
...

By Mark L. Zyla
Managing director of Zyla Valuation Advisors
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Artificial intelligence has become the default answer to almost every business problem. Boards are racing to adopt it, investors expect it, and every industry is asking how AI will reshape the future. Yet amid that excitement, one question receives far less attention: are we still measuring value with frameworks built for an economy that no longer exists?
I believe that is the real issue. Valuation is not falling behind because technology is inadequate. It is falling behind because the foundations on which it relies have failed to keep pace with the modern economy.
That disconnect has become increasingly difficult to ignore. Across global markets, the pace of change has been relentless. Economic volatility, geopolitical shifts, and the rapid expansion of private capital have reshaped how businesses operate and how value is created. Private markets now play a significantly larger role in capital formation, with companies staying private longer and reducing the availability of public market data that has traditionally informed valuation benchmarks
Read More on Opinion
At the same time, intangible assets, intellectual property, brand equity, data, and human capital have become the dominant drivers of enterprise value. Research shows that intangible assets now account for more than 90 percent of the S&P 500’s market value, a dramatic shift from previous decades.

...
Yet valuation has not evolved at the same pace. Many of today’s methodologies remain anchored in an economy dominated by tangible assets, predictable cash flows, and transparent public markets. We are using yesterday’s models to value tomorrow’s businesses. The result is not just imprecision; it is inconsistency, opacity, and increasing reliance on assumptions that vary widely across markets and practitioners.
In periods of heightened uncertainty, those assumptions matter even more. Small differences in inputs can lead to materially different conclusions, particularly when valuing assets that lack clear cash flow profiles or comparable benchmarks. This is where the illusion of precision becomes dangerous. Valuation often appears to be a technical exercise, but at its core, it is an opinion. It requires judgment, context, and an understanding of risks that cannot be fully captured in a dataset.
This is precisely why artificial intelligence, for all its promise, cannot solve the problem.
AI is a powerful tool. It can process vast amounts of information, identify patterns, and improve efficiency in data gathering and analysis. But it cannot form an opinion of value. It cannot weigh qualitative factors, interpret incomplete information, or make informed judgments in the face of uncertainty. As I have often said, valuation ultimately comes down to an informed opinion, and AI does not have one.
The shift toward intangible assets only amplifies this challenge. In today’s economy, a company’s value increasingly resides in assets that are difficult to measure, protect, and even define. Intellectual property, proprietary technology, brand reputation, and human capital do not sit neatly on a balance sheet. In many cases, as I have observed, a company’s value effectively walks out the door every evening with its employees. Capturing and sustaining that value requires a fundamentally different approach than valuing physical assets like factories or inventory, yet many of the frameworks still in use were designed for precisely those tangible inputs.
This misalignment becomes even more pronounced in the context of private markets. As capital continues to shift away from public exchanges, the availability of transparent, standardized data declines. With fewer disclosure requirements and less publicly accessible information, valuations increasingly depend on internal assumptions and limited comparables. Recent research highlights how the growing "retailization" of private markets and the expansion of semi-liquid fund structures are driving demand for more frequent, timely, and accurate valuations, while simultaneously intensifying scrutiny around governance and transparency.
At the same time, reduced transparency introduces a compounding effect. When consistent valuation benchmarks are lacking, uncertainty for investors and stakeholders increases, and the margin for error widens. What may appear to be minor differences in assumptions can lead to materially different conclusions, making it more difficult to assess value accurately and consistently across transactions.
Overlaying all of this is the persistent lack of global standardization in valuation practices. While organizations such as the International Valuation Standards Council have made progress, valuation frameworks remain fragmented and largely localized. Different markets operate under varying assumptions, levels of data availability, and regulatory expectations. In an increasingly interconnected global economy, this inconsistency does more than complicate comparisons; it undermines transparency, erodes trust, and introduces systemic risk that is often underestimated.
We have seen the consequences of these dynamics before. During the 2007-2008 financial crisis, the widespread use of complex and opaque financial instruments, such as mortgage-backed securities and collateralized debt obligations, made it extremely difficult to assess underlying risk and value consistently.
Research from the IMF highlights how the crisis was amplified by the widespread use of complex and opaque financial instruments and the inability of markets to accurately price them, contributing to systemic instability. In practice, this led to significant mispricing across markets, where risks were underestimated and valuation models failed to reflect reality. While today’s environment is different, the underlying risks, lack of transparency, inconsistent methodologies, and heavy reliance on assumptions remain strikingly similar.
If these issues persist, the implications extend beyond individual transactions. Information asymmetry increases when one party has a better understanding of value than another. Investor confidence erodes when valuations cannot be compared or trusted. Markets become more fragile when transparency is limited, and inconsistencies go unchecked. These are not theoretical risks; they are structural vulnerabilities that can affect the stability of the broader financial system.
Digital assets offer a clear example of where current valuation frameworks struggle. Many of these assets lack traditional cash flows or intrinsic value indicators, and regulatory clarity is still evolving. As a result, valuations can vary widely, reflecting not just differences in data but differences in interpretation. This highlights a broader issue: our frameworks are not equipped to handle assets that do not fit conventional models.
The conversation around AI often distracts from these deeper structural challenges. It is easier to believe that better technology will fix the problem than to confront the need for fundamental change. But valuation is not a technical issue; it is a strategic one. It requires a rethinking of how we define, measure, and communicate value in a world where the drivers of that value have fundamentally shifted.
Businesses, investors, and advisers must recognize that the risks embedded in today’s valuation practices are not always visible. They are often hidden within assumptions, inconsistencies, and gaps in transparency. Addressing these risks will require more than adopting new tools. It will require adapting frameworks, improving global consistency, and acknowledging the inherently opinion-led nature of valuation.
We are operating in a new economic reality, whether we acknowledge it or not. If the way we measure value does not evolve with it, the consequences will not be limited to inaccurate valuations; they will extend to trust, stability, and the integrity of markets themselves.
AI will almost certainly make valuation faster. But speed is not the same as sound judgment. Until valuation frameworks evolve to reflect an economy driven by intangible assets, private capital, and increasing uncertainty, better technology will simply produce faster answers to the wrong questions. Before asking AI to reinvent valuation, we first need to rethink what and how we are trying to measure.
Mark L. Zyla is the managing director of Zyla Valuation Advisors and a recognized expert in valuation and fair value measurements. A former chairman of the International Valuation Standards Council’s Standards Review Board, he has decades of experience advising companies, auditors, and regulators on complex valuation matters. Zyla also serves as a lecturer in finance at the McCombs School of Business at the University of Texas at Austin and is a thought leader focused on the evolving challenges of valuing intangible assets and navigating global market inconsistencies.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines