Pope Leo XIV leaves after a Mass where he conferred the pallium on newly appointed metropolitan archbishops, in St. Peter’s Basilica, at the Vatican, Monday, June 29, 2026.

...

Jordan King

By Jordan King

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Pope Leo XIV's excommunications for certain members of the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX), a traditionalist breakaway group, raises fresh questions for thousands of American Catholics who worship at its chapels or sympathize with its opposition to the modern direction of the Catholic Church.

On Thursday, the Vatican excommunicated four bishops who were ordained in Écône, Switzerland, the day before without papal approval, along with the two bishops who carried out the consecrations. It also extended the penalty to lay members who "formally adhere to the Fraternity," affecting about 30,000 SSPX faithful in the United States, along with 124 priests serving 115 chapels, according to the society's most recent figures.

The decree immediately raised questions as Catholics sought to understand what the Vatican considers "formal adherence." In guidance issued later on Wednesday, the Vatican clarified that simply attending an SSPX chapel is not enough to incur the penalty. Instead, it said, each case must be assessed individually, distinguishing between those who formally embrace the society's doctrinal positions and those who attend solely for liturgical or spiritual reasons.

Read More on News

Peter Kwasniewski, an American Catholic philosopher and author who is a prominent voice in the traditionalist Catholic movement, told Newsweek he believed the decree would prompt "a crisis of conscience" for some American worshippers while others would "take it as a provocation, as a vindication of their principled stance."

For American Catholics who attend SSPX chapels, Leo's ruling is also likely to bring renewed appeals from diocesan bishops and parish priests to return to full communion with Rome. Several U.S. bishops have already urged the faithful not to deepen the schism, instead encouraging those connected to the society to seek reconciliation with the Catholic Church through their local dioceses and to pray for unity.

Pope Leo XIV is seen at a Mass where he conferred the pallium on newly appointed metropolitan archbishops in St. Peter's Basilica, at the Vatican, on June 29.

...

Which American Catholics Have Been Excommunicated?

The church's decree names all six of SSPX's bishops—Alfonso de Galarreta and Bernard Fellay, who carried out the consecrations, along with the four newly ordained ones:

The decree said each had incurred ipso facto, or automatic, excommunication.

The Vatican stressed that penalties against lay members of the SSPX "cannot be presumed automatically" and instead "must be evaluated case by case," depending on an individual's personal responsibility.

It said Catholics who "habitually participate" in the society's liturgies while "formally sharing its doctrinal positions" could be considered personally culpable, citing members of the SSPX's Third Order—a lay association for Catholics formally committed to the society's spirituality and mission—as one example of faithful who could be considered personally culpable. The document also sets out separate routes back into full communion.

From left, Marc Hanappier, Michel Poinsinet de Sivry, Michael Goldade and Pascal Schreiber pray during their consecration ceremony beside co-consecrator Bishop Bernard Fellay in a tent set up outside the Society of St. Pius X seminary in Écône, Switzerland, on July 1.

...

What Happens Now for SSPX Faithful in America?

Kwasniewski said this order's practical impact on American Catholics would vary, with some working to return to communion with Rome while others may double down.

"Conservative Americans tend to be rather law-abiding folk, with a sort of Anglo-American strictness ('the letter of the law'), unlike the Italian approach to law where it's more of an earnest suggestion and people wiggle around the observance of it," he told Newsweek.

"So I do think that a significant minority of American faithful who attend SSPX chapels will have a crisis of conscience about the Vatican's July 2 decree and may distance themselves from the society."

"But others, I'm afraid, will take it as a provocation, as a vindication of their principled stance, and in this way the divisions between the two sides are likely to expand and harden," he said.

How American Catholics respond may also depend on their local dioceses. Across the country, bishops have begun urging SSPX faithful to return to full communion with Rome.

Bishop James V. Johnston, whose Missouri diocese is home to the SSPX's U.S. headquarters, said on social media on Thursday, "Those who wish to maintain communion with the Catholic Church, including valid reception of the sacraments of Matrimony and Penance (Confession), will no longer find that possible within the SSPX."

"In this moment, I wish to reassure the members of the SSPX within this diocese of my pastoral concern as a shepherd with a desire to assist you in this time of crisis," he added.

Similarly, Archbishop Shawn McKnight, whose Kansas diocese contains what the SSPX calls "the largest SSPX-built church in the world," addressed the SSPX laity in a statement, saying, "They should know that they are loved by the church and remain the object of our prayers for unity."

SSPX Followers: 'We'll Wear It as a Badge of Honor'

Echoing Kwasniewski's prediction, several SSPX followers in Écône said the excommunications had only strengthened their resolve.

"We'll wear it as a badge of honor and remain Catholic while we continue to pray for [Pope Leo] and hope that one day they'll turn around and find their faults," one man told the independent Catholic outlet Ad Vaticanum.

"I actually feel relieved," another said, adding, "It's done, and we are in the correct way."

Conversely, one woman said she and other members were "very sad" and asked Leo to "reconsider."

Another said he did not believe the excommunications were valid. "I'm willing to take that, though it's with some fear and trembling; you don't want to be labeled excommunicated by the Catholic Church," he said. "But I don't fear for my salvation directly."

How SSPX Members Can Return to Full Communion

The Vatican has outlined separate paths back into full communion with the Catholic Church, depending on an individual's relationship with the SSPX.

Catholics found to have formally adhered to the society must submit a signed Profession of Faith and Formula of Adherence to their local bishop, affirming their acceptance of Catholic doctrine, papal authority and the teachings of the Second Vatican Council before they can be readmitted to the church.

For those who attended SSPX chapels only for liturgical or spiritual reasons, the process is simpler. The Vatican said it is sufficient to approach "a priest in full communion with the Catholic Church" with the intention of "no longer attending the Society of Saint Pius X."

SSPX priests seeking reconciliation must also submit a handwritten request to the pope for the remission of ecclesiastical penalties before completing a probationary period under a bishop or religious superior.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Tobias Meyjes and Shakeema Edwards.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines