10

Loading video...

Shane Croucher

By Shane Croucher

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


California Gov. Gavin Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass have faced sharp criticism from their opponents and some residents over their preparations for and handling of the devastating wildfires gripping the state.

Now, there is talk of both Democrats facing potential recalls as their political opponents seek to capitalize on the upset over the fires, and questions about the state and city's management of vegetation, water supply, and fire budgets.

Izzy Gardon, director of communications for Newsom, told Newsweek in a statement: "The Governor is focused on protecting people, not playing politics, and making sure firefighters have all the resources they need."

Read More on Politics

Nathan Click, a spokesperson for Newsom, added that "the same group of far-right activists have launched six different recall attempts against the governor since he's taken office, each of which have failed spectacularly."

Click continued: "Even Republican Party leaders have criticized these repeated attempts as a brazen campaign finance 'grift,' and the recall organizers have been sued by their own donors for pocketing funds raised previously."

Zach Seidl, a spokesperson for Bass, told Newsweek in a statement she "is leading our city through one of the worst crises in our history. Hurricane-force winds and unseasonably dry conditions drove these firestorms—misinformation surrounding this crisis has been staggering."

Seidl continued: "Mayor Bass issued a sweeping executive order last night to clear the way to rebuild homes fast and that will do everything she can to get Angelenos back home. She has secured the federal, state, and local resources we need to continue fighting these fires and is moving forward on an all-of-the-above plan for recovery."

Newsweek has emailed Bass's office for comment.

A recall fight would be a first for Bass, who had to cut short her trip to Ghana in Africa when the fires broke out. But this is familiar territory for Newsom, who has successfully fended off previous efforts to recall him.

Newsweek asked some of those in the know on Californian politics if they thought Newsom and Bass would face recall elections and, if so, how likely each is to survive them. Here's what they said.

Gavin Newsom and Karen Bass

...

Bruce E. Cain: Karen Bass Faces a Big Problem

The recall process and direct democracy in California have long been professionalized and taken over by money.

The Republican party and wealthy interests pulled this recall move on Gavin during the pandemic, capitalizing on frustration over public schools being closed.

With money you can pretty much start a recall against an opponent whenever the timing seems right.

Even if it fails, attacks like this will excite the MAGA base and distract attention away from the Congressional fights within the Republican ranks over tariffs, budget, and the like.

Urban fires fall more under the jurisdiction of mayors so pinning this on Gavin is a bit of a long shot unless there is some smoking guns connection, which I have not seen yet.

The problem for the Republicans is that a MAGA candidate has no chance in this state, and we ask voters to both recall the governor and replace him/her at the same time. My money would be on his survival at the moment.

They have a better shot with Mayor Bass as there are more moderate and credible candidates who could replace her.

That said, this was an unprecedented fire with 100 mph winds. No one in California would have been prepared for that.

However, cutting firefighting resources and being out of town when the danger had been known for days are not good looks, whether or not they mattered to the disaster in the end.

Powerful and famous people losing their homes is a big problem for her. Their voices are much more prominent than hers, and sympathy for the victims will be high.

Bruce E. Cain is a professor of political science at Stanford University and director of the Bill Lane Center for the American West.

Garry South: Shocked if Bass Survives a Recall

Republicans in California are so impotent, all they can do is howl at the moon—and try to initiate recalls. Newsom handily beat the recall in 2021, and the latest attempt fizzled altogether and didn't even make ballot.

Californians are not in the mood for more of this silliness, and Newsom has done a superb job of marshaling state and federal resources to fight the fires—even from Canada and Mexico.

Bass made a huge mistake by being out of the country—in Africa, in fact—when the fires broke out, despite public warnings before she left that we were in extreme fire danger.

Since she rushed back, she has seemed like little more than a bit player, behind the curve and on the defense.

Newsom, a former mayor himself, has seemed more like the mayor of Los Angeles during this disaster than she has. I would be shocked if she survives the inevitable recall attempt.

Garry South is principal of Garry South Consulting and a Democratic strategist in California.

Kenneth Fire in West Hills LA

...

Chris Hoene: Recall System Needs Fixing

Gov. Newsom has already faced at least two recall efforts (only one succeeded in going to the ballot, and failed).

The governor's detractors may try again, but the governor is termed out at the end of 2026, so it doesn't seem to make much sense and would be a large waste of private (via the interests involved) and public (if an election were needed) resources.

In terms of why, the reality is that it's easier to win a recall election with a small minority of voters than it is to win a statewide election during a normal election cycle.

The system really needs to be fixed, because a minority of voters in a small turnout recall election should not be able to overturn the wishes of a much larger majority that voted someone into office during the normal, larger turnout election cycle.

The only question we should be asking right now is what aid and assistance do local leaders in the LA region need in order to respond to the crisis at hand and protect and care for Los Angelenos.

High winds and fire danger remain major threats and a host of the most threatening fires are still not contained.

The people who have lost homes, who are evacuated and don't know what lies ahead, and the communities that are struggling to navigate through all of the emergency, economic, and social upheaval that comes with these disasters deserve better than politicians and political interests immediately turning to questions of how they can gain from the situation.

What we need most right now is a "we're all in this together" response from everyone.

Chris Hoene is executive director of the California Budget & Policy Center.

Paul Mitchell: Fires Give Bass's Opponents a Big Weapon—But No Recall

A Newsom recall "effort" is inevitable as there is a little cottage industry of consultants and activists who have continually done petitions and raised money and used these efforts as a kind of a gift.

We all know of the one actual recall election in 2021, but there were six other "attempts" in the last five years—the most recent failed just a few months ago.

So, will there be another one? Of course. Will it get the signatures to qualify? Of course not. In fact the 2021 recall wasn't started as a real attempt to qualify, they just stumbled into COVID complaints and got extensions that allowed them to.

When the recall was started it was for completely other reasons—and mostly grift.

As for Karen Bass, I also presume someone will pull recall papers, but she isn't going to be recalled. The fires have given her opponents a big weapon, but in the mid to long term they will find that voters don't want to turn a natural disaster into a recall of their mayor.

And who in her place? Rick Caruso who used private firefighters and diminishing public water to save his own properties?

Maybe there will be issues here for a re-election, but they won't cause a recall.

Paul Mitchell is a Democratic strategist in California and vice president of Political Data Inc.

Updated, 1/16/25, 08:50 a.m. ET: Language around cuts to firefighting resources was clarified.

Updated, 1/17/25, 02:50 a.m. ET: A statement from Bass's spokesperson was added.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines