House for sale sign Florida

...

Chloe Mayer

By Chloe Mayer

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Florida may be heading towards a "big investor selloff" in its housing market as oversupply and lessening demand result in falling rental incomes, according to one expert.

Real estate analyst Nick Gerli, CEO of the property market Reventure App, says that rent cuts are widespread across the Sunshine State following a flurry of apartment complex construction. The increase in supply has resulted in falling demand for homes, which means that rent prices are tumbling in a bid to attract tenants, he says.

Gerli's comments follow a report by real estate brokerage and mortgage service Redfin in October, which suggested that investors are steering clear of Florida's housing market due to hurricane damage, insurance costs, and new safety regulations.

Read More

Florida Home Sales Plunge As Sunshine State Becomes Less Desirable4 min read

Florida Home Sales Plunge As Sunshine State Becomes Less Desirable

Rising Number of Mortgage Applications Reveal Changing Housing Market3 min read

Rising Number of Mortgage Applications Reveal Changing Housing Market

Housing Market Alarm as Homebuyers ‘Most Pessimistic’ They Have Ever Been3 min read

Housing Market Alarm as Homebuyers ‘Most Pessimistic’ They Have Ever Been

But a potential glut of homes being offered for sale in Florida is not likely to impact Americans' pessimistic perceptions of the housing market. In August, a survey revealed that the number of Americans planning to buy a home is at its lowest level in 12 years.

Prices remain stubbornly high and mortgage rates are hovering around the 7 percent mark, meaning homes in many areas of the country are sitting on the shelf for months as they struggle to find a buyer.

House for sale sign Florida

...

Data from Apartmentlist, cited by Gerli, showed the rental downturn in 1- or 2-bed apartments by comparing November 2022 prices with those from November 2024. In Fort Myers, Florida, rents dropped from $1,617 in 2022 down to $1,406 this year; a fall of some 13 percent. Other affected areas include Naples, North Port/Sarasota, and Jacksonville. And even the ever-popular Miami saw rents fall 1.6 percent from $1,825 down to $1,796.

"Don't be surprised if we see a big investor selloff in Florida in 2025 due to these declining rents," Gerli said.

Gerli posted a lengthy thread on social media site X, formerly Twitter, on Saturday outlining his assessment of Florida's housing market as a result of the challenging market for investor-landlords. Hundreds of X users subsequently shared the thread, with several replying to Gerli to tell him about their personal experience of the housing sector.

View this post on X

Newsweek has reached out by email to the Florida Housing Coalition, which describes itself as the state's "leading affordable housing expert on everything from ending homelessness to first-time homeownership."

"Declining rents is very problematic for landlords in Florida, because many bought into the market during the peak of the bubble in 2021-2022. And expected rents to keep growing," Gerli wrote.

"Some investors are already dumping properties in Florida as a result of these declining rents. While rents are dropping, operating expenses are skyrocketing. HOA [homeowners' association] fees for condos, property insurance costs, and taxes have all spiked in the last 2-3 years. Heavily compressing landlord profit margins."

Vacancy rates "are up in every Florida market," he added. He shared a screenshot of Apartmentlist data that suggested vacancy rates stood at 10.18 percent in Fort Myers last month, compared to 4.64 percent back in November 2022. Other areas, such as North Port, showed a similar story. "Once again this is the result of a huge deluge of new apartment (and single-family) supply hitting the market from builders," Gerli said, pointing out that even more new homes are set to be finished in 2025.

Nevertheless, "even with these declines, rents in Florida are still well above pre-pandemic norms," Gerli noted. That means "landlords who bought in Florida prior to the pandemic are still doing well for themselves" by seeing a good return on their investment as homes were "undervalued" from 2008 until 2019.

"But landlords who bought or developed after the pandemic are starting to feel some major distress" and suffer from cash flow problems, he added. And they "stand to lose quite a bit if they bought during the boom when it was overvalued" from between 2020 until the Fall of 2024, he said.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines