Israel, strike, near, aid

...

Tom O'Connor

By Tom O'Connor

Deputy Editor, National Security and Foreign Policy

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A senior Hamas official has accused Israel of putting Palestinian civilians in harm's way by forcing them to collect humanitarian assistance at U.S.-backed sites, only to be faced with deadly force.

Israeli forces have been accused twice in recent days of opening fire on civilians seeking to receive aid being distributed at a site administered by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation near the southern city of Rafah. The foundation was established with United States and Israeli support amid Israel's ongoing blockade of other international humanitarian organizations such as the United Nations, which Israel has accused of failing to prevent Hamas from looting supplies.

Israeli officials have so far denied wrongdoing, but Hamas Political Bureau member and spokesperson Basem Naim argued the incidents were part of a deliberate policy.

Read More on News

"In the context of the ongoing Israeli aggression against the Gaza Strip, the new Israeli mechanism for distributing humanitarian aid serves to intensify policies of starvation and societal targeting, transforming aid into death traps," Naim said in a statement shared with Newsweek on Tuesday.

He asserted that the mechanism being carried out by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation "forces civilians to move toward dangerous military zones in order to access aid, thereby placing their lives at grave risk."

"This policy has led to the martyrdom of no fewer than 75 Palestinian civilians over the past week while attempting to reach aid distribution points," Naim said, "including 27 martyrs in Rafah on June 3 and 31 martyrs in a similar incident on June 1, in addition to dozens of injuries."

Israel, strike, near, aid

...

Conflicting Narratives

The latest incident to occur near a site operated by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation unfolded early Tuesday as Israel Defense Forces (IDF) personnel opened fire near a crowd gathered to collect aid.

The IDF said in a statement that its forces had "identified several suspects moving toward them, deviating from the designated access routes," prompting troops to carry out "warning fire" around half a kilometer from the aid side. Then, "after the suspects failed to retreat, additional shots were directed near a few individual suspects who advanced toward the troops."

"The IDF is aware of reports regarding casualties, and the details of the incident are being looked into," the statement said, adding that "IDF troops are not preventing the arrival of Gazan civilians to the humanitarian aid distribution sites."

BBC News reported Tuesday that the accounts of eyewitnesses, NGO workers and health workers on site appeared to contradict the Israeli narrative of the shooting.

Gaza's Hamas-led Government Media Office reported Tuesday that 27 people were killed and 90 more were injured, bringing the total number of those killed since the aid sites began operations last week to 102 and the number of wounded to 490.

"We condemn in the strongest terms the perpetration of these massacres against starving civilians, and we hold the Israeli occupation fully responsible for these ongoing massacres carried out under the umbrella of 'aid,'" the Government Media Office said, "and we also hold with it the American administration, which supports politically and on the ground this bloody project, directly responsible for the use of food as a weapon in the ongoing war of extermination on Gaza."

The IDF has denied responsibility for Sunday's incident at an aid distribution point in southern Khan Younis, sharing drone footage purporting to show masked Hamas fighters opening fire near the site.

"Hamas is a brutal and murderous terrorist organization that is starving the residents of Gaza," the IDF said in a statement Sunday. "Hamas is doing everything in its power to prevent the successful distribution of food in Gaza."

Tsach Saar, Israel's deputy consul general in New York, backed the Israeli account during an interview with Newsweek on Monday.

"We saw how local gunmen belonging to Hamas, how they were shooting at people, innocent people who came just to collect just food," Saar said. "This is the enemy that we are dealing with."

He accused those attributing blame to the IDF for that incident of perpetuating a "blood libel" against Israel, while acknowledging that Israeli forces have not gone without error throughout the conflict.

"At the end of the day, we are dealing with a very vicious, sophisticated and brutal enemy," Saar said, "and in a war with this kind of an organization that does not care for the well-being of its own people, that loots its own people's food, it's very difficult."

"And of course, mistakes have been made here and there, but the goal is justified, and it should be," he added. "And when innocent people are getting hurt in Gaza, this is a tragedy, not just for the Palestinians, it's also for the Israelis."

International Pressure

The bloodshed at the humanitarian assistance sites have compounded growing pressure faced by Israel over its nearly 20-month campaign in Gaza, sparked by a Hamas-led attack against Israel in October 2023.

Deadly attacks on distraught civilians trying to access the paltry amounts of food aid in Gaza, are unconscionable. For a third day running, people were killed around an aid distribution site run by the "Gaza Humanitarian Foundation". This morning, we have received information that dozens more people were killed and injured.

There must be a prompt and impartial investigation into each of these attacks, and those responsible held to account. Attacks directed against civilians constitute a grave breach of international law, and a war crime.

U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk described called the attacks "unconscionable" and called for "a prompt and impartial investigation into each of these attacks" in a statement delivered Tuesday.

"Attacks directed against civilians constitute a grave breach of international law, and a war crime," Türk said. "Palestinians have been presented the grimmest of choices: die from starvation or risk being killed while trying to access the meagre food that is being made available through Israel's militarized humanitarian assistance mechanism."

"This militarized system endangers lives and violates international standards on aid distribution, as the United Nations has repeatedly warned," he added.

His appeal for an independent probe into the attacks echoed an earlier call issued Monday by U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, who also reiterated a need for a ceasefire put an end to the conflict.

"Israel has clear obligations under international humanitarian law to agree to and facilitate humanitarian aid," Guterres said. "The unimpeded entry of assistance at scale to meet the enormous needs in Gaza must be restored immediately. The UN must be allowed to work in safety and security under conditions of full respect of humanitarian principles."

"I continue to call for an immediate permanent, sustainable ceasefire," he added. "All hostages must be released immediately and unconditionally. This is the only path to ensuring security for all. There is no military solution to the conflict."

U.S. Takes Aim at Media

While the U.N. comments follow a growing chorus of criticism directed at Israel from the international community, including from U.S. allies, over Israel's operations and its restrictions on aid, President Donald Trump's administration has expressed skepticism over media reporting on the issue.

Responding to a reporters' question about the latest deadly incident to unfold near a Gaza Humanitarian Foundation distribution point, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said that the "the administration is aware of those reports, and we are currently looking into the veracity of them because, unfortunately, unlike some in the media, we don't take the word of Hamas as total truth."

"We like to look into it when they speak," she added, "unlike the BBC."

U.S. State Department spokesperson Tammy Bruce also voiced frustration over journalists' questions on the matter during a separate press briefing later that same day.

"After three months of being harangued in this room by many of you about, 'Don't you care about the starving Gazans?' Seven million meals and now we're being harangued about, 'It's not by the right people,'" she said.

Bruce indicated that the U.S. was awaiting the results of the IDF's investigation to understand the details of the killings, noting what she said were the inherent dangers of an active area of conflict.

"Everyone has wanted food and aid to go through into Gaza," Bruce said. "It is a war zone, and different kinds of decisions have to be made. People put their lives at risk to get the aid into those kinds of regions. And this is one of those cases."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines