10

Loading video...

Jordan King

By Jordan King

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A debate has broken out in the U.S. over whether the attacks on Hezbollah members' pagers and walkie-talkies violate international law, and here is what we know so far.

Two consecutive attacks on Hezbollah using exploding pagers and walkie-talkies in Lebanon and Syria killed at least 12 people, including two young children, on Tuesday, and 20 people on Wednesday, with thousands more wounded.

Both strikes are believed to have been carried out by Israel, which is yet to make any official comment.

Read More on News

Several prominent Democrats have spoken out against the attacks, with Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC), the representative for New York's 14th congressional district, calling the pager strike a violation of international humanitarian law.

She wrote on X: "Israel's pager attack in Lebanon detonated thousands of handheld devices across a slew of public spaces, seriously injuring and killing innocent civilians.

"This attack clearly and unequivocally violates international humanitarian law and undermines US efforts to prevent a wider conflict.

"Congress needs a full accounting of the attack, including an answer from the State Department as to whether any US assistance went into the development or deployment of this technology."

View this post on X

Similarly, Ilhan Omar, the representative for Minnesota's 5th congressional district, who said: "Netanyahu's reckless disregard for civilian lives in the pager attack in Lebanon is yet another example of why we need to cut off military aid."

On Thursday, the leader of Hezbollah, Hassan Nasrallah, made the same accusation when he said: "The enemy has crossed all controls, laws and red lines through the bombings."

There are multiple, complicated aspects to consider when determining whether an attack violates international law—and because these strikes still have so many unanswered questions, it is even more difficult to do so.

But two major focuses on social media are about distinction—whether the attacks were carried out against lawful targets and were not indiscriminate—and prohibited use of certain weapons—whether the pagers and walkie-talkies constitute prohibited "booby-traps."

Brian Finucane, a senior adviser with the U.S. Program at the International Crisis Group, wrote about this for the national security online forum Just Security.

On distinction, Finucane explained that the carriers of the pagers and walkie-talkies would have to be "lawful targets, either on the basis of their status as fighters in an organized armed group that is party to a conflict with the attacker, or due to their direct participation in hostilities."

He added that the standard used by the attacker—to determine "direct participation in hostilities" or armed group membership—would come under scrutiny.

For an attack to be classed as indiscriminate, it would have to be asked whether it was directed at a specific military objective or whether it was carried out in a way that "cannot be directed at a specific military objective," Finucane said.

police officer inspects a car

...

John Spencer, Chair of Urban Warfare Studies at the Modern War Institute at West Point, told Newsweek: "By all rational and informed analysis, yes the page/walkie-talkie operation is legal (still not attributed to Israel which matters), from a law of armed conflict (sometimes called international humanitarian law) the operation passes all fundamental laws of war necessity, proportionality, and distinction. It was a very precise sabotage of an enemy piece of equipment used for military purposes."

Another issue Finucane looked at was the prohibited use of certain weapons, asking whether planting explosives in pagers and walkie-talkies constitutes booby-traps, regulated and in some cases prohibited, under Amended Protocol II of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons.

The legislation, which both Israel and Lebanon are parties to, defines a booby trap as a "device or material which is designed, constructed, or adapted to kill or injure, and which functions unexpectedly when a person disturbs or approaches an apparently harmless object or performs an apparently safe act."

It is important to note that this law does not completely ban the use of regular objects as booby traps, as the U.S. Department of Defense confirmed in an understanding previously submitted, saying "the prohibition contained in Article 7(2) of the Amended Mines Protocol does not preclude the expedient adaptation or adaptation in advance of other objects for use as booby-traps or other devices."

Director of the National Jewish Advocacy Center, Mark Goldfeder, addressed this when he responded to AOC's post, arguing: "Communication devices issued by terrorists to terrorists for terrorist purposes do not count as civilian objects."

Hezbollah, officially classed as a terrorist organization in the U.S, has been carrying out cross-border attacks on Israel, seen by many as a way to keep Israel under pressure on multiple fronts in order to help Gaza-based Hamas, also a U.S. designated terrorist group.

Hostilities from Lebanese territory followed the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel, which left more than 1,000 Israelis dead and 250 taken hostage. Israel's counter attack has cost over 40,000 lives in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run Gaza health ministry.

Following evacuations in Northern Israel, which shares a border with Lebanon, the region has now been included in Israel's stated war objectives for the first time since the current conflict began last year. Israel's security Cabinet approved "returning the residents of the north securely to their homes" as an official objective on Monday.

A few days before, on September 12, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said a political statement alone would not achieve this, adding that Israel is "preparing for a broad campaign."

The Israeli Defense Forces said on Thursday: "The IDF is currently striking Hezbollah targets in Lebanon to degrade Hezbollah's terrorist capabilities and infrastructure.

"For decades, Hezbollah has weaponized civilian homes, dug tunnels beneath them and used civilians as human shields—having turned southern Lebanon into a war zone. The IDF is operating to bring security to northern Israel in order to enable the return of residents to their homes and achieve war goals."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines