, did not resolve the underlying free speech issue or the jurisdiction issue being brought up now.

Related Story

Trump DOJ Says Judges Waged ‘Partisan Press Campaign’ Over ICE Operation

Trump DOJ Says Judges Waged ‘Partisan Press Campaign’ Over ICE Operation

Judges Warn of a 'First Amendment Black Hole'

"The Fourth Circuit’s conclusion threatens to create a First Amendment black hole—allowing each new administration to impose prior restraints on the speech of federal employees without any guarantee of judicial review of those restraints," the petition read.

The plaintiffs argue that the federal government could "categorically forbid federal employees from engaging in even private speech about gun rights, health care, vaccines, university admissions, or the war in Gaza—and judicial review of these brazenly unconstitutional policies would come only with the blessing of an agency official, and only after protracted and futile administrative proceedings."

All of these concerns stem from the path identified by the Fourth Circuit. An employee could submit a complaint to the Office of Special Counsel, but reaching the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB)—which adjudicates complaints—depends on the Special Counsel deciding to pursue corrective active, meaning it is not guaranteed at all.

Between fiscal years 2020 and 2025, the petition said, only one MSPB appeal was lodged, the petition said.

Why the Case Could Reach Beyond Immigration

While the case is about immigration judges and their rights, the petition argues that the restrictions could affect a wide range of federal employees wishing to speak about gun rights, healthcare, vaccines and more.

If the Supreme Court does grant the appeal and forces the case to be heard in federal district court, the wider DOJ policy could then be challenged.

"If the Supreme Court does grant certiorari on this question, and were to decide in our favor, then that means that the district court, in our case, could finally reach the merits of our First Amendment claims, which are strong, and hold that this policy is unconstitutional and prohibit the agency from enforcing it against judges who speak publicly about immigration law and policy," Krishnan said.

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here. Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Hollie Silverman and Edward T. Cummins.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines