
0.cached.png
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
From Hollywood to Woodstock, low-carbohydrate diets are the hot item on the nation's menu. So perhaps it is not surprising that at a recent White House dinner, Secretary of Agriculture Dan Glickman was chatting with Dr. Dean Ornish about the craze. As an avowed enemy of the fad, Ornish had nothing kind to say about the diets, which he calls "hazardous to your health." Listening to Ornish, Glickman became intrigued by the idea of a national forum to get all the issues out on the table.
The result was a face-off in Washington last week that Glickman called "The Great Nutrition Debate"--and moderator Carolyn O'Neil of CNN irreverently dubbed "Who Wants to Be a Millionaire Diet Doctor?" Panelists included five top-selling diet gurus, whose prescriptions range from Dr. Robert Atkins's ultrahigh-protein regime to Ornish's strict low-fat plan. In between: "The Zone's" Barry Sears, Dr. Morrison Bethea of "Sugar Busters!" fame and Dr. John McDougall of "Dr. McDougall's Right Foods." Rounding out the panel were Keith-Thomas Ayoob representing the American Dietetic Association and Dr. Denise Bruner of the American Society of Bariatric Physicians. (Bariatrics is the study of obesity.)
Read More on News
As the panelists squared off, the issue wasn't so much whether patients can lose weight on low-carb diets. Everyone agrees that they can, at least in the short term. But there was wide dispute over the long-term impact on a dieter's health. Atkins was the prime target. His radical approach--starting with a three-egg omelet and two strips of bacon for breakfast (lose the OJ)--has been accused of promoting everything from kidney damage to heart disease. Bread, pasta, sugar and fruit are out in the initial phase of the diet; steak, butter and cream are in. A spokesperson for the American Dietetic Association recently called it "a nutritionist's nightmare."
Atkins claims wide-reaching health benefits, but his critics say he falls short on rigorous scientific proof. Although he first published his diet nearly 30 years ago, he has only preliminary results of two new studies to back up his claims. Atkins presented these findings to the panel. But that wasn't enough for this crowd. Some highlights of last week's debate:
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines