10
Loading video...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
During his last year in office, Governor Ron DeSantis pushed aggressively for sweeping property tax reform in Florida, an effort that eventually led to the passage of Amendment 3.
The measure, which promises to significantly cut bills for most homeowners in the state, was not quite what the Republican governor had in mind. He had more ambitious plans, envisioning a path toward eliminating property taxes on homesteaded homes altogether.
Instead, lawmakers in Tallahassee went for a milder version of a property tax overhaul, which will raise the exemption for nonschool property taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, among other changes.
Read More on News
DeSantis said what he wanted was "a full elimination of property taxes on homesteaded properties, not just cuts," and refused to campaign for the amendment on the ballot. Still, the governor celebrated the passage of the bill with roughly 62 percent of the vote as a "big win for Florida homeowners."
And even though the measure will come into force under Governor-elect Byron Donalds, DeSantis’ legacy will loom over the reform and the way it changes Florida in the long term. This legacy might hurt his presidential ambitions in 2028, experts say—or propel it forward.
While not on the ballot in 2026, DeSantis "was a leader in the movement to pass one of the largest tax cuts in American history," Darryl Paulson, emeritus professor of government at the University of South Florida, told Newsweek. "DeSantis argues that Florida was one of just a few states where the GOP did not suffer tremendous losses at the polls [during the midterms, and he claims it was all due to Amendment 3.
"Will Governor DeSantis be the beneficiary of leading the movement for an enormous tax cut, even if the public interest suffers? Will other states soon follow Florida’s example and pass similar tax cuts and will hundreds of thousands of citizens move to Florida to take advantage of the enormous tax breaks being offered by the Sunshine State?" Paulson asked.
"He has already run for the presidency in 2024 and failed to garner sufficient support in Florida or nationally to achieve his goal. Will his backing of Amendment 3 in Florida be enough to win him the support of Florida voters and voters across the U.S. who are seeking tax relief and put him in the White House? Perhaps," Paulson said.
"But Governor DeSantis is one of the least popular politicians seeking the presidency," he added. "It is difficult to win any political election if the voters do not like you personally. Unfortunately for DeSantis, he is not an easy person to like."
Newsweek contacted DeSantis’ office for comment by email on Tuesday morning, but has not yet received a response.

...
A Costly Trade-Off for Lower Property Tax Bills
Most experts believe the state will not change for the better. While delivering savings on property tax bills for most long-term homeowners in the state, Amendment 3 will cause local governments across Florida to lose billions in revenues.
The drastic reduction in local governments’ budgets could mean that communities will be looking for ways to make up the gap, "either by cutting or eliminating services or raising fees and other assessments to maintain them," Sadaf Knight, CEO of Florida Policy Institute, previously told Newsweek.
"With local governments facing a gaping, $12 billion recurring loss in revenue, attention will turn to non-homesteads like rental units and commercial properties to raise property taxes, meaning a cost shift onto renters, small businesses, and consumers."
J. Edwin Benton, a professor of political science and public administration at the University of South Florida, told Newsweek that Floridians are likely to see cuts to services including police, fire and EMS, street and sidewalk repairs, parks, libraries and recreational programs.
"Anything that’s paid for with property tax revenue," he said. That was the point behind the property tax reform envisioned by DeSantis, Benton said.

...
"The whole purpose was to force local governments to cut back on what the state felt was unnecessary spending on the part of local governments," he said. "Whether or not that’ll work out or not, I don’t know, but what could happen is that local governments—and there’s nothing to prevent them from doing it—might come up with charges for services like EMS coming to your home."
"Police could charge for some of its services, you could pay more for going to museums, parks, other kinds of recreational facilities or public facilities," Benton said. "We could see a wide variety of what I call user fees or payment for services."
The alternative is not much rosier: if they were forced to cut back on basic primary services, the property tax reform would have a "devastating effect" on local governments, Benton said.
"One way or another, we all feel that we have to have emergency medical services, fire, police protection, parks and recreation. So we’ve got to find an alternative way to pay for those."
Florida’s Property Tax Reform Could Make or Break DeSantis’ Candidacy
DeSantis will no longer be in office when the impact of Amendment 3 starts being felt across Florida, shielding him from any potential regret that voters might feel in the future.
But any negative feelings linked to the reform could hurt his aspirations in two years if he seeks the Republican nomination for the presidency as he did back in 2024, Benton said. "It could hurt him politically that he’s the guy that had the idea to do this—and look at the mess that Floridians are in now," he said.
Should Floridians be happy with the way the property tax overhaul turns out, however, it is unclear whether DeSantis would benefit from it. A lot will depend on whether other states will soon follow Florida’s example and pass similar tax cuts, Paulson said, and how the state will handle potentially hundreds of thousands of people moving to Florida to take advantage of the enormous tax breaks being offered by it.
The first question that needs answering, however, is whether DeSantis will run for president again in 2028, though experts believe his ambition leaves him no alternative. "In part, what else is DeSantis going to do? He is term-limited after serving two terms as governor, and his ego, as well as limited options, suggest that a presidential run may be his best option," Paulson said.
"He has played it a little coy, he hasn’t come right out and said that he’s running," Aubrey Jewett, a professor of political science at the University of Central Florida, told Newsweek. "But nor has he said he’s not running. We do know that he is very politically ambitious."
While he believes that there is at least "a reasonable chance" that DeSantis will run for the Republican nomination in 2028, Jewett thinks he is not in a rush to make that announcement.
"I think he’s going to wait a little bit to see what happens with President Trump, to see if President Trump changes the way he governs in his leadership style or not, if the Republican brand improves over the next two years," he said. If the Republican Party remains unpopular among voters, DeSantis is young enough, for a politician, to "wait out another election cycle and then run," Jewett argued.

...
Many have seen his attempt at distancing himself from President Donald Trump after the midterms as a hint that he will seek the Republican nomination, though he said it is "too soon" to talk about 2028.
"I think it’s too soon to tell in terms of, like, you know, who’s going to run," the outgoing governor said on Fox News’s The Faulkner Focus on November 12. "I think we do need to come to grips with what happened in the midterms. I mean, we were losing Georgia, North Carolina, Texas. These are states that traditionally go well for us."
But DeSantis’ name, together with those of Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, is among the most floated around as a possible Trump’s successor in 2028.
"He has long held that dream, and I think that’s what he was doing. He was criticizing. Trump, where in the past he was afraid to do so because Trump had dismissed him as being a serious candidate," Benton said.
Crucially, DeSantis has not ruled out a presidential run. On November 4, he told CNN’s Jake Tapper: "I got some more things I got to do, and I’ll be a free man come January 5th. Not that I’m counting down to that, and then we’ll look to see the landscape."
Ahead of his 2024 presidential campaign, DeSantis built a political argument around what his administration had achieved in Florida, presenting those results as proof that his aggressive conservative governing agenda could be replicated nationally. This time, his track record in the state could prove trickier.
Benton thinks being seen as the architect of Florida’s property tax overhaul could become a political liability for DeSantis, rather than propel a potential presidential bid.
Jewett is more cautious, believing that DeSantis could easily skirt responsibility if the property tax overhaul went wrong.
"Could it end up hurting him? Yeah, it’s possible," he said. "But I think he’s clever enough to claim credit for the part that the Republican voters like and then dodge the blame if anything goes wrong.
"He could say it wasn’t the plan he suggested originally, and he wasn’t the governor overseeing its implementation."
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Matthew Robinson, James Debens and Emma Lee-Sang
Update, 11/20/26 10:39 a.m. ET: this article was updated with expert comment.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines