10

Loading video...

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Insurance is supposed to make uncertainty manageable. But when Americans keep paying more for protection while receiving less value in return, rising costs are no longer the whole story. The system itself deserves scrutiny.

The scale of the pressure is difficult to ignore. KFF’s 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey found that the average annual premium for employer-sponsored family coverage rose 5 percent to $28,303, with covered workers contributing an average of $7,471.

At the same time, rising homeowners insurance premiums are squeezing household budgets and adding another obstacle to an already strained housing market.

Read More on Leadership Insights

We tend to explain these increases through familiar forces: medical costs, natural disasters, inflation, litigation, and rebuilding expenses. Those pressures are real.

But after working in and around insurance since 1989, I believe focusing only on what insurance costs misses a deeper problem. The system contains structural incentives that do not always align with what consumers need from it.

How Insurance Commissions Can Shape Advice

Start with compensation. Insurance distribution has long relied on commissions tied to premiums and products sold. The problem is not that commissions exist. The problem is what they reward. When compensation rises with the premium placed, the system can reward higher costs even when consumers desperately want lower ones.

I am not suggesting agents routinely put commissions before clients. I am arguing that good intentions cannot fix a compensation structure that can pull advisers and consumers in opposite financial directions.

The second misalignment involves regulation. Insurance regulators have an essential responsibility to ensure carriers remain financially capable of paying claims. That priority is embedded deeply in the system.

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners states that at its core, statutory accounting helps regulators determine whether an insurer is financially sound, or solvent.

Solvency is indispensable, but protecting an insurer’s ability to survive is not identical to ensuring consumers receive affordable, useful protection. A financially healthy insurance market can still leave households struggling with premiums, deductibles, exclusions, and reduced coverage.

Then there is accounting. Insurers generally prepare statutory financial statements using Statutory Accounting Principles (SAP), rather than relying solely on the Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) framework familiar across corporate America. SAP has legitimate reasons for being conservative, particularly to protect an insurer’s ability to meet future obligations.

The Pricing Risk and Future Loses

But that priority exposes the deeper problem: The system is designed first to protect against an insurer’s financial uncertainty, while consumers are left carrying more of their own. Solvency matters, but it should not become the measure by which consumer value is sacrificed.

Actuarial science adds another layer. Pricing risk requires assumptions about future losses, medical costs, catastrophes, behavior, and countless other variables.

Models are necessary, but models also require judgment about which data deserve weight and which assumptions best represent tomorrow. Consumers see the resulting premium. Few can realistically evaluate the machinery that produced it.

The consequences are no longer abstract. Health insurance covers 165.6 million Americans under 65 through employers, making affordability a household economic issue rather than an industry concern. The pressure is becoming impossible to ignore in housing.

As CNBC recently reported, homeowners insurance premiums have surged nationwide, turning coverage into a growing affordability problem rather than simply another household expense. When insurance costs climb this sharply, they can influence whether prospective buyers can afford to own a home at all.

If this trajectory continues, more Americans will find themselves in an absurd position: insured on paper, yet increasingly unable to afford the protection they are paying for.

What Consumers Should Know Before They Renew

A better system would stop treating insurance as the automatic answer to every form of risk. Risk costs money, but consumers should start with the problem they need solved and determine whether insurance is actually the best tool for solving it.

Sometimes risk financing, prevention, or alternative ways of sharing costs may deliver greater value. In housing, stronger building standards and better claims processes could reduce losses instead of simply charging consumers more after the risk has already increased.

That requires a concrete first step. Regulators and employers should require consumer-facing insurance recommendations to disclose, in plain language, how intermediaries are compensated, what material coverage has changed from the previous year, and which viable non-insurance risk-financing or prevention alternatives were evaluated.

The answer is not abandoning insurance. It is recognizing where insurance works, where it does not, and having the courage to look beyond it when consumers deserve something better.

Treacy Duerfeldt is an Olympia, Washington-based insurance educator, risk advisor, and the founder of Construction Insurance Risk Education (CIRE) and NWC Alliance Construction Risk. All opinions expressed are the author's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines