House for sale

...

Suzanne Blake

By Suzanne Blake

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A real estate expert is warning that the current housing market needs a "dramatic intervention."

Nick Gerli, the CEO of real estate data platform Reventure App, said that Americans will continue to boycott the housing market even as mortgage rates head lower.

This week, the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage average was at 6.47 percent. That's a whopping 26 basis points below last week's average, marking the biggest drop since last December.

Read More on U.S.

More From Newsweek Vault: Should I Buy a House Now or Wait? How to Determine the Right Time to Get a Mortgage

Despite this, Gerli wrote on X (formerly Twitter) that there "has been no bounce back in homebuyer demand."

House for sale

...

In fact, the weekly mortgage application index came in at 134, down 11 percent from last year.

"American sentiment on home-buying remains at one of the lowest levels of all-time," Gerli wrote.

More From Newsweek Vault: How to Get a Mortgage With No Money Down

Fannie Mae's national housing survey reported that 82 percent of Americans felt it was a bad time to buy last month, which was one of the worst readings in the past 14 years, Gerli said.

In an average year, only 40 percent of Americans usually feel it's a bad time to buy.

"Incrementally low mortgage rates is going to do nothing to change these perceptions," Gerli wrote. "Rather, what's needed is dramatic intervention."

He said mortgage rates down to the 5.5 percent range, plus a 15 percent drop in prices, would be the type of thing needed to bring Americans back into the homebuyer market.

"If rates were to drop to 5.5%, and prices were to fall 15%, the typical monthly mortgage payment for new buyers would fall to $2,100/month," Gerli wrote. "To me - this is the 'sweet spot' where buyer demand would return."

Those hoping that lower mortgage rates are the answer to all the housing market's problems are wrong, Gerli continued.

"Anyone expecting a 'housing boom' from lower mortgage rates is sadly mistaken," Gerli said. "The path forward is a return to normal levels of demand. What we saw in 2017-18. And that's going to take substantial declines in prices, and further declines in rates."

Certain markets are more likely to see a more affordable housing market sooner than others. Gerli said Sun Belt states like Texas, Florida and Tennessee are the most likely places to reach equilibrium first.

"They now have a pile-up of inventory, and historically high price cuts. And values are now starting to drop," Gerli wrote.

Alex Beene, a financial literacy instructor at the University of Tennessee at Martin, echoed Gerli's sentiments, saying much of the excitement around lower interest rates won't fix the larger problem.

"Most financial analysts are saying a drop in interest rates will trigger more home sales, but I don't think it will provide the surge needed to see a healthier market for houses," Beene told Newsweek.

He went on: "Prices are going to have to come down too. The reality for most Americans is that a 1 to 1½ percent drop in interest rates isn't going to equate to a massive difference in most monthly payments, which is the primary reason most are avoiding a purchase at the moment. When a home costs $1,000 more a month in payments than an apartment, you stay a renter."

Alan Chang, a nationwide title and escrow expert, said the larger real estate market is not healthy, with affordability still at an all-time low because of inflated values and higher interest rates.

He told Newsweek that 2% to 3% mortgage interest rates "are not normal but appear to be what much of the market is wanting. This would only drive an unhealthy market, like what we experienced in 2019-2022."

Chang said a healthier mortgage rate between 4 and 5 percent would be much more sustainable, but it's unlikely to happen in 2024 and much of 2025.

"It's a catch-22 here. If everyone is complaining about high interest rates and high home prices, lower interest rates will not help affordability much in the long term," Chang said. "Home affordability can be achieved with adding more inventory and having less demand, not just one part of the problem."

On the sellers' side, homeowners are naturally going to want to get the highest value for their property, Beene said, and the only likely way to get them to move prices down is through months of low sales and little interest.

"If no sudden movement happens on interest rates, you could see that," he said. "This fall and 2025 could certainly produce a better buying opportunity if these pieces fall into place."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines