
...

By Jack Royston
Chief Royal Correspondent
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor, the former prince, has won a lawsuit against police over searches of his homes as part of an investigation into Jeffrey Epstein-related allegations.
Thames Valley police acknowledged that the search warrants at Marsh Farm and Royal Lodge were unlawful, the High Court in London heard on Thursday.
Police on Thursday said it was a decision taken by the Central Criminal Court, usually referred to in Britain as the Old Bailey, that led to the warrants being quashed. There are legal proceedings ongoing that could mean the evidence will continue to be useable as part of their investigation.
Read More on News
To sign up for Newsweek's The Royal Report newsletter, click here.

...
Why It Matters
Mountbatten-Windsor was arrested in February on suspicion of misconduct in public office following emails contained in the Epstein files, which had been recently released by the U.S. Department of Justice.
He had been accused in the media of leaking confidential trade documents and investment opportunities to Epstein in 2010. At the time, Mountbatten-Windsor was a U.K. trade envoy and Epstein had been convicted in 2008 of soliciting prostitution from a minor.
Separately, Virginia Giuffre said she was sexually assaulted by Mountbatten-Windsor after being trafficked for sex by Epstein in 2001. Mountbatten-Windsor has always denied Epstein-related wrongdoing and her allegations were not part of the police investigation.
Related Story

King Charles’ Authority Is Under Threat From Andrew Lawsuit
Thames Valley Police Respond to Ruling
Mountbatten-Windsor filed for a "judicial review" of the decision to grant the search warrants and a hearing took place in private on Thursday. The judge in the case, Nicholas Hilliard, told the High Court: “The fact that the search warrants were quashed does not bring the investigation to an end or mean that the whole of the investigation is unlawful.”
The warrants were issued by the recorder of London, Mark Lucraft KC, according to The Guardian. Police said officers had done all they could to ensure that the court had all the information needed and said it was the court's decision that was incorrect.
Mountbatten-Windsor filed his judicial review in May and it was in July that the police acknowledged the warrants had been issued under the wrong piece of statute.
A Thames Valley Police spokesperson said in a statement to Newsweek: “On 22 July, the High Court quashed search warrants granted on 18 February 2026 for two properties in Norfolk and Berkshire that were searched as part of Thames Valley Police’s ongoing investigation into misconduct in public office by a man in his 60s from Norfolk.
“The agreement that led to the quashing of the warrants relates specifically to a decision made by the court regarding the legal basis for these and is not a judgement on our ongoing investigation.
“We ensured the court was presented with all the necessary information and paperwork to inform their decision, following the correct legal processes throughout.
“We accept the position that the initial court’s decision to issue warrants under the specific piece of legislation used was incorrect and therefore these must be legally quashed."
What Happens Next
Thames Valley Police have applied to retain the evidence gathered and Mountbatten-Windsor's legal team have indicated they will contest that application, which is to be heard in 2027.
In his judgment, seen by Newsweek, Hilliard said: "It is agreed that a lawful warrant could only have been issued if the criteria under different provisions...had been met."
Hilliard said the relevant law "gives a judge the power to say that someone who is in possession of property as a result of an unlawful search warrant [here TVP] can still retain the property if it would be lawful to seize the property under some other provision once it was returned to the owner [here Mr. Mountbatten-Windsor].
"There would be little point in handing property back if it could then simply be lawfully seized under some other provision."
Mark Stephens, of U.K. law firm Howard Kennedy, told Newsweek that the police may yet be able to use the material, which according to Thursday's judgment includes documentary evidence and electronic devices.
"The issue is what happens to the information and in the U.K., the fruits of an unlawful warrant are usually permitted to be used," Stephens said. "If they're probative of guilt or exculpation they won't be excluded. It's very different in America.
"I think it's quite important that because this was a warrant that could have been lawfully exercised, it's really a technical win, and when the judge is looking at [it], they're going to say you may technically have got it wrong but it wouldn't have made any substantive difference so we are going to have the evidence anyway."
Police will retain the material while they wait for the High Court to decide what should happen to it.
“Legal proceedings are currently ongoing to decide how material seized during the searches will be managed and whether we can lawfully retain it in support of our ongoing investigation," the police statement said.
“Our investigation into alleged misconduct in public office by a man in his 60s from Norfolk remains ongoing, and we continue to pursue all reasonable lines of enquiry to effectively and fairly progress this investigation."
Error That Led to the Lawsuit
Hilliard explained the error in his judgment: "It is a condition for the grant of a warrant under s.8(1)(d) of PACE [the Police and Criminal Evidence Act] that the judge is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the material sought does not include items subject to legal privilege or which constitute what is called Special Procedure material.
"Special Procedure material includes material which is in the possession of a person who acquired or created it in the course of any trade, business, profession or other occupation or for the purpose of any paid or unpaid office and who holds it subject to an express or implied undertaking to hold it in confidence."
However, the investigation related to Mountbatten-Windsor's time as a trade envoy and he was accused of leaking confidential information to Epstein.
The judgment read: "The presence of material subject to legal privilege was expressly envisaged in the application for the search warrants and because it was inherent in the nature of the alleged offences under investigation, misconduct in public office, that the material was likely to be in the possession of a person, namely Mr. Mountbatten-Windsor, who had acquired or created it in circumstances which would make it Special Procedure material."
The judgment suggests that the parties agreed that the warrants would have been lawful had they been issued under section nine and schedule one of the same act.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: John Fitzpatrick and Dave Siminoff.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines