A flag reading “We are” and featuring a map of the Falkland Islands is displayed on the stands ahead of the Argentine Professional Football League 2026 Apertura tournament match between River Plate and Boca Juniors at the Mas Monumental stadium in Buenos Aires on April 19, 2026. (Photo by JUAN MABROMATA / AFP via Getty Images)

...

Bradley Martin

By Bradley Martin

Executive Director, Near East Center for Strategic Studies

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


King Charles III and Queen Camilla’s state visit to the United States concluded with Secretary of State Marco Rubio dismissing proposals to ‘review’ the United Kingdom’s claim to the Falkland Islands. Controversy erupted after a leaked internal Pentagon email suggested the U.S. was punishing the U.K. over the latter’s lack of support for the Iran war.

The Falklands are a group of islands disputed between the U.K. and Argentina, located 300 miles east of Argentina with a population of around 3,600.

The roots of the Falklands dispute stretch to the mid-18th century, when the U.K. withdrew from the islands following a power struggle with Spain. After declaring independence from Spain in 1816, Argentina moved quickly to claim sovereignty and set up a settlement. However, in 1833, the British reasserted control, expelled the Argentine settlers, and turned the Falklands into a formal British colony.

Read More on Opinion

In 1982, Argentina’s military dictatorship, headed by Lieutenant General Leopoldo Galtieri, launched a surprise invasion to reclaim the Falklands. After a fierce but brief undeclared war lasting just 10 weeks, Argentine forces surrendered to the British. The conflict left around 900 people dead: 649 Argentines, 255 British personnel, and three Falkland Islanders. The islands have since remained under British sovereignty as an Overseas Territory.

Dominion over the Falkland Islands remains a live and contentious issue. During an interview with the digital channel Neura Media, Argentine President Javier Milei declared that his government is exerting every possible effort to recover the territory, which Argentina calls the Islas Malvinas.

A flag reading "We are" and featuring a map of the Falkland Islands is displayed on the stands ahead of the Argentine Professional Football League 2026 Apertura tournament match between River Plate and Boca Juniors at the Mas Monumental stadium in Buenos Aires on April 19, 2026.

...

“Sovereignty is nonnegotiable, but it must be handled judiciously with brains,” Milei said. British Prime Minister Keir Starmer expressed his country’s disapproval of Argentina’s claim and reiterated that the U.K.’s position remains “unchanged.”

Starmer has yet to explain why British sovereignty should be unquestionably honored when it comes to the Falklands, but not when it comes to the Chagos Islands, where he recently shelved his deal to hand over sovereignty of the British-held archipelago to Mauritius and pay an estimated £101M ($136M) a year to lease back a joint U.K.-U.S. military base.

This double standard becomes clearer when viewed through his selective use of international law against Israel. Last year, he announced Britain’s recognition of a Palestinian state in the West Bank (what Israel calls Judea and Samaria), Gaza Strip, and East Jerusalem, even as the final status of these territories continues to be fiercely contested by Israel. Starmer has yet to explain why the U.K. maintains sovereignty over Northern Ireland, despite claims by Irish nationalists, or Gibraltar, despite it being claimed by Spain.

Yet, the U.K. hardly holds a monopoly on this anti-Israel hypocrisy.

Spain, since 1815, has occupied the municipality of Olivenza, despite it being claimed by Portugal. The last remains of the Spanish Empire continue to exist with the plazas de soberanía and the cities of Ceuta and Melilla, despite these areas being claimed by Morocco as its sovereign land. In 2017, the Spanish government crushed the wishes of 90 percent of Catalans who voted in favor of independence by arresting and imprisoning Catalan independence leader Jordi Sànchez.

France’s selective moral stance is evident in its quick recognition of a Palestinian state alongside its continued colonial footprint.

Paris still controls 13 overseas territories globally and exerts considerable financial sway over former African colonies via the CFA franc monetary system. This system forced 14 newly independent African countries to keep half their foreign reserves in the French treasury—an arrangement former President Jacques Chirac described as boosting French banks while draining resources and growth potential from those nations.

Despite European objections, Israel has a strong legal basis to apply sovereignty over these territories under the international doctrine of uti possidetis juris. This principle holds that a newly independent state inherits the borders of the last highest-level administrative unit in the region. In this context, Israel is reclaiming East Jerusalem and the West Bank (areas seized and occupied by Jordan during Israel’s 1948 War of Independence). Far from annexing foreign land, Israel is simply extending its sovereign rights over its historic heartland.

The Falklands debate has ripped the mask off Europe’s sanctimonious posture toward Israel. It is not rooted in consistent international law or impartial principles but rather stands as a stark testament to unpleasant truths about convenient double standards and a diversion from the continent’s colonial history.

Bradley Martin is the Executive Director of the Near East Center for Strategic Studies. Follow him on Facebook and X @ByBradleyMartin

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines