
...

By Jasmine Laws
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is looking to change the reporting requirements companies followed from 2011 to 2022, which include exemptions for certain carcinogenic chemicals. They're accepting public comments for 45 days following the announcement.
The proposed change, announced on Monday, would loosen the reporting requirements manufacturers face when disclosing their use of perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), a group of chemicals the International Agency for Research on Cancer classified as a Group 1 human carcinogen.
The EPA told Newsweek that it is "not rolling back any regulations on PFAS, and this proposal does not change any regulations related to future PFAS production."
Read More on News
"The rule that EPA is amending is a reporting rule that requires one-time reporting of PFAS manufactured or imported in any year between 2011 and 2022," the agency added.
Why It Matters
The new proposed rule follows a series of rollbacks the EPA is hoping to implement, both regarding PFAS and other harmful chemicals more broadly.
In September, the agency asked the U.S. Court of Appeals to reverse regulatory standards in place for three PFAS chemicals—PFHxS, PFNA, and HFPO-DA—meaning that companies would no longer have to ensure they are under the current maximum contaminant level.
This came despite a series of releases of EPA data revealing that millions of Americans are currently drinking water contaminated with the chemicals, and research more broadly highlighting the harm PFAS chemicals can do to public health.
Last month, the EPA also proposed a new rule, meaning toxic chemicals under the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA)—which includes asbestos, formaldehyde, mercury and lead—would be evaluated based on their use in certain conditions, potentially allowing them to be used in situations the EPA deems safe.

...
What To Know
This latest rule proposed by the EPA would reduce "regulatory reporting burdens" and provide "greater regulatory certainty to industry, resulting in a net reduction in cost while ensuring that EPA receives the PFAS data that are most relevant to the agency," the agency said in its press release.
The Biden administration EPA previously tried to close a loophole in 2023 that allowed companies to avoid reporting when they used PFAS chemicals in production, but Trump's EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin said that this rule would have "imposed crushing regulatory burdens and nearly $1 billion in implementation costs on American businesses."
The agency said it was looking to implement the change to minimize the costs of compliance for smaller companies, to avoid "unnecessary or duplicative reporting" and other factors, and Zeldin said it would "combat PFAS contamination without placing ridiculous requirements on manufacturers, especially the small businesses that drive our country’s economy."
The rule would mean that companies no longer have to disclose when they use PFAS chemicals in mixtures or products at concentrations of 0.1 percent or lower, as well as in any imported products, certain byproducts, impurities, research and development chemicals and non-isolated intermediates.
The move has prompted significant concern among environmentalists and experts who are familiar with the widespread impact the chemicals can have on public health.
Scott Faber, senior vice president of Government Affairs at the non-profit organization Environmental Working Group, told Newsweek that the law was "creating loopholes for chemical companies."
He added that this is "what happens when you put chemical industry lobbyists in charge of the EPA. Industry claims to support 'responsible production, use and management' of PFAS, but the people charged with protecting us from toxic forever chemicals can’t make good decisions when we hide the truth about how PFAS is used."
Phil Brown, the director of the Social Science Environmental Health Research Institute at Northeastern University, told Newsweek that the "most alarming" aspect of this proposed rule is the exemption from reporting for imported products.
"In a world-wide economy with intertwining supply chains, many from countries with little or no regulatory control, this is a blanket acceptance of massive PFAS contamination," he said.
He also said that the exempted small firms—which are companies with revenues less than $120 million—are "not 'small' firms and indeed may be contributing to PFAS exposure."
Additionally, he said it is important to note that PFAS chemicals are "toxic in extremely low concentrations," something the EPA itself decided in its 2019 health advisory levels, so the exemption for mixtures or products with a PFAS concentration of 0.1 percent or less "ignores the fact that millions of pounds of total production volume would yield high amounts of PFAS at any level."
The exemption regarding byproducts, impurities, and non-isolated intermediates is also "very troublesome," Brown said, as "we know that various types of PFAS degrade and transform into other PFAS, and such exemptions will empower chemical manufacturers to avoid existing regulations."
Proposing to eliminate reporting requirements for all research and development chemical production is also "alarming," he said, "since the public will never know about corporations’ creation of new replacement chemicals, which have traditionally been very problematic as attempts to skirt existing regulations."
He pointed to Depont and Chemours’ production of GenX PFAS chemicals as examples.
What People Are Saying
Phil Brown, the director of the Social Science Environmental Health Research Institute at Northeastern University, told Newsweek: "As with all its attacks on chemical regulation, EPA cites 'regulatory overreach' and costs to business, but does not address costs to people in terms of the many diseases linked to PFAS. This series of exemptions is part of EPA’s suite of PFAS de-regulation that includes approving PFAS-laden pesticides and retracting some of its maximum contaminant levels (MCLs) that were the result of years of careful research and policymaking."
Jonathan Kalmuss-Katz, senior attorney at Earthjustice, told Newsweek: "If we’re going to protect the millions of people who are exposed to dangerous levels of PFAS in their homes and their communities, the first thing we need to know is where those chemicals are coming from and how they’re being used. EPA’s proposed rollback of the PFAS reporting rule would suppress that very information, allowing companies to hide the PFAS they import in widely used products or manufacture and release within the United States.”
He added: "These changes would leave the public in the dark, denying consumers, state regulators, and impacted communities information about a highly toxic class of chemicals. In the end, eliminating reporting on PFAS manufacturing and imports will only result in more PFAS exposures and increased risks of cancer, developmental harm, and other severe health effects."
The EPA told Newsweek: "The Biden Administration rule requires a small business to know whether and in what level PFAS might have been present in a printer imported into the U.S. in 2013. The agency recognizes that most companies would be unable to provide this kind of information, therefore removing imported articles from reporting requirements removes a significant regulatory burden. By exempting all imported articles, the percentage of PFAS information collected drops to about 2-3 percent of the PFAS information collected compared to the original rule. The informational benefits are not anticipated to be significantly reduced by the proposed rule because EPA expects that the article importers would be least likely to report information. The proposed rule accomplishes this while reducing the cost to industry by between $786 million and $843 million from the previous rule, which delivers on Administrator Zeldin’s promise to “implement section 8(a)7 to smartly collect necessary information, as Congress envisioned and consistent with TSCA, without overburdening small businesses and article importers."
What Happens Next
The EPA has said it will be accepting comments on the proposed changes for 45 days following the announcement in docket #EPA-HQ-OPPT-2020-0549 on www.regulations.gov.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines