BEIJING, CHINA:  TO GO WITH STORY “CHINA-MUSIC-PIANO-EDUCATION” A young girl plays the piano at the Aiyue Piano Kindergarten in Daxing on the outskirts of Beijing, 16 March 2005. Parents who put their children into the school are keen to see quick returns for their investment, and want children to learn as much and as quickly as possible.    AFP PHOTO/Peter PARKS  (Photo credit should read PETER PARKS/AFP via Getty Images)

...

Anna Rahmanan

By Anna Rahmanan

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Every morning, my oldest daughter asks me what she’s doing after school. Her question is warranted because she is currently signed up for an after-school activity Monday through Thursday.

On Tuesday, I responded “dance” because that is the day she takes two back-to-back hip-hop classes. She smiled at me and pointed out that she never has time for playdates—which, to her, don’t qualify as traditional after-school activities, but to her working mother, they certainly do. She wasn’t upset when she said that, though. She seemed to delight in the fact that she was the busiest 7-year-old she knew.

A few hours later, my lovely coworker Jenni Fink, she of Mildly Maternal fame, started chatting with me about what else? Mildly maternal things. We were discussing the maximum acceptable size of the “boo baskets” we’re already seeing around—a classic case of American extra-ism, as I had noted—when Jenni mentioned something she’d seen on Instagram about parents being burned out from trying to make every day extra special for their children. Another case of American extra-ism.

Read More on Life

"Meanwhile, I spent my childhood running errands with my mom and had a great time," Jenni said to me.

And, of course, the idea for this week’s parenting piece arrived because it has been very clear to me—and even clearer to my bank account—that America has a problem with after-schools. It got me thinking, how many after-schools are too many after-schools?

I can speak for myself when I tell you why my daughters are currently in two basketball classes, two dance classes, Hebrew school and tennis, and why I would love to have them start piano, but alas, there are only seven days in a week.

I want them to be well-rounded, sure, but I also want them to be able to make educated choices when they’re teenagers about what actually interests them, and I want to provide them with as much fodder as possible to make those decisions once the teenage years hit. You don’t know you hate tennis until you’ve played tennis, right? You don’t know you love piano until somebody makes you sit at one. You don’t know you have absolutely no interest in basketball until your parents have already paid for the semester. If I don’t force them to try everything now, how can I expect them to try things when they’re too busy thinking of boys or friends' drama?

Related Story

The Slow Death of College

The Slow Death of College

Of course, the fact that an after-school activity innately requires my kids to be outside of the house helps me out, but let me tell you that the thousands of dollars I spend on those programs I also would happily instead spend on the new pair of Chanel shoes that, anyway, I can’t find anywhere.

And the money is only half it. I spend much of my afternoons picking up and dropping off and then picking up again and dropping off again, I then have a harder time doing homework with them because they’re exhausted from all the enriching I have so thoughtfully arranged for them.

All that being said, my oldest daughter is happy to do these things. She comes home smiling. When I see her properly dribbling a basketball or watch her at her dance recital at the end of the year, smiling alongside her friends, it obviously makes it worth it.

I’m not sure her little sister will have the same reaction to such a packed schedule—and I guess that’s the point. We need to follow their lead. Well, first we need to guide them so they follow our lead, and then, at some mysterious point, trade places and follow theirs. Parenting!

But this whole conversation obviously led Jenni and me to the one true question underneath all of it. Do our kids need to learn how to be bored?

I can’t answer for the general population, but I can answer for my own kids: Yes. They need to learn how to be bored, and it is an important lesson we have to teach them. But perhaps they only need to learn how to be bored one day a week.

Meaning: It’s OK not to have an after-school every single day.

I should say that I also don’t particularly approve of the word “bored” in my own life. If I have time when I’m not doing something immediately important—like working or raising my kids—I don’t sit there and announce that I’m bored. I find something else to do. I go for a walk. I read. I call someone. I go to a museum. I wander around a store and buy something I absolutely did not need. I become obsessed with Zoe Saldana and the latest season of The Lioness or perhaps I finally start watching The West Wing. There is always something to do, and I know those things are there because at some point in my life, someone showed them to me.

And maybe that is the argument for after-schools that gets lost amid all the chauffeuring and scheduling and thousands of dollars and the low-level suspicion that modern parents have somehow turned childhood into an extracurricular arms race.

The point of all these activities isn’t, or at least shouldn’t be, to make sure our children never experience an unoccupied hour. It is to give them a catalog of things they might someday choose to do with an unoccupied hour.

Maybe you send your kid to tennis so that one day, when nobody has scheduled anything for her and nobody is entertaining her and she has an entire Saturday afternoon staring her in the face, she thinks: I could go hit a ball. That’s fine.

So, yes, I think children need to be bored. I just think we may have to teach them how. Clearly, in 2026, even boredom requires lessons.

For more on parenting, health and lifestyle, subscribe to The Good Life newsletter here.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines