
...

By Anna Rahmanan
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Among the many traditions I was indirectly asked to adopt when I moved from Italy to America, Thanksgiving is, without question, the most redeeming.
I couldn't care less about football, so the world does not stop turning for me on Super Bowl Sunday (although the halftime show is a spectacle I insist my daughters watch with me). The Fourth of July is lovely, of course, but mostly because who doesn't appreciate a day off in the middle of summer, preferably near a pool, with something delicious on the grill? Halloween? Fun for the kids, certainly, although I still find the American obsession with decorating one's entire front lawn with skeletons a little bewildering.
But Thanksgiving? Oh, Thanksgiving. I absolutely adore it.
Read More on Holidays
And I think I love it so much precisely because I wasn't raised here.
You see, I am a practicing Jew, and while I am fortunate to live among people of different faiths who respect my traditions and wish me a happy new year on Rosh Hashanah, there is always a distinction. They are wonderfully respectful of my celebrations, but they aren't celebrating with me. And that's perfectly natural, of course, but the difference is there. Palpable, even.
The reverse is equally true at Christmas. I love the lights! The trees! The elaborate decorations! I happily wish everyone a Merry Christmas and admire the sheer enthusiasm with which Americans transform their homes into winter wonderlands. But Christmas isn't my holiday. I enjoy it from the outside, as a delighted spectator.
And then comes Thanksgiving, a holiday that somehow belongs to all of us.
Related Story

Jesus Is Back. Can He End America’s Political Holy War?
Christians, Jews, Muslims, Hindus, atheists, agnostics. People whose families arrived generations ago and people who, like me, came here as adults, carrying their own customs, recipes, accents and memories. For one glorious Thursday in November, we can all participate in the same celebration, without having to explain what we believe, what we observe or why we do things differently.
And what is the centerpiece of this marvelous exercise in togetherness?
A fabulous, extravagant, banquet-style meal.
I grew up in Italy, where food is practically a love language, where meals are meant to last, where gathering around a table is as much about the conversation as it is about what is being served. And being Jewish only reinforces that instinct. From Shabbat dinners to holiday feasts, so much of Jewish life happens around a table, preferably one overflowing with food and people who have plenty to say. So imagine my delight at discovering that America had invented an entire holiday around the concept!
There is the turkey, of course (full disclosure: I do not eat turkey), and the stuffing, the mashed potatoes, the cranberry sauce, the pies, the second helpings, the inevitable Jewish addition to the menu and the glorious excess of it all. And the best part? No need to ask God for a sweet new year, as we do on Rosh Hashanah, or apologize for all the terrible things I most definitely did the year before, as on Yom Kippur. No religious obligations, no prescribed prayers, no particular faith required. Just a day to say thank you to the universe, to God, or to whatever higher power you believe in, for the family around the table and the food piled high upon it. How wonderful is that?
Being a mother adds another layer to it all.
I want my kids to grow up deeply connected to their Jewish identity, proud of our traditions and comfortable being different. But I also want them to experience the joy of belonging to something bigger, something shared with their friends, neighbors and classmates, regardless of religion.
Thanksgiving gives us exactly that.
Of course, the holiday's history is more complicated than the cheerful story often taught to children, and that deserves acknowledgment. But the tradition I have come to cherish is the one we create around our own tables each November.
A day when the invitation is simple. Come hungry, bring something and stay.
Perhaps it's the Italian Jew in me, perhaps it's the immigrant in me, or perhaps it's simply the mother in me who loves seeing people gathered around a table, eating too much and talking over one another.
Whatever it is, I am so very grateful America gave me Thanksgiving.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines