Fed up older woman.

...

Lydia Patrick

By Lydia Patrick

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Internet users are divided over a homeowner who is refusing to let their stepmom live in their future new home.

Redditor u/OwlOOIis shared their story on the subreddit "AITAH ('Am I The A*****?')" and quickly sparked debate, receiving over 8,700 upvotes. The user explained how they used their 401(k) retirement savings to put a down payment on a home for their father, 69, who co-owns the property, and his girlfriend, 73.

The dilemma arose when the original poster (OP) revealed their plans to sell the current house and purchase a multigenerational home.

Read More on Life

"They are aging poorly. I wanted to look at selling their house and buying a large multi generational home this year," the Redditor wrote. However, things took a turn when the stepmom misunderstood the situation.

aitah for telling my dads girlfriend the house
r/AITAH

View this post on Reddit

"Dad told me she was freaking out, and I said she can keep freaking out. She apparently thought I was selling their house and leaving them homeless and buying myself a house, and yelled at me through the phone. I could freak out cause 'she wasn't going anywhere,' and after the call made comments about how much rent she has paid and how she deserves something and threatened my dad with or I'll get a lawyer," the OP explained.

Newsweek reached out to u/OwlOOIis via Reddit for comment. We could not verify the details of the case.

The Redditor said that they felt "devastated" by the accusations, noting that they had been a generous landlord by covering the $200 monthly water bill and providing new appliances. When the misunderstanding came to light, the stepmom attempted to move past it without addressing her earlier accusations, according to the OP.

"I realized there was no way I could now share a roof with this person. I gave it a month and then sent her an email explaining I owe her nothing, that's not how rent works, she has no say in the sale or share in the proceeds," the OP wrote.

The Redditor also encouraged the stepmom to reconcile with her own child for future support and informed her that they would no longer be paying the water bill, particularly after buying their father a new truck.

Ultimately, the OP said, the stepmom lashed out, calling the Redditor "evil" and blaming the father for not providing enough details about the house plans. The OP stood firm, saying, "I told her it didn't matter and have a nice life."

Fed up older woman.

...

Experts Weigh In

Psychiatrist Dr. Carole Lieberman discussed the challenges of blending families in such arrangements.

Addressing the Redditor, Lieberman told Newsweek: "First of all, it was probably not a good idea to buy a multigenerational home to include a woman who you describe as 'incredibly negative' and 'full of complaints.' You would have been miserable."

However, she noted the importance of maintaining peace for the father's sake. "She makes him happy, so you need to cut her some slack, even though you are right about how rude and ungrateful she was. It's better to have her be rude and ungrateful in her own home—not yours.

Lieberman also pointed to the fears older individuals face, especially those with limited resources. "Knowing how dependent she is on you, it is terrifying when you are mad at her. Make nice with her, if only to keep your dad happy," she said.

Christina Previte, founder and managing attorney at WOLF Esquires LLC, provided legal insight into the situation.

She told Newsweek: "If OP owns the property with her father, he would have to consent to sell the property, or she would have to file an action to have the court force a sale.

"Stepmom has no rights at all because she's not an owner."

However, Previte added that marital rights could complicate the situation depending on when the property was acquired and how it was maintained.

"Stepmom may have tenant rights though if she's been paying rent. A lot of this depends on the state they are in since property rights are dictated by state law," Previte added.

She also recommended putting any future arrangements in writing to avoid misunderstandings.

Reddit Reacts

Redditors were divided on the issue. One user warned: "Just be careful that your dad doesn't leave her his share of the house. I'm not sure what way the deed was set up, but just check that that can't happen."

Another user said: "If she had been a decent person, the whole thing would've gone differently."

However, some sided with the stepmom and empathized with her fears. "Idk lady is in her 70s and thought she was about to be homeless. It's the not apologizing that's too much," said one user.

Another user wrote: "I think going Scorched Earth on her is the wrong approach. You are basically telling her that when your Dad dies, she will be an old lady living under a bridge. Does your Dad love her? Do you think he will let that happen? He will probably marry her and make sure she inherits his part of whatever you own together."

Newsweek's "What Should I Do?" offers expert advice to readers. If you have a personal dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money and work and your story could be featured on WSID at Newsweek.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines