Democratic Senate candidate Graham Platner speaks in Ogunquit, Maine on October 22, 2025.

...

Andrew Stanton

By Andrew Stanton

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Graham Platner, a Maine Democrat seeking to challenge Republican Senator Susan Collins, was dealt a blow in the latest poll of the battleground race.

Newsweek reached out to spokespersons for Platner, Collins and Governor Janet Mills for comment via email.

Why It Matters

Maine’s Senate race is viewed as one of Democrats’ best pickup opportunities on paper ahead of the 2026 midterms, as Collins is the one Republican representing a state won by former Vice President Kamala Harris last November. However, Collins has proven to be able to win in tough environments in the past, including in 2020, when she won despite former President Joe Biden easily winning the Pine Tree State.

Read More on Politics

Platner has become a favorite among the party’s left flank, but a series of scandals surrounding old Reddit posts and a tattoo appearing to use Nazi imagery have threatened to derail his campaign. He is facing Governor Mills, a more moderate Democrat who has earned the backing of the party establishment, in the primary. A new poll reveals how those scandals have affected his chances against Collins if he were to win the party’s nomination.

What to Know

A new poll conducted on behalf of the Democratic organization EMILYs List—which has endorsed Mills—was made public on Wednesday. It delivered troubling news for the Platner campaign. Most voters in Maine would prefer to reelect Collins over Platner, according to the survey first reported by Politico.

Collins held a nine-point lead over Platner in the poll (51 percent to 42 percent). When respondents were provided more information about Platner’s scandals, Collins’ lead grew to 19 points (57 percent to 38 percent). Collins still led by 14 points after respondents were given a response by Platner (55 percent to 41 percent).

Democratic Senate candidate Graham Platner speaks in Ogunquit, Maine, on October 22, 2025.

...

It surveyed 700 likely voters from October 22 to 27 and had a margin of error of plus or minus 3.7 percentage points.

The poll found that Maine voters would still prefer to vote for Democrats on a generic ballot by a nine-point margin (46 percent to 37 percent), and that Collins’ approval remains underwater, with 54 percent disapproving of her performance and 44 percent giving her positive marks.

Notably, it did not include a question about the hypothetical matchup between Mills and Collins, or the Democratic primary.

Dan Shea, a professor of political science at Colby College, told Newsweek that there “seems to be some stubborn enthusiasm for his candidacy,” but Maine voters are “savvy” and “pragmatic.”

“This squares with what we know about Maine’s no-nonsense electorate,” he said.

Platner is able to get Mainers to turn out, and young voters are particularly invested in his candidacy, but he will continue to deal with concerns about these issues, Shea said.

“The chances of outrunning them are about the same as a warm winter day in northern Maine,” he said.

Mark Brewer, a professor of political science at the University of Maine in Orono, told Newsweek that it’s not surprising to see Collins with a lead over Platner.

“Collins is a multiterm incumbent and these revelations regarding Platner and the other optics around his campaign have been largely negative over the past few weeks,” he said.

Still, it’s not clear that Platner’s chances have completely sunk, noting that he is still drawing large crowds and has lots of supporters. It’s still too early to say whether polls like this could repel some Democrats from his candidacy, he added.

“I suspect that if polling like this becomes a pattern and similar polling shows Mills doing better against Collins, then at least some Democrats supporting Platner might reconsider. We also need to remember that Mills is a relatively popular two term sitting governor,” he said.

James Melcher, a professor of political science at the University of Maine in Farmington, told Newsweek that Platner has lost some supporters and staff but still has a “passionate group of supporters.”

General election voters may be less forgiving, especially after being reminded of them in negative ads. But for now, he still has a strong core in the primary, especially among younger voters, many of whom want a more combative approach against Trump and the Republicans than many Democrats have used up until now,” he said.

Platner draws support from people who don’t care for “traditional politics,” he said. But if Mills has stronger numbers, her campaign will work to “play this up to the voters on the left and middle that want Collins out.”

A second poll of the race, released on Wednesday by the Maine People’s Resource Center, showed Platner with a four-point lead over Collins (45 percent to 41 percent). Mills trailed Collins by four points (46 percent to 42 percent).

It also polled the primary and gave Platner a two-point lead over Mills (41 percent to 39 percent). Jordan Wood, who announced he would run in Maine’s 2nd Congressional District, received five percent support in that poll.

The survey, conducted from October 26 to 29, included 783 Maine voters and had a margin of error of plus or minus 3.5 percentage points.

CNN first reported Platner’s resurfaced Reddit posts on October 16. Posts ranged from identifying as a "communist" to comments about rural white voters.

In a 2020 Reddit thread titled "White people aren’t as racist or stupid as Trump thinks," he responded: "Living in white rural America, I’m afraid to tell you they actually are."

In a second round of resurfaced posts reported by The Bangor Daily News on October 17*,* he reportedly posted a question about Black people not tipping and a post about sexual assault victims. He allegedly wrote that people should "take some responsibility for themselves and not get so f***** up they wind up having sex with someone they don’t mean to?"

He has also faced backlash over his tattoo that resembled the Totenkopf, or "death’s head," a symbol adopted by Nazis.

Platner has apologized for the posts and tattoo. He told the Associated Press he had covered the tattoo and said he was unaware the symbol was linked to Nazism. He told CNN the posts were "very much me f****** around the internet."

What People Are Saying

Dan Shea told Newsweek: "Democrats want to beat Susan Collins. If they have a sense that Platner is flawed—not their absolute best hope of finally knocking her off—they will back Governor Mills. Sure, many of the more progressive young voters will stick with him until the end, but that group doesn't decide Democratic primary elections in Maine. It's older women, middle-aged teachers, suburban dads, savvy business owners, and old-school liberals."

Pollster Adam Carlson raised concerns about the poll on X: "If you’re an org backing Mills trying to push a narrative that Platner is unelectable with hard numbers, sorry but you’re gonna have to show your work."

Maine State Representative Laurel Libby, a Republican, wrote on X: "You mean Mainers don't want an avowed Communist as their Senator?"

Zeteo Politics Editor Andrew Perez wrote on X: "Mills and her allies are trying to end Platner’s grassroots campaign without doing any actual work. So far, there is little sign of a Mills Senate campaign in Maine. EMILY’s List for some reason didn’t bother to include Mills in this poll."

What Happens Next

Candidates will spend the coming months making their cases to Mainers about why they are the strongest candidates in the Senate race. Forecasters like the Cook Political Report and Sabato’s Crystal Ball classify the race as a pure toss-up.

Update 11/12/25, 12:54 p.m. ET: This article was updated with comment from Mark Brewer and James Melcher.

Update 11/12/25, 5:39 p.m. ET: This article was updated with comment from Dan Shea and additional information.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines