Housing Could Shape Election in Battleground States

Photo-illustration by Newsweek/Getty/Housing Could Shape Election in Battleground States

Giulia Carbonaro

By Giulia Carbonaro

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Soaring home prices across the U.S. have strained affordability in the country, squeezing many aspiring buyers out of the market and pushing both Vice President Kamala Harris and Donald Trump to promise they'd do something if elected, to lower the cost of purchasing a property.

But climbing prices have meant that millions of homeowners in the country have seen the value of their properties grow in the past few years—an appreciation that might push them to vote for Harris in November, according to a first-of-its-kind study.

In "Housing Performance and the Electorate," a study published in early 2023, researchers analyzed home prices and election results at a nationwide level over each of the last six presidential elections, seeking to find out how the country's "largest asset class, residential real estate" influenced individual voter behavior.

Read More on News

Their initial idea was that homeowners tend to vote for the candidate who supports policies that are perceived as beneficial to their property value. What they found was that homeowners in counties where prices had climbed in the four years before an election were more likely to "vote-switch" to the incumbent party. Counties with poorer price performance, on the other hand, were more likely to vote for the challenging party.

Home price changes were influenced voters' behavior more in swing counties in seven battleground states: including Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin.

Housing Could Shape Election in Battleground States

...

At the time the study was published, it meant that—based on the study's results alone—homeowners in battleground states were more likely to vote for President Joe Biden in November. Now that Biden has withdrawn from the race and Harris has replaced him as the Democratic nominee, this same theory might weigh in favor of the vice president.

"Voters consider their financial circumstances when making decisions at the ballot box," Alan Tidwell, co-author of the 2023 study and associate professor of finance at the University of Alabama, told Newsweek.

"Typically, economic prosperity benefits the incumbent, while economic downturns increase support for the opposition party. Similarly, our findings on house prices suggest that the performance of residential real estate has a real and significant marginal impact on national elections," he added.

"Voters are likely to respond favorably to rising housing prices—and housing equity— attributing these gains to the incumbent candidate and political party," Tidwell explained.

"Both the incumbent candidate, if seeking reelection, and the incumbent party benefit from this effect, though it is more pronounced when the incumbent candidate is on the ballot."

While Harris is not the incumbent, the fact that she has been Biden's vice president for the last four years is still likely to give her an advantage over Trump—at least among homeowners.

The median sale price of a home in the U.S. was $438,837 as of July, according to Redfin data, up from $422,000 a year earlier and $331,000 in January 2021, when Biden was sworn into office.

The 2023 study found that the relationship between home prices and voting behavior was more significant if prices had increased over the last year before a presidential election.

Over the past year, home prices have surged in each of the seven battleground states that Harris and Trump will be fighting over in November. According to Redfin, home prices increased by 2.1 percent year-over-year in July in Arizona, while they were up 3.3 percent in Georgia, 6.4 percent in Michigan, 6 percent in Nevada, 2.2 percent in North Carolina, 5.3 percent in Pennsylvania, and 8.6 percent in Wisconsin.

Happy Homeowners, Unhappy Renters

While homeowners—who make up the majority of voters—might be happy about higher home prices and support the incumbent, buyers and renters might feel very differently.

"Renters, especially those aspiring to purchase a house, may be influenced by affordability concerns, potentially leading to different voting preferences," Tidwell said.

"Housing affordability concerns and the shortage of affordable housing are likely to have a significant role in this year's election, particularly among renters and aspiring first-time homebuyers.

A May analysis by Zillow found that rent prices had increased 1.5 times faster than wages in most major U.S. metropolitan areas in the previous four years. At the national level, rents surged by 30.4 percent while income rose 20.2 percent between 2019 and 2023. As per Zillow's latest data, the median rent for all bedrooms and all property types in the country is currently $2,100, unchanged from last year.

Harris has pledged to lower home prices by addressing the shortage of homes in the U.S. housing market, promising she will build 3 million new homes over four years to fix the existing supply gap if elected president. She also said she would create tax breaks for homebuilders targeting first-time buyers and double the available funding of $40 billion to encourage local governments to remove regulations slowing down new construction.

Trump has not offered many details on what he plans to do if elected to address the current housing affordability crisis, but said that he would stop illegal immigration to reduce demand for homes and free properties for Americans.

Newsweek contacted the Harris' and Trump's 2024 campaigns for comment by email on Sunday morning.

Housing market, U.S.

...

Tidwell believes that "a substantial wave of new construction is necessary to meet growing demand, especially after years of underbuilding that followed the [2008 and 2009] Great Recession and pandemic."

"While plans designed to increase housing supply through new construction activities are oriented toward longer-term solutions, the immediate impact on affordability will take time to materialize and for the population to feel its effect," Tidwell said.

"More short-term measures such as policy initiatives aimed at tax incentives, legislative action, or interest rate cuts could provide quicker relief to renters and potential homebuyers."

It is not yet clear how those policies could affect homeowners and their voting behavior should prices come down, but the effect won't be felt anytime soon. Though there appears to be bipartisan agreement on the need to increase housing inventory and address shelter affordability concerns, Tidwell said, "any policies impacting housing could be juxtaposed across the electorate and resonate differently depending on an individual's position as a renter, buyer, or homeowner."

Still a Wide Open Race

David Wessel, director of the Hutchins Center on Fiscal & Monetary Policy at the Brookings Institution think tank, told Newsweek that, while important, the housing market will be only one of many factors that voters will be considering in November.

"Housing costs are clearly on the minds of a lot of voters—that's why politicians talk so much about housing—but I don't think the outcome of this election will turn on voters comparing the Trump and Harris policy proposals," Wessel said.

"There are bigger issues at stake—the future of democracy, the nature of U.S. alliances, the rule of law, and abortion rights," he added. "There are winners and losers in today's housing market: folks who own a house are enjoying rising prices; folks who want to buy their first house aren't. Given that two-thirds of Americans own their houses, well, you can do the arithmetic."

The latest polls show that the 2024 presidential race is still wide open less than 60 days before election day. Ahead of the first debate between the two candidates on September 10, Harris was ahead in Wisconsin with 49 percent of the vote over Trump's 47 percent, Michigan, 48 percent over Trump's 46 percent, and Pennsylvania 49 percent over 48 percent, according to polling averages compiled by The New York Times.

The two candidates were head-to-head in Arizona, Georgia, Nevada, and North Carolina, each with 48 percent of the vote.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines