
...
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Inside a packed University of Michigan lecture hall in early April, veteran Democratic U.S. Representative Debbie Dingell watched Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed campaign with the abrasive far-left streamer Hasan Piker.
"Quite frankly, I haven’t seen that many people outside an event yet this year," Dingell told The Associated Press, while carefully noting that her attendance was not an endorsement of El-Sayed. Or, presumably, Piker.
The evening’s scene looked like the future of Democratic politics: excitable young voters and an anti-establishment energy galvanized by a popular influencer treated as an emergent coalition-builder for the party.
Read More on Analysis
The vibes are froth and fizz. Piker may be a powerful character inside the political internet, with his millions of global followers and ability to drive the conversation on social media, mostly through controversy.
But the reality of Piker’s true influence as the leader of brat leftism is humbling for a man of his ego.
Hasan the Headache
Piker's recent and rapid ascent to political relevance within their party is making many Democrats nervous, creating an internal rift over whether it should associate itself with a character like him.
The latest Piker-sparked furor over Luigi Mangione saw the streamer deploy Marxist "social murder" theory to rationalize why some younger Americans welcomed the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson.
The analysis prompted a familiar backlash against Piker. But this isn't his first rodeo.
Piker has stirred waves of anger for remarks including "America deserved 9/11," that landlords should be killed, that Hamas is "a thousand times better" than Israel, that those who care about Medicare fraud should kill GOP Senator Rick Scott, for making a shocking and profane rant against a Vietnamese refugee—the list goes on.
"This whole Piker discourse has been embarrassing to every person who has tried to make him the spokesman for Democrats," said Neera Tanden, a longtime Democratic consultant and a former senior Biden administration official, on X.
The concern is understandable, as Piker appears on swathes of Democratic-linked podcasts and is courted by progressive candidates.
Piker gives Republicans an unusually vivid caricature to staple onto Democrats—the blood-lusting commie of America's fevered nightmares—who would much rather talk about prices, jobs, health care, and Trump.
And it distracts Democratic attention away from much more important party business, like winning elections: There's a pretty important set of them coming up in November.
Piker's choice words are not those of a thoughtful messenger for a party trying to win suburban House seats. Democrats who pretend he has some kind of mass appeal to an untapped portion of the electorate are asking voters to ignore what the record shows.
The mistake is to confuse offensiveness with importance. Piker's pugnacious style can dominate a podcast cycle, a campaign event, or a cable segment because the internet rewards conflict. And Republicans also have every incentive to make Piker a stand-in for Democrats who have never appeared on his stream.
The trap for Democrats is not that, by ignoring Piker, they lose out on millions of younger voters obediently awaiting their guru's political instructions. It’s that some Democrats may end up spending more time litigating Piker’s persona than selling voters a message that speaks to issues they really care about.
The Brutal Reality of Public Opinion
Piker is certainly not a small figure online. He is one of the world’s most-watched political streamers with more than 3 million Twitch followers alone, not to mention the millions of others who follow him on various other social media platforms.
Every stream is highly engaging and compelling, and his subscribers keenly join in, offering their own views or encouragement, and occasionally jousting with Piker on his own opinions or rhetoric. That he's handsome, stylish and photogenic can't hurt either.
Those kinds of numbers matter for his prominence in livestream culture. They may also help to drum up donors for candidates and issues he supports, or bring them to the attention of the online left.
But they do not automatically translate into an ability to persuade voters writ large, or that Piker is now a household name in the U.S. Piker still, ultimately, operates within a marginal political niche, even if he's loud and rude enough to catch bigger attention.
And this is where there's a brutal reality for Piker, which may offer some comfort to Democrats who want to keep him out of their party: nobody cares.
An April Echelon survey of likely voters found that 60 percent had never heard of Piker. Moreover, 19 percent had heard of him but had no opinion. A further 15 percent viewed him somewhat or very unfavorably. Just 7 percent viewed him favorably.
Among Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents, Echelon found that 51 percent said Piker’s views were "antithetical to what most Democrats believe" and that party leaders should say so.
However, 21 percent did say he reaches new audiences and helps Democrats defeat the MAGA right, though only 9 percent said they "agree with his views, and he's an asset to the Democratic Party." A further 19 percent were "unsure."
That doesn't sound like there's an imminent Piker-led radical takeover of the party and its voters. And it certainly doesn't sound like someone capable of moving the needle with independent voters in an election.
Ask the Right Question
Conventional Democratic communication has plainly failed to reach many younger voters, who have a shared economic-driven dissatisfaction with both major parties, rather than a neat ideological identity that coheres them all together.
Piker's brat leftism is reminiscent of old school punk, so the appeal to young people sick of a status quo that seems to be actively working against their interests is understandable.
They want to kick out at the system and Piker is their steel toe-capped boot. (Even if he is, ironically enough, an affluent nepo baby who got his big media break through his uncle, Cenk Uygur of The Young Turks.)
But within the Democratic Party, Piker's utility is less clear.
Any candidate who seeks Piker as a validator inherits a fight over him instead of their governing priorities. The audience Piker reaches is politically useful at the margins, and may generate cash, but it is dangerous when mistaken for the electorate.
The sober answer for Democrats is neither excommunication theater nor influencer worship, both of which elevate Piker's relevance to a status voters say he doesn’t deserve.
Piker's real power is in attention and distortion. It can make small things look big, but it's a viewpoint easily corrected.
Democrats just need the right perspective. They should ask themselves the same question as the great American public: who the hell even is this guy?
Hey gang, Carlo Versano here. I hope you enjoyed this article. As Newsweek's Director of Politics and Culture and editor of the 1600 newsletter, I'm keen to hear what you think. Now, Newsweek is offering a new service to allow you to communicate directly with me in the form of a text message chat. You can sign up and get a direct line to me, as well as the reporters who work for me. You can shape our coverage.
As a Newsweek member, we're offering this service to you for free. You can sign up below, or read more about how it works here. Let's talk!
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines