
...

By Anna Rahmanan
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The most disturbing possibility about Friday's nationwide aviation shutdown is that the Federal Aviation Administration is telling the truth.
According to Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, the November 13 disruption began when a contractor performing routine maintenance at a remote facility installed equipment that overwhelmed the nation's aging air traffic control network. Within hours, the FAA had suspended departures nationwide.
The government has found no evidence of a cyberattack. Turns out, ordinary maintenance proved quite sufficient.
Read More on Analysis
Which leaves us in the peculiar position of almost hoping the government is concealing something. A sophisticated cyberattack would at least suggest that bringing American aviation to a standstill required considerable expertise and a determined adversary capable of overcoming formidable defenses. The official explanation suggests that the system could be overwhelmed by people whose only intention was to keep it running.
It's unsettling to think that a national emergency of such large proportion is tied to such an innocuous explanation. If a hostile foreign power had managed to shut down American aviation, the country would rightly demand to know how its defenses had been breached. But if the FAA's account is accurate, the real question is what those defenses were capable of preventing in the first place.
The FAA's preliminary findings trace the disruption to excessive network traffic potentially originating at facilities in Texas and Arkansas. Contractor L3Harris had been installing a router at the Arkansas site. The resulting instability spread to 17 of the country's 22 air traffic control centers.
Related Story

Jesus Is Back. Can He End America’s Political Holy War?
The network was receiving roughly 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds. Communications and radar feeds became unreliable, prompting the FAA to halt departures while approximately 3,500 aircraft already airborne landed safely.
The investigation will eventually establish what went wrong with the equipment, but identifying the malfunction is only part of the answer. Why did the system allow the disturbance to spread across so much of the country?
An adversary seeking to disrupt American aviation might have considerably less work to do than previously assumed. The apparent vulnerability suggests that overwhelming a shared network could achieve effects that might otherwise require penetrating multiple control centers.
And the cyber threat is becoming more capable as artificial intelligence gives attackers new ways to automate complex operations.
France recently accused Iranian military hackers of sabotaging refrigeration systems at roughly 700 supermarkets, an allegation Iran denies. There is no established connection between that attack and AI, but the episode illustrates how cyber operations can disrupt ordinary physical infrastructure.
Of course, the incident does not establish that an outside attacker could reproduce the failure. The contractor had authorized access and the precise technical conditions remain uncertain. A vulnerability accessible to maintenance personnel may be inaccessible to hostile actors (or so we hope).
The Government Accountability Office reported in September that more than 75 percent of the FAA's 138 air traffic control systems had previously been classified as unsustainable or potentially unsustainable. Modernization is overdue, although Friday's events suggest that even upgrading the equipment requires considerable care.
To the FAA's credit, the shutdown was precautionary. Aircraft already airborne landed safely and suspending departures when communications became unreliable was the responsible decision. The safety procedures appear to have worked. Hurrah?
Yet an adversary seeking economic disruption would hardly object to the FAA exercising caution. If someone could deliberately trigger comparable failures, forcing repeated shutdowns might accomplish the intended damage without putting a single aircraft directly at risk.
The investigation may establish that Friday's malfunction depended on an unusual combination of circumstances that an outsider could never reproduce. Such a finding would offer genuine reassurance. It would also make the distinction between an isolated accident and an exploitable weakness considerably clearer.
For now, the FAA's account offers little reassurance about how well the network could withstand a deliberate attempt to disrupt it. The government says no one attacked it. We may eventually wish that were the explanation.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines